STD research is faulty

Posted

I agree with Village Trustee Sopchak – do the research. Unfortunately, her research concerning special taxing districts contains errors. Here are the facts.

In her op-ed last week, she state Vermont doesn’t impose debt limits on towns so she feels the concern that STDs circumvent debt limits imposed by the state is irrelevant. Vermont Statutes 24 V.S.A §1762, states a municipality cannot incur indebtedness for public improvements, which in aggregate, would exceed 10 times the last grand list of the municipal corporation. That means that the Town of Essex could bond public improvement in an amount 10 times the grand list and the STD could do the same – doubling the debt limits.

STD elections will not be in March at Town Meeting Day. They will be in April.

Sopchak states any increase in the STD taxes would result in a reduction in the town taxes. There is no way to predict what the town taxes will do. However, when governments get tax rates set, they seldom reduce them for any reason. We can’t say how much they’ll go up, and she can’t say they’ll go down. We simply don’t know, and there are many unmet needs in all municipal governments begging for revenues.

She further asserts the STD wouldn’t increase tax rates because the Essex Jct. Recreation and Parks runs “like an STD” and has had a stable tax rate for 10 years. In fact, over the past few years EJRP used a prior surplus to keep the tax rate in check. Worse still, according to its last budget presentation, they say they have “expanded programming to nearly maximum capacity which will limit increases in program revenue in the future years. This is likely the final year EJRP can present a budget with a level tax rate.”

What other costs will need to be picked up by the STD that will inflate the recreation budgets? According to the EJRP 6/30/15 audit, it only has $5,268 in capital project funds and an aging swimming pool. The town has a capital budget in excess of $850,000 for projects over the next few years for items such as milfoil mitigation and dam repairs at Indian Brook plus park assets replacements. If the new STD is to maintain the town parks they will need to raise taxes for these capital items. Taxes that are in addition to their regular operating funds.

Her comparison of Chittenden Solid Waste District as an STD is the only example that is an STD. The truth is, STDs are not all created equal. CSWD has its own agreement just as the recreation STD has its own.

Here are some major differences.

Composition: CSWD allocates votes to the town of Essex and the village of Essex as two separate entities. Voters of the village are entitled to vote only as a village resident; they are not entitled to a second vote as a town resident. The recreation STD would allow village residents to vote on taxes, changes to the agreement, dissolution, etc. as both village residents and town residents. They can vote twice.

Board of Commissions: CSWD has one commissioner from each member municipality appointed by the municipal legislative body, thus guaranteeing that the views and plans of the municipality as a whole are represented. The recreation STD has a five-member board who would not report back to the municipal boards.

Voting: With CSWD, each commission member is entitled to cast one vote for every 5,000 population or portion thereof. In the recreation STD, each of the five members of the board have one vote – regardless of population represented.

Termination of Membership: A member municipality may vote to terminate membership after one year in the CSWD. The recreation STD ties a member municipality in for at least five years before it can vote to terminate membership.

Appropriations: If the CSWD user fees and revenues do not meet the expenses, each member municipality is assessed a percentage of the obligations, based on the amount of the solid waste generated by them to the whole district – prorated usage. The recreation STD will tax based on their expenditures without any measurement of usage or number of municipal assets utilized.

Surplus: If the CSWD ends the fiscal year with a deficit or a surplus, that amount must be included in the operating budget of the following year. The recreation STD allows for any surplus to be used as the board of directors decides; it does not need to be returned to the members as a reduction in taxes.

I agree. Do the research. Check the facts.

Something I don’t see that our legislative body has yet decided to do.

RaMona Sheppard is an Essex Town resident.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here