ESSEX TOWN — The selectboard discussed town budget goals and priorities in fiscal year 2027 this past Monday, prompted by town management looking for feedback.
All members present shared their perspectives on what they’d like to see prioritized — with every member stressing they’d like to see every effort made to prevent the budget from increasing as drastically as it has in recent years.
“We've had a couple of bigger tax increases lately,” said member Andy Watts, kicking off the discussion. “We've heard people comment tonight about taxes. I think we have, in the past, targeted three and a half percent. I'd like to go there, if we can.”
Fiscal year 2027 is next year, from July 1, 2026 to June 30, 2027. The budget process will begin in earnest in the coming weeks, to be developed throughout the coming months by town management and to be voted on by residents this upcoming March on Town Meeting Day.
The Town of Essex saw its first substantial increase in taxes in FY24, after its separation from the City of Essex Junction. The town lost 41% of its tax base, causing town residents to contribute more to maintain overall services.
A critical component of the budget process is receiving input from the selectboard on high-level goals and priorities for the budget year — high-level goals potentially including a target for the tax rate and desired levels of service for municipal functions, among other topics.
“Staff has already started at the managerial level to start talking about budget and start the budget process and prep,” Town Manager Greg Duggan said. “Each year, we come to you as one of their real first steps and get a sense of any high level goals you want to accomplish.”
Staff is now working with selectboard members and department heads to schedule the selectboard’s first budget workshop, which is expected to take place during the first or second week of December. Budget packets are scheduled to be delivered in late November.
Selectboard Chair Tracey Delphia was out Monday, so member Ethan Lawrence noted this topic should also be placed on the next agenda, just to quickly gather her thoughts at the next meeting.
Board members said they understand the budget is often impacted by the need to have competitive salaries to retain and recruit town staff.
Kendall Chamberlin asked Duggan if there was any idea what percentage of an overall tax increase would account for just the staff wages, but Duggan was uncertain of the answer to that question on Monday night.
Hence, Chamberlain requested Duggan obtain that intel to share at a near-future meeting.
“[To get] a smaller percentage increase, it would be nice to know exactly what percentage of the budget needs to go up just for increases for staff [salaries and benefits],” he said. “If we had that number, then we could determine the actual rest of the budget, which is a little more flexible.”
Watts said it's a good idea to start the budget process earlier this year, for the sake of preventing those big swings in the midst of board-informed conversations.
Lastly, Watts said he wants to make sure everyone has a very clean story about any fund balance leftover from the previous year, with a clear recommendation of what it should be used for — maybe in parallel, suggesting a discussion about preparing a fund balance policy.
Clerk Shannon Jackson said he’s heard from many people concerned about affordability in Essex and reiterated Chamberlin’s point about scrutinizing the budget carefully.
“It's listed in our core values,” Jackson said. “It's listed in our goals about trying to help make sure that Essex is inclusive, as well as affordable. And as Kendall was saying, let's see what the minimum requirement is, but let's try to see whether there's areas to save.”
“There's obviously a lot of things we'd love to be doing,” he added. “There's ways to enhance the town, but I think it's really important right now, when people's wallets are being strained so much that we try to get this as low as possible.”
Lawrence was also adamant about keeping costs down, but believes the board and town have done a good job in spite of recent challenges.
“I’m just gonna be a little more spicy on the tax policy,” Lawrence said. “The last four years have heard the same thing, other than the one year we had, the transition year that was rough, but we bit it off, and we did a good job.”
“But, you know, it's been one of my goals for 3.5%, for the last three years,” he added. “And unfortunately, every year, there's a way for it to become [nearly] 5%, and it's and it's been consistent for three years now. I would like to see it under 2%.”
A number of selectboard goals are about potential cost savings, which Lawrence said could be worked toward potentially by leveraging the updated fund balance policy to minimize tax spikes as Watts mentioned, updating the town’s purchasing policy, and being more stringent about what sorts of projects other undesignated capital fund balances can be reassigned to.
Duggan noted management comes to the selectboard for all reassignment permissions.
Lawrence also mentioned wanting to make additional changes to user fees for parks, particularly Indian Brook, and said he wants to begin discussions with the public works department in the coming months to get a head start on estimated costs for sidewalk plowing. Lawrence would also like to create a measuring device for the will to develop 80 and 90 Upper Main Street.
Jackson at this point asked whether there would be a discussion when thinking of the budget, about looking at a local options tax or meals and rooms tax, to help reduce the budget itself as a separate stream of income to support projects.
The idea had come up initially during the selectboard’s strategic planning session.
“Is that appropriate for this?” he asked. “Or is that a project we’re working on elsewhere?”
Jackson said new fees for parks could also help lessen the burden of property taxes.
“I'd love to make it so that our visitors to our wonderful town are also helping,” he said.
Duggan said the LOT or meals and rooms is relevant to talk about now and in other contexts.
“It depends,” Duggan said. “Do you have thoughts on where you'd like to apply that? Would it go directly to reducing the tax rate? Would it go towards a specific project, specific items, a specific fund? We did a survey probably four or five years ago about interest in local options tax.”
“My brief summary is that [taxpayer feedback] was lukewarm at best, and a lot of feedback was, ‘Well, tell us how you want to use it, and we can tell you if we're supportive or not,’” he added. “So I think this is an ongoing conversation, if you want us to bump that up.”
Here, Chamberlain noted a list and potential number of necessitated capital projects would be helpful context for the conversation around whether or not, and how, to implement a LOT.
“Just want to remind us that we have non-property tax revenue as a low priority in our work plan,” Watts said. “So, I think in bringing it up to try to say, ‘We need to talk about this during budgeting is rationing that a little bit.”
Jackson said Watts is absolutely right, but still reiterated additional revenue streams would keep climbing, hence the need to throw out ideas that could ease the burden of rising taxes.
“I’m also a realist — there's fixed costs that are going to be necessary with health care increases and staffing and union salaries that are expected to go up,” Jackson said. “I haven't seen a huge surge of people moving to Essex for the past three years, so I don't expect our base to grow.”
Chamberlain asked staff where they feel the selectboard should be focused, based on where the challenges might be concentrated in this year of planning, and while Duggan appreciated the question, he also said it’s tough to answer that question at this early stage.
“Looking back in the past few years, in my opinion, it's been a balance between trying to keep the tax rate at a manageable amount after that for a separation year, while also hearing from a lot of people and a lot of good desires of what types of service improvements we can make,” said Greg Duggan, of general affordability concerns. “It does come at cost in a lot of cases.”
“Just keep that stuff in mind, and we will put together a best proposal for you to consider, and as far as what service levels we think we have, and what we're hearing and what you're asking for, and then have a good conversation about where it spurs the right budget amount to fund the services that people are expecting to make.”
To help inform discussion, the selectboard looked back on its FY26 work plan along with its
pre-established values and long-term goals, all viewable in Monday night’s meeting packet.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here