At their Sept. 13 meeting, village trustees adopted a resolution authored by village president George Tyler. In a memo to trustees, which attempts to justify the need for this resolution, Mr. Tyler states a “no” vote on the proposed independent tax district for recreation in the village and town “will signal that the community does not wish to consolidate recreation departments.” Wow! What an assumption!
Despite hearing from a number of people that this would be an incorrect interpretation of the voters’ will, the trustees forged ahead with approval of Mr. Tyler’s proposed resolution.
They apparently failed to understand many folks may well vote no, not because they are opposed to any consolidation model, but because they do not like or still have many unanswered questions about the specific STD proposal advocated by the Recreation Governance Study Committee. Additionally, many potential “no” voters question why alternative models were not more fully vetted during the RGSC’s deliberations.
Not only is the trustees’ assumption regarding a possible no vote fallacious, it is down right shortsighted. But hold on, there’s more.
The trustees’ resolution itself states that in the event of a negative vote in December, “the trustees and village government will pursue no further efforts to consolidate recreation departments with the Town of Essex.”
At best, the trustees’ position reminds one of the youngster in a playground ball game who says, when things don’t go his way, “I’m going to take my bat and ball and go home.” Worse yet, however, it appears to border on coercion, pressuring voters to either approve the proposed recreation governance model or to lose any opportunity to negotiate a potentially better one with the town in the future.
Scare tactics are not OK. Let’s keep the conversation based in reality as citizens continue to ponder this critical issue.
The trustees, in my view, should rescind the portion of their resolution which precludes them from pursuing further efforts with the town toward recreation department consolidation, given a negative vote in December. I implore them to please keep the door open to other options that might emerge down the road.
The late President John F. Kennedy once said, “We should never negotiate out of fear, but we should never fear to negotiate.” The trustees would be well advised to heed his admonition at the local level.
Robert Bates
Essex Jct.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here