As a radical, lunatic environmentalist, it pains me to say that the prolonged slap upside the head that the climate-environmental movement is receiving from the Trump administration was as foreseeable as it is depressing.
Conservation and environmental protection inevitably require regulating human activities, which is why environmentalists naturally align themselves with the Democrats who, as the party of change, are more inclined to approve and impose regulatory legislation.
Nowhere has this easy alliance been more successful than in Vermont where, for decades, the Democrat-dominated House and Senate have been willing enablers and generators of cutting-edge environmental legislation.
But success, locally and nationally, has come at the cost of politicizing a grave problem that should, but tragically doesn’t, transcend political ideologies. Climate change has become solidly identified as a “liberal” issue.
And so now that the political winds have blown a radically conservative Republican administration into office, all of us lunatic environmentalists must watch from the sidelines as years of hard-fought environmental regulations are gleefully dismantled, with far reaching consequences both nationally and in Vermont. Paying the price, as it were, for putting all the chips in one basket.
Even if Democrats take back control of Congress come November, most regulatory agencies are under Executive control, and Trump’s Justice Department has made it clear they have no intention of aggressively enforcing whatever remaining climate and environmental rules survive Trump’s onslaught.
This won’t be over soon.
Rather than being consumed by outrage, or paralyzed by despair, Vermont’s environmental activists should analyze this disaster with the same scientific dispassion they apply to things like atmospheric chemistry and ecosystem impacts.
The hard problem they need to solve is how to make environmental rules more bullet-proof and less exposed to the violent crosswinds of national politics. In other words, how do we get more bipartisan support? How do we depoliticize the climate movement?
If it can be done, I think the answer might look something like Rural Vermont Rising, a grassroots movement of “Farmers, families, Democrats, Republicans – united by our love for our land.”
Rural Vermont Rising began as a collective online response to Act 181, which the Vermont Legislature passed in 2024 to address the state’s housing shortage and stagnant growth. Act 181 aimed to roll back Act 250’s cumbersome land development rules while, at the same time, adhering to its underlying doctrine of preserving Vermont’s native environment by continuing to constrain growth in rural areas.
We applauded this idea in the Essex and Essex Junction governments because it validated our longstanding strategy of concentrating development in our already existing community centers.
But what was good policy for Chittenden County, and other developed areas, was tone deaf policy for Vermont’s rural and agricultural communities, who rightly felt the state was overlooking their economic development needs in pursuit of an ideological vision.
In their own words, RVR “… sprang spontaneously from every corner of Vermont in response to the regulatory overreach of Act 181, identifying it as a top-down restriction of land and property rights that threatens farmers, businesses, and families.”
They correctly point out that the “true stewards of Vermont’s landscape live and work on the land itself.” They appreciate the state’s conservation efforts; they would just like to have a bigger say in how those efforts are formulated.
What they don’t want is to be siloed as reactionary, anti-regulatory, anti-science, climate deniers. They’re none of those things. They understand what’s at stake, perhaps even more than many environmental activists who have little experience with actually living and working off the land.
A statewide, politically diverse grassroots movement like RVR can carry a lot of clout in Montpelier, but it can also be easily fractured by the hyperreactivity of social media, which is why RVR’s online organizers actively promote patient, non-reactive dialogue among members, and avoidance of wearing party affiliations on one’s sleeves.
It’s a tricky balancing act, but it’s also a smart way to sustain and expand a space where liberals and conservatives can listen to each other constructively and find common ground.
You could call it an inverse approach to the Burlington City Council’s.
Trump will eventually be gone, and the American government will regain its traditional respect for scientific authority and institutions. But the environmental movement can’t go back to the way things were, trying to effect sweeping legislation without first gaining more bipartisan support.
Nature’s most successful species are the ones that adapt and learn or, as Oscar Wilde said, “experience is simply the name we give our mistakes.”
Vermont’s greatest gift to the environmental movement shouldn’t be as a powerhouse of climate regulations but, perhaps with RVR as a model, as a leader in bridging the gap between environmental activists and those most impacted by environmental legislation.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here