Our words represent only our opinions and not necessarily those of fellow board members or municipal staff.
For three years, the town and village have collaborated to make local government more efficient by consolidating municipal services when opportunities arise. Each opportunity’s unique challenges required a thoughtful, evenhanded solution. For example, we moved the Village Public Works Department under the administrative umbrella of the town, but allowed the department to maintain its separate identity and have the village trustees recommend its budget. A town employee runs the Essex Senior Center, but the village provides the facilities. Community planning will most likely become a town operation, but the village will maintain a separate development review board to evaluate projects in the village.
In each case we strove to maintain customer service by understanding each department’s culture and operation and preserving the things it does best. Above all, we’ve avoided the traditional town vs. village turf battles.
We approached recreation consolidation the same way: How do we maintain what’s best in each department, consolidate governance and administration, and blend operations together rather than have one department simply “take over” the other? We appointed a 10-member committee to study the possibilities and recommend a solution. Their answer – to create a union municipal district – is an excellent one. The governance structure allows the town and village to oversee operations. It gives voters strict control over budgets and, with Australian (paper) balloting, encourages greater voter turnout. It keeps all properties and assets in the hands of the Essex community, and it offers the best chance of continuing all the recreational leagues, family events, traditions, programs and services that have evolved in the Essex community over the last 40 years.
Some don’t agree with this collaborative approach. They insist consolidation means having the town take over the village department. Period. Never mind political concerns, culture and the complexities of assimilating a larger (village) department with its unique programs and independent history into a smaller town department. They reject the recreation study because it didn’t validate their preconceived ideas.
Fortunately, all but one of the elected officials in the town and village overseeing the recreation study see the wisdom of finding common ground and trying to preserve what’s best in both departments. That’s why they agreed to put the question to the voters. That’s why they allowed the Recreation Governance Study Committee to continue reaching out and answering questions.
For the past three months the committee has circulated through the community explaining how they came to their recommendation, how it would work and why it makes sense. Despite their efforts, and the efforts of village and town staff to address concerns, critics of the proposal have only become more incensed. They’ve tried to “brand” the union district as an “STD” to create a negative impression in voters’ minds. They’ve claimed the study process, which was monitored by village, town and supervisory union administrative and legal staff, was “rigged.” Despite both recreation departments’ histories of prudent budgets and stable finances, they’ve tried to convince voters that bringing the departments together will suddenly make their budgets spin out of control.
Those opponents can’t explain why the same governance structure that works for the town, village and school districts won’t work for recreation. They decry “creating another bureaucracy” when they know that combining the two departments would, in fact, streamline administrative needs. They change the subject when it’s pointed out that a similar town-village union district created Essex High School and the Center for Technology.
We support the union recreation district proposal not only because it preserves our wonderful recreation programs while controlling costs, but also because it is the best way to keep town-village consolidation moving forward. As we continue with the collaborative process we began three years ago, we might soon approach the question of a complete government merger. Consolidating the recreation departments now in a way that builds mutual trust rather than stirs political tensions will take us one giant step closer to that goal.
Max Levy is the chairman of the Essex Town Selectboard. George Tyler is president of the Essex Jct. Board of Trustees.
Editor’s note: This op-ed is in response to selectboard vice-chairwoman Irene Wrenner’s Sept. 29 perspective.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here