Column: Can AI make City Councilors smarter?

Posted

George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor.

With concert season now upon us here in Essex Junction, my thoughts drift fondly back to the many hours I and my fellow Trustees/City Councilors spent reflecting on the excruciating minutia of sound waivers for the Champlain Valley Exposition.

It was painful in ways I can’t describe. You had to be there.

In simple terms: CVE’s concerts often exceed Essex Junction’s sound ordinance. And so, Essex Junction waives the ordinance specifically for CVE a certain number of times each year, which helps CVE fulfill part of its non-profit, arts and culture mission.

This also brings the city a nice chunk of change from its local sales tax on tickets and refreshments, particularly during the Champlain Valley Fair. Plus, CVE provides the city lots of perks, like letting it use its facilities for elections and fire department training.

It would be a cozy relationship were it not for the several thousand or so city residents within earshot of CVE, some of whom are totally cool with the noise, some are iffy about it, and some detest every ordinance-exceeding decibel.

As elected officials in charge of waivers, our job was to find that magical sweet spot where everyone left angry.

I’m joking of course, but that’s what it felt like. It wasn’t fun.

The problem preceded my time in Essex Junction government and continues to this day. CVE currently gets 20 waivers per year, but they would like to eventually increase the number of concerts they host to help pay for renovating their ancient grandstand.

The waiver issue caused a ruckus on the city council this year and, like Arnold Schwarzenegger, it will most assuredly be back.

Therefore, immersed as we now are in AI hype, I decided to ask ChatGPT to provide us waiver-conflicted city dwellers some advice.

AI chatbots being precociously chatty, I had to edit much of what was said. But here’s a trimmed-down version of our actual conversation.

Me: If you were on the city council, how would you handle the waiver question?

ChatGPT: Municipal problems are often messy but solvable with the right approach.

Me: Agreed about the messy part. Do you think we should just hold a city-wide sound waiver vote? Isn’t that the fairest thing to do?

ChatGPT: Holding a yes-no vote guarantees a polarized, unsatisfying outcome. This is really a governance and tradeoff problem: quality of life vs. cultural/economic activity. The solution should reflect that complexity.

Me: Okay, so there’s no easy way around it. And you’re right about the polarizing vote being unsatisfactory. Let’s hear your approach.

ChatGPT: First, saying that “some people are bothered by the noise, and some people aren’t” isn’t a good basis for making policy. Try to map out complaints geographically and temporally. Survey residents with distance-based analysis.

Me: That might be tough to do, as in expensive.

ChatGPT: You could try a managed impact framework. Don’t just count the waivers. Count total noise exposure and differentiate between low, medium, high impact events. That way, the question becomes “how much impact is acceptable?” rather than just “how many concerts?”

Me: Cool idea. So, like Noah Kahan would be a low impact event and a Twisted Sister Comeback Tour would be high impact?

ChatGPT: Not really. The artist name isn’t a good proxy for “impact.” A Noah Kahan show could be lower impact than a Twisted Sister show in some cases, but either could be “high impact” depending on the variables that actually drive neighborhood sound exposure.

Me: I was kidding. The problem is that many people just don’t like the noise, regardless of who’s playing and how many decibels it is over the sound limit.

ChatGPT: If people feel acknowledged rather than ignored, opposition often softens.

Me: Good point.

ChatGPT: Right now, nearby residents are carrying the burden for a citywide amenity. Compensate the people who bear the cost.

Me: For example?

ChatGPT: A community benefit fund paid by CVE (a ticket surcharge for example). Or property tax abatements or rebates for the most affected zones. Free or discounted tickets for nearby residents (sounds small, but it changes sentiment).

Me: Okay. The tax abatement-rebate thing probably wouldn’t fly, but the other ideas are interesting. But can we circle back to the economic activity vs quality of life question you mentioned?

ChatGPT: Ultimately, this is a values decision. Is the city prioritizing being a regional entertainment hub or prioritizing residential quiet and predictability? There’s no neutral answer. The city council should say clearly what balance they’re choosing—and why—rather than pretending everyone can be fully satisfied.

My final thoughts: All joking aside, I’m humbled. The machine deduced the philosophical nub of the problem. It’s one of those untidy human values things we need to figure out on our own, and we can’t pretend there are perfect solutions, even with machines helping us.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here