Essex Junction City Council reconsiders management model for Tree Farm Recreational Facility

Posted

ESSEX JUNCTION — City Council shared a renewed desire for eventual joint-municipal management of the Tree Farm Recreational Facility on Wednesday night. 

After about an hour of council discussion and public participation on the subject, the full council voted to authorize city councilors Marcus Certa and Raj Chawla to request a meeting with two Essex selectboard members in the near future. The goal is to begin a preliminary dialogue around the future of Tree Farm property management by the end of this next lease in 2025. 

The Tree Farm Recreational Facility is a popular set of sports fields in Essex Junction, co-owned by the City and Town. The Tree Farm Management Group is a third party established over two decades ago to manage the property, at a time when the Town and then-Village purchased it from the state, lacking municipal capacity to manage it personally. 

The idea, voiced a number of times over the years by Essex Junction leaders, is for the Junction’s and Town’s recreation departments to eventually jointly take over. But given past strife, a number of residents and field users at the Dec. 11 council meeting expressed they do not support direct, joint municipal management of the property. 

At an hours-long meeting in fall of 2022 between both municipalities, the agreement was to extend the lease with the Tree Farm Management Group by three-years and come to a decision about municipal management within two. As 2024 now draws to a close, the municipalities still need a little more time.  

Contrary to the feelings of Essex Junction city councilors on the matter, which remain generally consistent since the start of the conversation years ago, the town historically has been in favor of indefinitely continuing third party management. 

In fact, this time around, Town of Essex leadership has already voted unanimously to offer the same three-year lease back to the Tree Farm Management Group — without having consulted  the City. 

Prior to this week, Essex Junction’s city council discussed the matter only in the context of an executive session, City Manager Regina Mahoney said. 

“The agreement requires that the [discussion] is reopened before the end of December 2024,” she said at the meeting. “So that is why we’re having this conversation tonight.” 

City Council President Raj Chawla said right off the bat the end goal should be to bring the property under city-town management, though the timeline for doing so remains up in the air. 

“I think there are excellent reasons why we should do that,” he said. “Improvements need to be made in an infrastructure-sense to the property. The Tree Farm has, understandably, pointed out that this shouldn't be part of their agreement.” 

For instance, Chawla believes there should be actual facilities accompanying the fields, such as restrooms and snack bars, but that asking the Tree Farm Management Group to take on capital projects of that nature or scale would be inappropriate. 

Now that Essex Junction has a parks and recreation department well-equipped with the mechanisms needed to manage the Tree Farm, he believes it should work with the Town’s recreation department to come up with a plan for joint management. 

“We don't typically have third parties managing parks and properties for us,” Chawla said. 

“It also becomes interesting when we're asking the entities that are renting from us to also set the rates,” he added. “The city rec department has a very successful history in running what we call enterprise funds, or operations that are fee-based and service-based, in an efficient and cost-effective way.” 

Following Chawla’s remarks, city councilor Marcus Certa said that while he thinks there will eventually be an appropriate time for that, he still has some concerns around the current capacity of the city’s recreation department, and for the time being, favored extending the current lease once again to the Tree Farm Management Group. 

Chawla also said he is personally a member of the Tree Farm Management Group’s board — hence, his nomination to be a part of the preliminary Junction-Town working group. 

“I hear your concerns about the need for some facilities on the property,” Certa said, addressing Chawla. “I think there's potential, within an agreement, for the Tree Farm [Group] to continue to manage this property on an extended lease, with a caveat of building up either a capital fund or some mechanism by which we can help add to the amenities of that particular property.” 

City Council clerk Tim Miller echoed Certa’s statements. 

Councilor Elaine Haney said the City’s parks department has expressed, on the contrary, that they do have the capacity to take on Tree Farm management responsibilities. Her concerns are primarily around the financial capacity of the City overall to take on such a large property parcel requiring a certain level of risk as well as with a need for additional capital investment. 

For these slightly different reasons, she agreed with Certa and Miller that extending the lease for now is in all parties’ best interest — but with the intention of moving more rapidly toward transferring over to municipal management by the end of this next contract. 

She also expressed interest in asking the managing tenant to contribute to a capital fund for the property, particularly for any capital needs that are necessary only based on how heavily that property is used. 

“The Town of Essex selectboard already took action to offer a lease,” Haney said. “Seeing as we both own the property, I think we might want to work together to coordinate those conversations better than we have in the past, so we are not one behind the other, or going in different directions.” 

Council Vice President Amber Thibeault generally agreed with everything that had been said by other council members. She favored extending the lease with consideration of capital upgrades and with the goal of continuing to move toward municipal management in the long-term. 

“What we haven't done here yet, obviously, is talk to the selectboard about this,” Chawla reiterated. “As has been pointed out, we own it jointly. So unfortunately, that hasn't happened, and they made it into what feels like a hard decision, but I think it'd be a good idea to get together on the side and kind of see where we're really at, see how we're feeling about this.” 

“Because I think this is an in-between that hasn't been suggested before,” he added, on new solutions-thinking around pursuing capital improvements even under the renewed lease. 

Over the years, Chawla believes an additional capital fee for users of every unit that the Tree Farm Management Group rents out would add up to eventually becoming a meaningful sum, contributing to the construction of desired amenities on the property. 

“That's not something we've all talked about, so I can't imagine how they feel about it, or that they've considered it,” Chawla said. “I don't want to get into the concept of what is an ‘extended lease’ period of time. I think let's figure out where we are with the town first, and then figure out the much longer-term conversation.” 

Passionate parents, Tree Farm Management Group board members and local sports program volunteers and staff alike spoke up to share the importance of this community feature, and to broadly express general confidence in the quality of continued care being administered by the Tree Farm Management Group — with a particularly pertinent point of satisfaction being its ability to do so as a volunteer-run nonprofit, at zero expense to taxpayers. 

But several folks believe user fees have already risen so greatly that the ability to reasonably fundraise via user fees for capital improvements is minimal. 

A vast majority of participants favor the status quo, proposing an even longer lease and voicing overall support for the reputation and performance of the Tree Farm Management Group and its funding model, and speaking out against a municipal take-over. 

A few participants close to the issue just expressed concern around how the transition to direct municipal oversight would be handled in the future, bringing to light worries about the Town’s and Junction’s ability to settle on a clear shared vision given their history. 

But others still shared a desire to see collaborative efforts overcome that history to maximize the safety and functional uses of the property, and a desire to move away from cheap, temporary “Band-Aid” solutions for road maintenance and to eventually install proper drainage there. 

After well over a dozen members of the public contributed to the discussion, the council resumed its proceedings toward a motion. 

“I think it would be worthwhile for us to have a conversation with the Town and to hear their reasoning as to why they thought we should extend the lease,” Haney said. “Because we just haven't had any conversations with them.” 

She suggested discussing with the Town how the groups can best jointly manage capital development, what collaboration would look like, what kind of capital investment they hope to see, as well as working out who manages parking lot and road maintenance details. 

Chawla reiterated the best way to begin these discussions is to start working in small groups with a few representatives from each municipality. 

“We have a lot of history and not a lot of time,” he said. “This takes an awful lot of time and planning. I would suggest a couple of us get together with their leadership or representatives to see if there's any interest in exploring some of these topics in the first place, quite honestly, and where there might be some agreement, so that we can at least start somewhere.” 

The granular details and timeline would be established subsequently. 

Officially, the next management agreement has to be established before the end of 2025. 

“We appreciate the work that the tree farm has done so far,” Chawla said after the vote, as members of the public began to rise and depart. “The property is obviously in very good hands.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here