Of the issues raised concerning the rec & parks recommendation, I want to focus on two potential fraud preventative and alternative options. At the Aug. 10 Recreation Governance Study Committee work session, I asked a basic question: Why does the rec & parks group intend to ask the Vermont Attorney General’s Office for a legal exemption which allows them to remove the independent status of the special tax district’s treasurer and place that position under the executive director? To date, no explanation has been given for avoiding a legal requirement the legislature put in to counter major fraud.
My concern with fraud arises from my professional work experience in development and fundraising with multi-million nonprofit groups in Baltimore. The structure proposed by the RGSC is very close to a 501(c)3 nonprofit in that the financial books are closed, the treasurer is under the executive director and donors have no access to financial records. The exception is public tax grant funds, which federal and state governments may audit.
No audit guarantees fraud will be found. In the HIV/AIDS nonprofit for which I worked, fraud in the millions of dollars from the Ryan White AIDS fund went on over 10 years and three directors. Just before I quit, federal auditors spent two weeks looking for mismanagement and found nothing. But fraud there was, and after I left, the accountant, who also quit, explained to me the method, such a simple one the feds missed it. From my own knowledge, a variant of that method could easily be used in the closed financial system of an STD.
I challenge anyone in Essex working as an accountant, CPA, investment adviser or banker to explain how the proposed system of one private board with private oversight over closed books is more likely to stop public tax fraud than oversight by the town and the village accountants and auditors, let alone state auditors of public funds – especially if the STD treasurer is not independent. The RGSC needs to stop saying the proposed district will have more oversight, because that is patently not fact.
Second, at the Aug. 1 Essex Selectboard meeting, which ran for four hours, trustee president George Tyler made this statement: “We can take the EJRP into the village administration and make it a department, then merge it with the town rec department later, if that’s what residents want.” Essex has valid alternatives to the tax district recommendation. I encourage residents to watch the VCAM tape of the Aug. 1 meeting to hear the RGSC presentation, residents’ comments and Tyler’s full statement made after 9 p.m.
Paula DeMichele
Essex
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here