Column: Print beats pixels for middle school readers

Posted

George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor.


Those of a certain age will remember the 20th century philosopher and media pundit Marshall McLuhan, who famously said: “The Medium is the Message.”

What McLuhan meant was the means by which information is communicated is often more important than the information itself. He showed how changes in mass media technology cause dramatic disruptions of culture and politics. McLuhan predicted the Internet long before it existed and also predicted that its social disruptions would make all previous disruptions caused by legacy media – newspapers, radio, television – look like gentle ripples on a calm lake.

Hold that thought a moment and allow me to describe a groundbreaking study about to be published by neurocognition specialists at Columbia University, which says that middle school students process written information acquired from print media vs digital media in crucially different ways.

This isn’t altogether surprising. Academic psychologists have long been aware that school kids acquire certain kinds of information better from printed text vs digital media. What’s different about this study is that it’s the first to suggest why this might be happening, by looking at the brain scans of middle school kids as they read expository texts on printed pages vs digital screens.

Middle school students were chosen because that’s when kids make the transition from “learning to read,” to “reading to learn.” The neurons responsible for their cognitive abilities begin to consolidate.

What the brain scans showed is that students process expository text, the kind used to explain things or describe intellectual concepts, at a “deeper” level when it’s presented to them as print on paper vs pixels on a screen. By current scientific understanding, this translates into creating more “robust” neural frameworks for semantic reasoning.

When the students read the same text on digital screens, their scans showed the kind of “shallow processing” pattern displayed when acquiring any other kind of textual information from digital media.

Dr. Karen Froud, the lead author of the study and the director of Columbia’s Graduate School of Neuroscience, said this doesn’t mean the students didn’t understand what the digital information was saying. It means their brains were responding to the same information in very different ways, based on how it was presented to them.

Froud cautioned against too much speculation but suggested that her team’s results might help explain the nationwide drop in students’ reading comprehension scores during the Covid pandemic.

This is important because schools are still trying to sort out why students’ test scores crashed so badly, particularly in areas that require verbal reasoning and critical thinking. There’s been a push to improve digital education platforms in anticipation of another pandemic or similar event that requires closing schools. Froud’s study suggests that these efforts misunderstand what’s really going on. Or, as Marshall McLuhan might say, you can tweak digital education technology all you want, but it won’t make any difference if the digital media itself is the problem.

Froud said, “we should not yet throw away printed books,” but she also said we shouldn’t see digital media as all bad for educating kids. Its advantages for providing immediate access to vast amounts of information are obvious. Digital media is also more adaptable and flexible for certain academic needs and individual abilities. For example, kids with learning disabilities.

As some commenters on the study have said, such as political columnist John MacArthur in a recent Guardian editorial, the broader challenge here is figuring what these results mean within the context of the “digital revolution” in K-12 education. At the precise moment when rigorous scientific research is showing that the old-fashioned paper method is better for teaching children how to read, said MacArthur, education technology companies are promising school boards faster and cheaper improvements in standardized test scores with computerized test-taking and screen-reading programs.

Having acquired my cognitive abilities (what’s left of them) in the pre-Internet age, I found it poignant to hear the students in Froud’s study referred to as “iGens” – kids who have no experience with the pre-Internet world. Perhaps it’s my 20th century bias talking, but I think we shouldn’t be too quick to abandon that old print-driven world. This seems to be the message of Froud’s study.

The research shows that going back to printed text helps iGens’ develop better critical reading skills. Let’s hope educators will stop listening to technology companies and start listening to the science.

(The study is called: ‘Middle-schoolers’ reading and processing depth in response to digital and print media: An N400 study,’ by Karen Froud (and others) at Teachers College, Columbia University.)

Columns are opinion pieces regularly contributed by a select group of writers. Columns reflect the opinions of the writer and do not represent the views of the Essex Reporter.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here