Marybeth Redmond is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. Redmond is a long-time journalist who served as state representative of Essex Town from 2019-2022.
What’s our responsibility as a society and a people to repair the harms perpetuated by leaders and institutions that existed years or even centuries before we lived? This is a hot button topic being debated by governments, states, universities, churches, and nearly every institution with a historical record.
I am holding this question in my own life too. What is my personal responsibility to help heal the wounds of a past that I had nothing to do with? One real world example that I am considering in this light is the plight of thousands of Vermont children who resided at the former St. Joseph’s Orphanage in Burlington.
Consider this astounding statistic: Over 120 years (from 1854-1974), 13,000 of Vermont’s children passed through the doors of this orphanage located on North Avenue. Many Vermonters know someone who lived there. Several of the incarcerated women I wrote with at the Chittenden Regional Correctional Facility years back – some of their mothers and grandmothers spent time at the orphanage.
As babies or young children, they were placed at the towering brick residence overlooking Lake Champlain by desperate single mothers, families unable to care for expanding broods in the time before contraception, human service agencies, and the State of Vermont. The facility was operated by the Roman Catholic Diocese of Burlington who engaged the French-Canadian Sisters of Providence to run the facility.
Some of the orphans’ stints were brief and uneventful; others endured maltreatment for entire childhoods and describe neglect and physical and sexual abuse, among other traumas, that impact their lives to this day.
Fewer than 100 of these former residents remain to recount this tragic history first-hand. Many of these individuals, now well into their 60s and 70s, are the last surviving generation. A few of them still struggle with basic human needs like buying food and affording monthly rent.
The survivors support one another with loving care through a group they formed, the Voices of St. Joseph’s Orphanage. In recent years, they have been engaged in a courageous reckoning of their pasts, adopting as their collective mission “to ensure the safety of children, both now and in the future, and hold accountable those who abuse them.”
You can read more about this devastating chapter in Vermont’s history in author Christine Kenneally’s 2023 book, Ghosts in the Orphanage: A Story of Mysterious Deaths, a Conspiracy of Silence, and a Search for Justice. For the record, the Vermont Attorney General’s office, in concert with other agencies, did open a formal investigation from 2018-2020 to explore the accusations of murder but did not find evidence to support the allegations.
Why do I recount this historical moment as one I feel a sense of responsibility for? Because I have sat for hours and heard their harrowing tales in legislative hearings and other more intimate story-sharing venues. And as someone whose religious background is Catholic, I can say without hesitation that my tradition has botched the compassionate repair needed, circled its own legal wagons, refused to meet with the Voices group or provide the orphan records requested, and not paid for the therapists of the survivors’ specific choosing.
But my goal in sharing this story is not to bash the Catholic Church, which should have accounted publicly for its past role and made right in ways that reflect its merciful founder. Instead, I have tried to channel my outrage and supportive energy into taking my own deliberate action that will hopefully add healing balm to the situation, but most especially communicate to those still living the nightmare, “I see you. I hear you. I believe you. This should never have happened.”
With a team of Vermonters, including former Lieutenant Governor Molly Gray, I have been working to fundraise for a public memorial that will transform a corridor of land within Kieslich Park in Burlington into a memorial pathway of unfolding beauty dedicated to the resilience of Vermont’s children; most importantly, it will honor the lives of the 13,000 orphans on the very same land they once roamed and played.
This community project was envisioned by the Voices group in collaboration with the Burlington Parks, Recreation & Waterfront. Thus far, we have raised $85,000 of a $160,000 goal. The aim is for the memorial to be installed sometime during 2024, and your contributions are welcome here: https://www.stjosephsrjinquiry.com/memorialfund
In no way can a public memorial begin to assuage the wrath that was wrought on so many Vermont lives. But in my mind, it’s a positive and productive step forward. It’s putting a stake in the ground that declares as a society, we won’t tolerate that kind of treatment for children (as I sadly read the recent report in SevenDays about the children held at the former Woodside Juvenile Rehabilitation Center in Essex).
I wonder what issue from the past gets under your skin and burns? What wrongdoing do you find yourself ruminating about endlessly? I would suggest that you pay attention to that uncomfortable, internal broiling within. It’s a signal of where your energy and vitality may be useful in our community to help heal or repair a breach.
Columns are opinion pieces regularly contributed by a select group of writers. Columns reflect the opinions of the writer and do not represent the views of the Essex Reporter.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here