George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor.
In 2016 the Essex Town government spent over $2 million renovating its administrative office building at 81 Main St. in Essex Junction. Relations between the town and village were good, the building was run down, and it seemed like a smart investment.
Seven years later – and two years after village-town separation – the Town is understandably planning to relocate its offices to the Essex Town Center which means they’ll be looking to sell their 81 Main St. building which means – given the glut of commercial properties on the market – they’re likely to only get a fraction of their investment back, providing they can find a buyer interested in a government office building with a vault.
Let’s change frames a moment and look at the Essex Westford School District where we see that the superintendent and school administration are operating out of rented second-floor office space at the Post Office Square shopping center on Pearl St in Essex Junction. While this is a great arrangement for the shopping mall owner, it’s not the most accessible, reasonable, nor sustainable location for the administrative and supervisory services of the state’s largest school district.
You can see where I’m going with this but the details bear mentioning.
Moving the EWSD administration out of the shopping center and into 81 Main St. would put school staff in a newly renovated space designed for public accessibility that’s within a stone’s throw of the Essex Education Center campus. Its parking lot would be exclusively for school business and its spacious, tech-friendly public meeting room would fit nicely with the EWSD board’s desire to improve public engagement.
Making the right move might seem like a no-brainer, but here’s the problem: getting the three local elected boards – school board, selectboard, and city council – to collaborate.
The school district has expressed interest in 81 Main, which suggests they see it as a good fit. They’re aiming to have a community conversation about buildings and infrastructure next year, but more pressing needs may arise than administrative office space. A final decision could be years off.
In the meantime, the Essex Selectboard set the clock ticking on building new administrative offices with their recent $3 million purchase of land in the Town center.
The Essex Junction City Council acquired the right of first refusal on 81 Main as part of the City-Town separation agreement, so nothing can happen without their involvement. They’re swimming in infrastructure projects right now and have no immediate plans for 81 Main, but it’s nice to have options. And even if they waive their option and the building is sold privately, the city benefits by having the building’s tax value added to its grand list. Having the school district take ownership would keep it off the city’s tax rolls.
Let’s talk about money.
Government buildings aren’t cheap. City and Town taxpayers are already paying down a $7 million, 20-year bond for the Essex Police facility, and Town taxpayers will soon be looking at multi-million-dollar expenditures for new municipal facilities in the Town Center. The city and town may be separate now, but they fund the same school district, so any small financial gain that either side achieves from the private sale of 81 Main must be weighed against the significant tax increases all sides will see if they wind up having to pay for a new school administration building in three or four years.
The EWSD staff wants to have a community conversation about buildings. Knowing how dedicated they are to their mission, it’s a safe bet they’ll put their students’ needs ahead of their own, which is normally how it should be.
But strategic thinking sometimes requires community leaders to set aside their usual ways of doing business and take a more aggressive, carpe diem approach to things. Sometimes outcomes are more important than processes.
Maybe 81 Main wouldn’t be a good fit for the school district. Maybe it’s not large enough for future growth. Maybe it wouldn’t work for some other reason. But why not find out now, and if it does work, plan accordingly? If someone in local government has a better idea for 81 Main, let’s hear it now so we can compare. Let’s make a deal that benefits everyone.
Columns are opinion pieces regularly contributed by a select group of writers. Columns reflect the opinions of the writer and do not represent the views of the Essex Reporter.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here