George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor.
Our environmentally-conscious state just had a giant red flag waved in its face, and we all need to wake up and pay attention.
The federal government has released its Fifth National Climate Assessment, its comprehensive report on the current state of climate change mitigation and readiness, combining data from 14 agencies including the EPA, NASA, and the National Science Foundation. It showed that among the 12 northeastern states, Vermont is second to last, after West Virginia, for climate adaptation.
Let’s break this down. As the report makes clear, responsible climate action doesn’t just mean reducing your carbon footprint (mitigation). It means reducing your carbon footprint while adapting your state to the inevitable impacts of a changing climate. Two pillars. Mitigation and adaptation. Yin and yang.
Yes, we should strive towards net zero. We should build solar arrays and wind farms, encourage conservation, and alternative energy sources. But we can’t delude ourselves into believing that reducing our insignificant contribution to a global phenomenon will somehow save us from its wrath. So, we also need to build more resilient roads, culverts, bridges, and dams. Upgrade storm drain systems designed for earlier times.
In 1999, I attended Vermont’s first regional conference on climate change hosted by the University of Vermont in collaboration with the Agency of Natural Resources and the Atlantic Center for the Environment. One of the key takeaways was that small rural states like Vermont, who contribute very little to the climate problem but are very vulnerable to its effects, must – keyword – must balance their mitigation efforts with their adaptation efforts.
That was 25 years ago. Since then, we’ve had lots of bold legislative initiatives aimed at mitigating Vermont’s carbon footprint. But bold initiatives on the adaptation side? Not so much. A whole lot of yin and not enough yang.
I’m going to speak the truth about Vermont’s role in the global climate crisis, so those of you who are a bit squeamish might want to leave the room. Ready? Vermont’s contribution to the atmospheric carbon load is so negligible that if we didn’t release a single molecule of carbon dioxide or methane into the atmosphere it wouldn’t make the slightest difference in terms of what’s coming our way.
Perhaps more important, and I think this gets to the heart of the matter, no one is watching us. The governments of China, India, and Russia are not waiting to see what bold new steps Vermont takes on global warming. Yet, the narratives that accompany our climate mitigation efforts often allude to the state’s “leadership role” in the climate crisis. Says who?
If we want to talk about leadership, perhaps we should look to our neighboring states of Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and New York who have all done a better job balancing mitigation with adaptation.
The Vermont Legislature’s Affordable Heat Act is a prime example of what we shouldn't be doing. The goal is to eventually convert all home heating systems to sustainable, non-fossil fuel sources. The legislature acknowledges that the financial impacts will be staggering, but they insist the costs can be distributed “equitably” through a complex algorithm of taxes, federal grants, and carbon credits.
Gov. Phil Scott vetoed the act last year, and at a recent meeting of the Essex Rotary called it “punitive” on Vermont’s most vulnerable homeowners. But the legislature overrode his veto, and, in the coming session, they’ll hammer out the details with the aim of full implementation in 2025. And while this grand drama is unfolding under the golden dome, local governments all over the state will be scrounging for whatever resources they can get to patch up the damage from last year’s record flooding while getting ready for the next round. As a former city councilor, my heart goes out to them. Relying on FEMA to shore up your infrastructure is like staking your retirement on lottery tickets.
Vermont doesn’t need a bold new mitigation effort. We need a bold new adaptation effort. Yes, we want to live in an environmentally progressive state and, yes, Vermont’s small size makes it a good laboratory for trying new things. But how many times do we need to see our state capital under water (pardon the pun) before the message sinks in? Local communities throughout the state need real dollars, not credits or matches or incentives, but real state aid, to fund their own sorely needed adaptation projects.
In their dialogue over the Affordable Heat Act, Scott and the legislative leadership were arguing from different universes. The legislators had their sights set on the lofty goal of reducing global carbon emissions; Scott had his sights set on the health and well-being of Vermonters.
As someone who is gravely concerned about the evolving climate crisis, I believe the Governor got it right.
Columns are opinion pieces regularly contributed by a select group of writers. Columns reflect the opinions of the writer and do not represent the views of the Essex Reporter.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here