My recent letter to the editor generated two responses: an opposing letter in last week’s paper written by the leader(s) of those opposing a unified recreation district, and an email from a thoughtful citizen who took the time to contact me directly.
Both said I missed something, and I’m really glad they did. I overlooked the bonding statute and relied instead on external research, a mistake on my part. So I’d like to correct myself and also take the opportunity now to prevent yet another scare tactic from running rampant through our community.
It’s true Vermont does not limit a municipality’s ability to appropriate or spend funds. In addition, Vermont also does not have limits on property taxes.
However, there is also a statute that limits how much bonding a municipality can do. I was more focused on spending rather than bonding. At the time, opponents of the unified rec district claimed we were creating the district to avoid spending limits. If there weren’t any spending limits, why would we need to avoid them?
But now that we’ve confirmed there is a debt limit, their argument has changed. Creating a unified rec district to avoid spending or debt limits is no longer a valid argument. So now opponents are claiming we will impose a huge debt burden of 10 times the grand list onto our residents. Just because the limit is that high does not mean we would ever bond that much.
The Essex Recreation Department has no bonded debt. Essex Jct. Recreation and Parks has borrowed money only once. Opponents cannot explain why combining the two departments would suddenly change that trend.
The fact that the unified recreation district would be subject to the same limitations on bonding as all other municipalities in Vermont is a very good thing. Along with the combination of an elected board, annual, public audits and voter-approved budgets, a unified recreation district would have exactly the same checks and balances as the Essex Jct. Village Board of Trustees and the Essex Town Selectboard. Opponents cannot explain why a rec district would be any different from these existing boards.
Finally, let’s not forget all bonding is subject to voter approval. The specific limitations of 24 V.S.A. 53 § 1762 are ridiculously high. If there ever were a board actually willing to ask for approval of a $100 million bond, I suspect the community would vote an emphatic no.
Accuracy is important—thanks for pointing out my oversight. Scare tactics are not OK. Let’s keep the conversation based in reality.
Elaine Sopchak
Village Trustee
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here