George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor.
The Champlain Valley Expo wants the Essex Junction City Council to give them 15 more waivers annually to stage outdoor events that might, and probably will, violate the city’s sound ordinance.
The council should grant CVE’s request, but with some serious strings attached. Before I discuss the strings, a little background is needed.
CVE owns 130 acres of land between Pearl Street and Route 2A. Its facilities and parking lots occupy only a portion of the property, the rest is mostly undeveloped. Yet it pays no property taxes to the city or school district because of its non-profit status. To compensate, CVE bends over backwards to make its facilities available at little or no cost for a range of charitable and governmental events – things like the Essex High School graduation, Relay for Life, city and school elections, pandemic immunizations (hopefully no more), and National Guard Deployments.
CVE also gives the city an annual $15 thousand payment in lieu of taxes, and the additional revenue it provides through Essex Junction’s local sales tax, as well as the residual benefits to other local businesses, is likely many times more than that. CVE pays all the policing and public safety costs of their events.
If CVE suddenly stopped making its facilities available for charitable and government functions and simply wrote the city a bigger check, I suspect the city would not spend the money on building a large indoor exposition center. And so, all those charities and community events would need to go someplace a lot less desirable and accommodating. Sometimes a payment in kind is better than cash.
But CVE has been financially treading water since the pandemic, which is why they’ve come to City Council hat in hand to ask for more sound waivers. They believe the revenue they take in from staging an additional 15 money-making events each year would provide enough extra income to finance a sorely needed upgrade of their outdated and increasingly ramshackle grandstand.
The prospect of more noise emanating from the fairgrounds has prompted many city residents to object to CVE’s request and ask City Council why Essex Junction has a noise ordinance if CVE is routinely allowed to break it.
Beneath the public debates about noise mitigation, sound barriers, traffic congestion, and property taxes, the real problem is that because of the unpredictable nature of its business, CVE is averse to taking on long term debt. Instead, it has proposed a plan for financing the upgrade of its grandstand that requires putting the Essex Junction City Council in the hot seat.
CVE operates as a kind of autonomous public enterprise because of its non-profit status as an educational- agricultural venue. Its vision is regional. Its board and corporate officers include state officials and business leaders who may not grasp how big an ask they’re dropping on the City Council’s shoulders. Local officials don’t appreciate having to explain why some folks can violate ordinances while others can’t.
City Council has a right to do some asking of its own: Where are we going here, CVE? Will you be wanting more sound waivers next year? Is holding more and more outdoor concerts your only strategy for funding capital improvements? And while we’re at it, what is your long-term vision and how does it align with the City’s community development goals? What’s your plan for the vast swath of tax-free acreage you own, a small portion of which could be developed to provide much needed housing that would bring in much needed tax revenue? And, please, let’s not hear about the sacred inviolability of CVE’s deeded property holdings and non-profit status. The Essex Junction City Council is quite adept at expunging ancient charters and statutes that have outlived their purpose. Anything written by humans can be revised by other humans. See Essex Junction-Essex Town separation.
Most city residents I know, including myself, appreciate CVE’s community-mindedness and value the contribution they make to our northwestern Vermont culture. It’s a unique asset that many other Vermont communities would love to have. But its location in the middle of a growing city poses some unique challenges, and their leadership needs to understand this. Fifteen extra outdoor concerts a year is pushing things.
Because CVE anchors so much business activity for Pearl Street, and because of the sales tax revenue it generates, and because of all the community benefits it provides, the City Council should grant CVE’s waiver request so it can move forward with its grandstand upgrade.
But if CVE wants Essex Junction to make these kinds of concessions, then it’s reasonable for City Council to tell CVE that it’s time for them to seriously start thinking outside the box about creative ways to strengthen their bond with the local community.
Columns are opinion pieces regularly contributed by a select group of writers. Columns reflect the opinions of the writer and do not represent the views of the Essex Reporter.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here