George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor.
It’s budget building time in Essex Junction and Essex Town.
It’s the season when the two elected boards scrutinize the departmental and municipal service budgets proposed by managers for the coming year, looking for efficiencies that might help limit tax increases.
Three of the budgets they’ll be looking at – one in the city, one in the town, and one they share – are so fundamentally efficient that they should come under a different kind of scrutiny, as in: Should we be doing something more for them?
I’m talking about the Essex Junction and Essex Town fire departments, and Essex Rescue, which, if you don’t know, is an independent non-profit that provides ambulance and first responder emergency medical services to the greater Essex-Underhill-Westford area. It receives about 20 percent of its population-based funding from Essex Junction and Essex Town.
The reason for the accolades is in the budget numbers.
In this year’s city and town budgets, which extend to July 2026, Essex Junction and Essex Town are spending $1.8 million on their combined fire departments and their shared contribution to Essex Rescue.
South Burlington is spending $7.4 million for the same services. Williston is spending $3.9 million.
On a per capita basis, that translates to South Burlington spending about $341 per person for fire and EMS services; Williston spending $395; and Essex Junction & Essex Town combined spending about $82.
Sure, every local government has its own accounting practices. For example, one might include fire department administrative, capital, or dispatch costs in their fire department budgets; another might put those costs in separate budgets. It’s tricky to make apples-to-apples comparisons with municipal finances.
But the bottom line is clear: Year after year, the Essex community gets an amazing bargain from its current fire and EMS services structure.
How is this possible? Volunteers. All three Essex first responder organizations rely heavily on paid on-call volunteers for their operations. South Burlington and Williston have full-time paid professional staff.
In very simple terms, by taking advantage of the fact that well-trained volunteers can handle fire and EMS services about as well as professionals (no aspersions to professional responders intended) the city and town governments routinely save millions of dollars.
The key, of course, is having a reliable pool of capable, community-service-minded people who are willing to commit to the long hours of training as well as the disruptions to their work and family lives imposed by on-call scheduling.
This is where the institutional culture of disciplined public service plays a role. The Essex Junction Fire Department got started in 1893 as a volunteer bucket brigade and acquired its first horse drawn “chemical” engine in 1895. (For history nerds, that’s just 30 years after the Civil War!) For 130 years, it’s been an entry point for people looking to help protect and improve their community. Current Essex Junction City Council member Tim Miller has served with the fire department for many years. Other elected officials and board members also started their careers with the Essex Junction Fire Department.
The Essex Town Fire Department was created by the town government in 1973 to meet the needs of a rapidly growing community around the Town center. Essex Rescue got started in 1971 as an unaffiliated service relying entirely on donations.
In other words, all three organizations have decades of tradition built into their DNA that provides vision and focus for new volunteers which would be impossible for a local government to recreate from scratch. All three have established cultures of altruistic service.
The downsides of relying on volunteers are the uncertainties for providing 24/7 coverage and the high turnover and burn out rate.
As Essex Rescue’s executive director Colleen Ballard says, volunteers “… often burnout faster because they are trying to balance everything in their life,” and when something “has to give in their lives and priorities,” it’s their volunteer activities.
All three organizations struggle, at times, to attract and retain new volunteers. It’s their biggest challenge and something that we should all care about because transitioning to professional full-time fire and emergency medical services would add millions to local budgets with no significant improvement.
But as Ballard points out, it’s more than just the financial savings to the community; it’s the culture of service above self that volunteers bring.
One of Mahatma Gandhi’s most insightful quotes was: “The best way to find yourself is to lose yourself in the service of others.” It’s a great piece of wisdom that every young person should heed.
At a moment in our national political culture when (weirdly) empathy is getting a bad rap, we should be grateful for the tradition of volunteer service that still seems to be going strong in our community and whisper a little prayer of hope that it continues.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here