Column: The unifying spirit of Bennington Battle Day

Posted

George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor. Reach him at gatyle@gmail.com. 

America might not be celebrating its 250th anniversary this year had a brief but shockingly decisive skirmish between German mercenaries and New England militiamen that occurred on August 16, 1777 turned out differently. 

The Battle of Bennington, as we now know it, was actually fought on a wooded hillside along the Walloomsac River in New York, a few miles west of the Vermont border. It left British General “Gentleman Johny” Burgoyne’s invading “Canada Army” blind, starving and undermanned as it stumbled into its fateful encounter with Benedict Arnold and the American Northern Army a few weeks later at Saratoga.

If you’re a bit shaky on your U.S. history, it was America’s dramatic victory at Saratoga that persuaded French King Louis XVI to openly support the American cause at a crucial moment when the war’s outcome was in the balance. 

The details are straight out of a Mel Gibson movie.

Burgoyne had intended to crush the rebellion by separating New England’s radicals and firebrands from the rest of the colonies whom, the British Crown believed, were more loyalist inclined.

In Montreal, Burgoyne assembled an invasion army of roughly 4,000 British regulars, 3,000 German mercenaries, 2,000 loyalists and hundreds of Native American warriors to act as guides and shock troops. In June 1777, they sailed south on Lake Champlain with the aim of landing at Fort Ticonderoga and marching inland toward Albany. At the same time, British General Howe’s army in New York City was to march north, up the Hudson Valley to Albany, effectively cutting New England off from the rest of the colonies.

Burgoyne’s host quickly drove the American blocking force from Ticonderoga. But as the British and their mercenaries moved away from the lake, their pace slowed and their supplies dwindled faster than they could restock them. The narrow trails through the Adirondack foothills were not like the open European roads which proper armies were used to.

As they neared Fort Edward, New York, Burgoyne learned of abundant supplies of horses, fodder and food under light guard in the village of Bennington, just across the border in the newly declared Republic of Vermont.

He dispatched a force of about 1,000 soldiers, mostly German dragoons, supplemented by loyalists and Iroquois warriors, to seize the supplies. 

Burgoyne’s arrogance numbed him to the fact that his invasion, with his mercenaries and warriors wreaking havoc on civilians, had enraged hundreds of militiamen farmers and woodsmen throughout the Connecticut River Valley, who picked up their hunting long-guns, much more accurate and deadly than army muskets, and headed to Bennington, to join regular troops from New Hampshire and the Green Mountain Boys, veterans of several Revolutionary War battles, whose spirited leader, Ethan Allen, had been captured earlier in a raid on Montreal and imprisoned in England.

Heading up this impromptu New England army of roughly 2,500 soldiers was General John Stark of New Hampshire, a no-nonsense tactician who’d survived capture and torture in the French and Indian War and hand-to-hand fighting at Bunker Hill. 

The Germans and their allies were only alerted to their danger as they approached the Vermont border. They sent for reinforcements and dug themselves into defensive positions above the river, thinking they were safe. They weren’t.

The Americans had moved stealthily through the woods until they were almost on top of the German lines.  Stark ordered the attack at 3 p.m. By 5 p.m. it was over, with 207 German, loyalist, and Iroquois dead and 750 captured. American losses were about 30 dead and 40 wounded.

Burgoyne suffered not only a significant loss of manpower, but his army got none of the supplies they desperately needed. Worse, most of the Native Americans he’d recruited quit the campaign, disgusted by the loss of 70 fellow warriors and British incompetence. Gone were the eyes and ears Burgoyne needed to track the Americans’ movements. 

I think of this battle, rightly commemorated as a Vermont state holiday, and I think of our fellow Vermonters currently deployed to the Middle East in National Guard units, and I think of the strong, humble spirit that still characterizes the people of this state. 

I didn’t appreciate Bennington Battle Day when I first moved to Vermont. Back then, many of the stores closed. State and local government offices closing was bad enough, but stores closing was inconvenient!

Now I get it. You need to live here a while to understand. It’s our own secular holiday that honors Vermont’s faithful, patriotic spirit. The details of the battle help us remember.

In a time of divisive national politics over who the “real” Americans are, Vermonters never think of asking themselves that question because we all share the same pride in our little state’s outsized contribution to America’s freedom. In sharing, we know who the real Americans are: All of us.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here