Column: Why not Essex for women’s correctional facility?

Posted

Marybeth Redmond, a long-time journalist, co-founded the writinginside VT program at the Chittenden Regional Correctional Facility in South Burlington, which ran for a decade from 2010-2020. Feel free to reach out to her at: marybethredmond@comcast.net


The Vermont Department of Corrections is exploring the siting of a new correctional facility and re-entry center for women inside the Town of Essex. 

To learn more about the proposal, I recently attended the Town selectboard and planning commission meetings, as well as listened to testimony about the project provided to the Joint Legislative Justice Oversight Committee on Aug. 28.

I’ve also been calling up my experience working with hundreds of incarcerated women at the Chittenden Regional Correctional Facility in South Burlington. Many readers may not know this, but in 2010 I co-founded a writing-for-self-change program in the facility where I have spent thousands of hours getting to know the women, their stories as well as their aspirations.

Women have been incarcerated there since 2011, housed in a failing building originally designed as a temporary detention facility that is literally sinking into the ground.

A dozen years ago, the shape of the South Burlington prison (across from Klinger’s Bakery & Cafe) was so concerning that several program providers there, me included, co-authored a report highlighting the “disturbing conditions.”

These included: raw sewage backups, scant hot water, an uneven heating system, zero space for vocational/employment training, and next-to-no outdoor area for walking and exercise. These same issues remain to this day with a $3 million price tag per year to “maintain” the facility, according to a recent presentation by Corrections administrators to the Essex Selectboard.

One-third of the Vermont women housed in the South Burlington facility hail from Chittenden County, Corrections data indicates. Eighty percent are mothers. And 95 percent will return to a community across the state, striving to create a productive life.

The State has offered some sensible reasons for locating the new facility in Chittenden County and Essex, specifically. They want to keep employed their current correctional staff trained in trauma-informed, gender-responsive practices, many of whom reside in the vicinity. 

The Department of Corrections also wants to continue partnering with program providers in the Burlington area who have worked with the incarcerated women for decades. Some of these include: Lund’s Kids-A-Part program, facilitating contact between incarcerated parents and their children; Mercy Connections, matching “inside” women with mentors in preparation for their transition to the community; Vermont Works for Women, delivering soft skills and employment training; and the Vermont Network Against Domestic and Sexual Violence’s DIVAS program.

The State also honed in on Essex because it owns two sizable rural parcels of land there, which will reduce taxpayer impact for a project already slated to cost more than $70 million. Corrections investigated privately owned properties in Williston and other locations, but the costs were prohibitive.

Some of the local dust-up among Essex residents relates to the specific locations. One proposed site is located off River Road (between North Williston and Sand Hill Roads) in the Industrial Zone. Another location is situated at the end of VT 289 adjacent to the landfill (off Colchester Road) on property acquired by the State for the not-completed Circumferential Highway. The actual correctional facility and re-entry center would not be visible from the road at either location.

Neighbors living several miles from the River Road location showed up at a recent planning commission meeting to push back against the potential noise, traffic, and perceived impacts to property values. 

I personally believe the Colchester Road location is the more favorable one due to fewer environmental impacts and proximity to the bus line and employment, though both locations would require zoning changes by the Town of Essex to proceed.

There’s also boisterous input from the FreeHer Campaign, advocating for the abolition of prison facilities altogether. These advocates want justice-involved women housed in less institutional settings such as transitional housing or existing buildings converted from former uses like college dormitories.

This is a noble aim but is unrealistic currently. We in Vermont are not there yet. Our criminal justice and courts systems need reform, an infusion of resources, as well as refinement of some of the current laws that land people in jail. We also need deeper investment in restorative justice, diversion, mental health, and prevention programs that prioritize treatment and not punitive measures.

And, this is hard to say but true from my own experience working with Vermont’s incarcerated populations — there are some folks who need to be removed from society for a time due to the nature of their crime, for public safety reasons, and to immerse themselves in the structure of treatment within a therapeutic setting. How we do that in less institutional settings that typically breed violence and unhealthy cultures are the cutting-edge questions of our time.

I see this new prison and re-entry facility for incarcerated women as the very last prison we could construct for women in the Green Mountain State. We could hold this aim high as the project proceeds.

There are those I am meeting in local cafes and grocery aisles whom I am pleasantly surprised are saying, “why not Essex?” as the location for this new project. I agree.


 Columns are opinion pieces regularly contributed by a select group of writers. Columns reflect the opinions of the writer and do not represent the views of the Essex Reporter.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here