Fraud controls needed for rec district

Posted

As a resident of Essex, I have attended meetings about the new municipal tax district recommended by the park and recs study committee. A very basic issue about finances is being obscured.

At the Aug. 1 selectboard meeting, member Andy Watts raised questions about finances for the new tax district. First, he questioned why the study committee is asking for an exemption from the Vermont law, which requires the treasurer be independent. An exemption allows the treasurer to be placed under the executive director. At the Aug. 10 park and recs study committee work session, I asked why they are asking for an exemption from state law that allows them to remove the independent status of the treasurer. I received no clear answer.

This is one of several legal waivers from the Vermont law code being requested. I asked my neighbor, Mary-Ann Parizo, retired Essex Jct. state legislator, whether the legislative intent in making the treasurer’s function independent was to deter major fraud. She said, “Yes, it was.” Removing the independent status of the treasurer will be an invitation to major fraud in this new municipal tax district.

I question creating a structure that would make fraud easier 15, 30 or 50 years from now. In the past four years, there has been widespread fraud, running in one instance into a half million dollars, in a dozen Vermont municipalities. This kind of fraud already happened here in the 1970s when a village treasurer absconded with hundreds of thousands of dollars. No external audit guarantees discovery of really sophisticated fraud.

Mr. Watts also raised the issue of dedicated funds received through the school and of future grant funding.

I assume that as with a 501.c.3 nonprofit, the books of the new tax district will be closed. Residents will see only the line item budget for a vote. Will the new municipality file a tax return, and will that return be open to the public? Reading a tax return is not a foolproof way to discover fraud, but it is a way to track use of all funds. A closed tax return contributes to fraud.

Other legal waivers are being requested, notably an exemption from state law that allows the new park and recs municipality to increase the time limit for a vote to withdraw from the new district from one year to three, or even seven years. For voter transparency, I am asking all legal waivers being requested should be released to the public in a clear list, with reasons for the requested exemptions.

Paula DeMichele

Essex

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here