Essex Jct. Recreation & Parks director Brad Luck and village president George Tyler decided more than a year before the upcoming Dec. 13 special election – when voters decide to create a rec district, or not – that an independent rec district would be the best outcome, at least for them.
A special taxing district could keep money flowing into the Village’s Rec Dept., while ensuring lingering questions as to what EJRP really collects and spends (due to its CCSU ties, childcare subsidized by taxpayers, minimal oversight, etc.) might never be answered.
You see, an STD would have just one board for oversight, comprised of people who love recreation.
Bad for Taxpayers!
Truly, that arrangement would be great for growing rec programs, budgets, tax rates faster than if they were underneath three levels of oversight, should EJRP merge instead (with town rec) under town government.
The latter type of consolidation would follow the pattern of all prior town/village consolidations, but who needs consistency? Or lower tax rates, for that matter.
There are three fallacies in this plan.
#1 FALLACY from the Rec Gov Study Committee: STDs have “more oversight.”
In truth, one hallmark of STDs is less oversight – fewer checks and balances – than a town-administered department. Another is special elections at odd times of the year. Say, 12 days before Christmas?
#2 FALLACY: The RGSC considered options on a level playing field.
Actually, an STD was the predicted outcome four months before committee members were appointed. Back on Nov. 17, 2015, Mr. Tyler wanted to “begin the discussion on how the community would approach creating an Essex-wide recreation district together.”
First, the boards would need to “jointly approve creating a study committee whose task would be to identify and frame all issues pertinent to creating this district and develop a plan.”
#3 FALLACY: A study – “detailed investigation and analysis” (Google definition) – of options took place.
In less than three hours, the RGSC learned about/discussed options and then decided an STD was its preferred direction for both rec departments for the next five years.
Certainly, this was one smart, savvy committee, but it had several months over which to dig and deliberate. Why the haste? Where the due diligence?
Decide in haste, market at leisure.
By rushing its decision, the committee and staff were able to use the time remaining to work out legal issues and to develop an elaborate sales pitch (including catchy YouTube videos) to cover for people who stood to gain, as well as those who’d “invested an enormous amount of work” in this initiative to find EJRP a new home – namely, all the village trustees, said one of them who did not serve on the RGSC.
Mr. Tyler corroborated on Dec. 7, 2015, creating a rec district is “something that we have explored” long before anyone was publicly asked to study the future of recreation in Essex.
If someone stood to gain from less oversight and a bigger budget in a future STD, it might be EJRP director Brad Luck.
On Dec. 7, 2015, four months before a committee would be formed to gather info and study rec options, Mr. Luck offered, “A lot of this stuff Ally and I have readily available”; a group would be able to “vet it pretty quickly.”
When RGSC members tell you how many times they met and point to a list of pros and cons compiled in less than an hour on May 4 as proof of their diligence, thank them for their time.
And try not to think of a fig leaf. “It’s foolhardy to set up a fig-leaf committee and hope nobody will look under the fig leaf and see what’s there.” — Howard Rubenstein
Visit www.PlanBforEssex.org to learn more about the process that no one else wants to talk about.
Irene Wrenner is an Essex Selectboard member, expressing her personal opinion.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here