George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor.
If you need a break from the excitement of watching our national government imploding, let’s talk about something that’s close to all Vermonters’ hearts this time of year: road salt.
First, do you know how road salt melts ice?
I’ll defer to the Vermont-appropriate description provided by the Lake Champlain Sea Grant Institute:
“When we spread sodium chloride and it mixes with water, it breaks into its individual components, called ions, which are sodium and chloride. These ions act like referees in a hockey game preventing fights between players; that is, the sodium and chloride ions get in between water molecules and inhibit them from joining together to form ice crystals.”
Exactly. It’s like a little hockey game. The problem is that when the game is over and temperatures rise, the ions of sodium and chloride buddy up with the water molecules and they all trickle their way off the road and into the groundwater which flows into nearby streams, rivers, lakes and ponds. The Lake Champlain Sea Grant Institute, like other environmental organizations, is alarmed at the rising levels of chloride they’re seeing in aquatic ecosystems throughout Vermont and urging the state and local governments to do something about it.
Why is too much chloride bad? Freshwater plants, fish, and other organisms have evolved to handle trace amounts of naturally occurring chloride in their environment. Sudden increases can be toxic to them, and many lakes and ponds, including Lake Champlain, are approaching toxic levels.
Vermont motorists should also be concerned. It’s not just the icky feeling of driving a car that looks like a giant frosted donut. Road salt speeds up the natural rusting process that occurs in iron-based metals.
The analogy for this molecular process comes from the folks at Hemmings Motor News in Bennington, who publish the “Bible” of car collecting:
“So, in a way, we can look at driving on salted roads as akin to repeatedly bashing your head against a brick wall. Sure, we’re all gonna die anyway, but some behaviors will certainly accelerate that process.”
You gotta love the road-salt-inspired prose.
The rusting effect of road salt also eats away at culverts and bridges, which is a bad thing for a state that’s seeing more frequent storms and flooding from climate change every year.
The Vermont Agency of Transportation has been decreasing the amount of salt it spreads on state highways by switching to brine and wetted-salt mixtures that are cheaper, more effective, and use less salt. So, what’s causing chloride levels to rise?
According to Vtrans, the excess salt is caused by cities, towns, and private property owners spreading much more salt than they need to.
They do this for different reasons. They may lack the equipment to spray brine or pre-wet the salt before spreading it, which helps it stick to the road better and activates its anti-freezing powers quicker. They may also be concerned about liability for accidents caused by unsalted or under-salted roads. Or they may be doing it to keep their constituents happy or just because it’s what they’ve always done and don’t know any better.
For all these reasons, the Vermont Senate’s Natural Resources and Energy Committee is working on a bill, S.29, that would establish a voluntary certification program for municipal and private organizations where they would learn about current best practices for applying road salt in ways that minimize usage and environmental impacts, while keeping roads reasonably ice-free.
Those who complete the certification process could no longer be held liable for accidents allegedly caused by under-salted roads, as long as they follow the program’s guidelines.
Although many details are still being worked out, S.29 looks like a smart piece of legislation from a municipal government point of view because its voluntary approach gives cities and towns time to plan ahead.
Many – perhaps most – municipal highway departments aren’t in a position to adopt state-of-the-art practices because they lack the right equipment. Salt-spreading trucks are big ticket items for any town’s budget. They usually perform double duty as snowplows and can cost well over $100,000. Other equipment needed to transition from rock salt to brine or wetted-salt is equally expensive.
Town governments need to anticipate these kinds of purchases years ahead of time so they can save up for them. Knowing that their staffs can get the right training and that they’ll have less liability if they follow the program’s recommendations will be an incentive for them to purchase the kind of equipment that can take advantage of the latest best practices instead of just purchasing newer versions of their worn-out stuff. It might even make them do it sooner.
This is a good example of the state working constructively with municipal governments at a pace they can handle. Thumbs up on this one.
Columns are opinion pieces regularly contributed by a select group of writers. Columns reflect the opinions of the writer and do not represent the views of the Essex Reporter.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here