We did the research

Posted

We heard dire warnings by some opposed to the creation of a unified recreation district. “Do the research about special taxing districts,” they told us.

We did the research. Here’s what we found.

The source of the stories about runaway taxes and loss of accountability is a report called “Out of Sight: How Special Taxing Districts Circumvent Spending Limits and Decrease Accountability in Government” by Stephen Slivinski of the Goldwater Institute.

Turns out, the report has nothing to do with the new recreation district being proposed for Essex. Here’s why:

Goldwater – Cities and towns create special taxing districts to circumvent debt or spending limits imposed on them by the state.

Reality – Vermont doesn’t impose debt or spending limits on cities and towns. That concern is irrelevant.

Goldwater – Cities and towns create taxing districts to shift the responsibility of operating a service out of their budgets. Their budgets don’t go down; they simply use the unspent money for other purposes.

Reality – The cost of running recreation would be deducted from the Essex Town budget. Essex’s general fund tax rate would go down.

Goldwater – Once created, special taxing districts tend to have ever-increasing tax rates.

Reality – Essex Jct. Recreation and Parks, which already funds itself like a special taxing district and serves as the model for the new unified program, has had a stable tax rate for 10 years.

Goldwater – Special districts often levy wildly different tax rates among their member communities.

Reality – The Essex Community Recreation District would be legally required to have a single tax rate.

Goldwater – Special districts tend to deliver lower quality services than municipal services.

Reality – The proposed mission statement of the recreation district requires delivery of the same service levels provided by the two recreation departments today. EJRP, funded as a special district for over 15 years, has some of the most popular and successful recreation programs in the state.

Goldwater – Few special taxing districts are audited to prevent fraud.

Reality – The Essex recreation district would undergo annual, independent audits reported to the public.

Goldwater – Elections for special districts are often timed for low turnout so leaders and budgets go unchallenged.

Reality – The vote to establish the Essex recreation district is required by state election law to be held on December 13. Thereafter, all votes will be timed for Town Meeting Day. Members of the governing board would be elected to serve fixed terms, as with all other governing boards in Essex, and their elections would also be timed to occur on Town Meeting Day.

Other discrepancies

Most of the taxing districts mentioned in the report were designed to provide a service or regulate a facility serving millions of people over large geographic areas. Their budgets were typically in the hundreds of millions of dollars. The Essex recreation district would serve the Essex community; its budget would be about the same as what we collectively spend on recreation now.

Opponents have also claimed special taxing districts are unusual in New England. In fact, all New England states have many taxing districts; all except Vermont have recreation districts. For Essex, we need look no further than the Union 46 School District (Essex High School), Chittenden Solid Waste District, and the tri-town (Williston, Essex, Essex Jct.) wastewater district for local examples of union districts that have provided excellent, financially-stable services for many years. The Essex community has a very successful track record participating in special taxing districts that all residents pay into and that have not resulted in widely varying, rapidly increasing and unaccounted for spending.

The Goldwater report recommends precautions for communities wishing to establish special taxing districts. What’s interesting is that the proposed agreement already includes them. The district’s opponents fail to mention that fact.

The village trustees, town selectboard and prudential committee all voted to approve the unified recreation district agreement in concept and will entrust the final decision to voters. Fourteen of 15 elected officials approved the concept based on research and citizen input. The single dissenting vote among all three elected boards has been the source of most of the opposition to the district.

As you think about how you’ll vote on this issue, remember opposing opinions are very important, but what’s more important is the accuracy of the information on which you base your vote. The Recreation Governance Study Committee will share in a timely way accurate, clear, understandable information answering the many questions voters have.

We ask that you, the voters, also “do your research,” check your facts and consider your sources.

Elaine Sopchak is a Village Trustee. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here