George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor.
Let’s start with a simple number: 0.1%
That’s what Vermont contributes to America’s atmospheric CO2 emissions, according to the US Dept of Energy. It’s less than any other state. Massachusetts contributes ten times as much; New York, thirty times.
Yet, to fight global warming the Vermont Legislature wants to shrink our CO2 levels even more with a host of new carbon emission rules that could indirectly raise the cost of living and penalize many small businesses.
Heating fuels, utility rates, new cars and trucks could all see big price hikes. No one’s sure what the costs will be because there are too many variables and unknowables. The experts can’t agree – which is always a bad sign.
The cause of this toil and trouble is Vermont’s Global Warming Solutions Act, which the Legislature approved in 2020 after President Trump, with the fascinating logic that climate change is a hoax, pulled the United States out of the Paris Agreement which had established an international framework for reducing fossil fuel emissions.
To push back against Trump and maintain solidarity with the Paris Agreement, Vermont legislators passed the GWSA, which calls for reducing CO2 emissions to 26% below 2005 levels by 2025, 40% below 1990 emissions by 2030, and 80% below 1990 emissions by 2050.
To comply with their self-imposed deadlines, they proposed new regulations for selling home heating fuels and automobiles – Vermont’s two main sources of carbon emissions – with the aim of finalizing them in the 2025 session. The delay was to provide time to study the impacts of what they were proposing. The studies have been completed and they paint a hazy and troubling picture.
The rules would impose new fees on residential fuel oil, propane, and kerosene that Vermont heating fuel companies bring into the state. The companies could offset the fees by getting their customers to weatherize their homes and installing heat pumps, but no one’s sure how all that’s supposed to happen or exactly what the costs would be.
The rules also say 35% of new vehicles sold in the state must be electric. Automobile manufacturers – Subaru, Ford, Kia, etc. – would work with their affiliated Vermont dealerships to somehow make this happen. Otherwise, they too would be hit with fees.
The good news is that they could offset the fees by purchasing carbon credits. The disturbing news is that Elon Musk, the South African born, Mars enraptured, soon-to-be Trump advisor on government efficiency, has cornered the market on carbon credits. Yikes!
Despite all the uncertainty, everyone agrees that most of the costs will ultimately land on Vermont households, passed along by car dealers, heating fuel distributors, and other affected businesses.
Adding to the drama is the shadow of the Conservation Law Foundation waiting in the wings to sue the state if it doesn’t meet its own GWSA targets. Environmental lawsuits on this scale have a history of being very costly and winding up in bad places, so no one wants to see it happen.
Now comes the really interesting part. Last year, Democrats and Progressives were able to override Gov. Phil Scott’s vetoes of their environmental legislation. But that’s not going to happen in 2025. Vermont Democrats and Progressive lost the legislative supermajority that made them bullet-proof against Scott’s vetoes, and it was voter disapproval of what the Democrats were proposing that caused much of the political turnover.
Democrats must now work with Republicans, who generally share their concerns about climate change but have very different ideas of how to confront it. If the two sides can’t come up with something that meets the governor’s liking – well, the Conservation Law Foundation is standing by.
Julie Moore, head of Vermont’s Agency of Natural Resources, has suggested that the Legislature push back the GWSA deadlines in their 2025 session to buy more time for analyzing the impacts of the penalties that her agency would be required to impose.
Considering the daunting challenges facing the Legislature this session in reforming education funding and keeping Vermont’s health care system afloat, Democrats might want to listen to her.
Delaying legislation to gather more information is the oldest political trick in the book for killing something without leaving your fingerprints on the murder weapon, so environmentalists are wary of it.
But if our carbon emissions are already so low that the net effect of the proposed new rules will have zero impact on global warming but a harmful impact on financially strapped Vermonters and put more money in the pocket of the world’s richest man, it might be time to hit the pause button.
Yes, we’re facing a global climate crisis and time is running out. Enacting aggressive new policies that ignore the state’s political realities and alienate voters is not the way to deal with it.
Columns are opinion pieces regularly contributed by a select group of writers. Columns reflect the opinions of the writer and do not represent the views of the Essex Reporter.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here