Marybeth Redmond is a former Vermont state representative (Essex, 2019—2022), longtime journalist and co-founder of writinginsideVT, a 10-year writing program for incarcerated women at the Chittenden Regional Correctional Facility.
Calls to completely abolish Vermont’s prison facility for justice-involved women may be well-intentioned, but they are ultimately misguided and unrealistic.
For decades, Vermont has lacked a trauma-informed correctional facility designed to meet the rehabilitation needs of women. For the past 14 years, women have been confined to the aging Chittenden Regional Correctional Facility in South Burlington—a crumbling, 50-year-old building with no space for job training, recreation, or comprehensive treatment. Despite $3 million in annual upkeep and millions more in deferred maintenance, the facility remains inadequate and inhumane.
Abolitionists often claim that “there is no such thing as a trauma-informed prison,” but I disagree. I’ve witnessed such a facility firsthand in Maine, where women reside in dorm-like settings, access mental health and substance use treatment, hold jobs, and participate in programs that give them agency and structure. Mentorship, stable housing, and consistent meals allow these women to focus on recovery and rebuilding their lives.
Vermont’s replacement, the Corrections and Re-entry for Women (CREW) Center proposed in Essex, is designed with those principles in mind. It would be smaller than the current facility (158 beds vs. 177), with 30 beds dedicated to re-entry services aimed at reducing recidivism and supporting successful transitions back into the community.
Where abolitionists and I agree is the urgent need to strengthen the social safety net. Vermont’s continuum of care—including mental health and substance use treatment, transitional housing, job training, and restorative justice services—has been chronically underfunded. Last year, the Department of Corrections (DOC) invested $10.6 million in community-based alternatives to incarceration and plans to expand funding through opioid settlement dollars. But the need remains overwhelming, especially as opioids and fentanyl continue to ravage communities.
Further complicating matters, the federal government is pulling back critical grant funding that for decades has sustained local nonprofits working with justice-involved women. Without reliable support, these organizations are struggling to meet increasing demand.
Even under ideal conditions—with robust federal and state investment in social services—there will still be women who require secure facilities. Some face violent charges or acute needs that community-based services simply aren’t equipped to handle. Assuming every woman can be safely treated in the community ignores reality and risks serious harm.
We’ve seen the consequences of prematurely closing secure facilities. Vulnerable individuals spill into the streets without proper support. Many community providers are unable or unwilling to serve justice-involved individuals due to limited capacity or a lack of specialized training.
Some women need a secure, stable environment to detox, access care, and begin planning for a better future. Eliminating all 177 existing beds would overwhelm already-strained providers and leave around 1,400 women without appropriate care, according to the DOC. In such a vacuum, Vermont may be forced to send women to out-of-state, for-profit facilities where cost-cutting trumps quality care.
Yes, the long-term goal should be to build out community-based systems robust enough to reduce—and eventually eliminate—incarceration. But dismantling the current system without a viable alternative in place will only cause more suffering. Delays driven by prison abolitionists risk prolonging the use of the outdated South Burlington facility, where women continue to be housed in conditions that do not support their rehabilitation.
Progress requires both vision and pragmatism. The CREW facility is not about reinforcing incarceration—it's about replacing a failed structure with one that acknowledges the complex needs of justice-involved women. Rather than abandon these women to a broken system or ship them out of state, Vermont has an opportunity to provide a safer, more supportive environment while continuing to invest in the long-term goal of reducing incarceration. We don’t need to choose between community care and secure facilities—we need to build both, responsibly and urgently.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here