George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor.
The Essex Junction Development Review Board at its public hearing on Sept.18 upheld the city’s demand that local cannabis cultivator Jason Struthers immediately cease his farming operation or face a $200 per day fine.
Although Struthers has vowed to appeal the verdict to Vermont Superior Court, the city DRB’s unanimous decision very likely brings to a close a convoluted and fraught three-year legal saga that garnered regional media attention because of Struthers’ quirky use of duck poop to fertilize his plants, culminating in a Vermont Supreme Court ruling — all because of misleading language in the original legislation that legalized recreational cannabis.
The brief history of the case is that in 2022 Struthers was granted a license by Vermont’s Cannabis Control Commission to grow pot for commercial sale in the half acre lot behind his Essex Junction home on 8 Taft St., even though it was within a city residential zone that prohibits farming.
If that sounds contradictory, it’s because the commission was trying to comply with the wording of the legislature’s 2020 bill that legalized recreational cannabis cultivation, which said that as far as local municipal laws are concerned, “a cannabis establishment shall not be regulated as “farming” under the Required Agricultural Practices” rules. The RAP rules refer to state regulations meant to protect groundwater from agricultural runoff.
If you interpret that statement as saying that municipalities cannot regulate cannabis as “farming,” you’re not alone. The Vermont Superior Court interpreted it the same way.
And so when Essex Junction told Struthers that, regardless of his grower’s license, his operation violated city rules against farming in residential zones, and he appealed to Vermont Superior Court, saying that his operation was exempt from city ordinances because it came under the jurisdiction of RAP rules, the court ruled in his favor.
Only when Struthers’ neighbors, who must live with the pungent stench of duck manure combined with drying cannabis, appealed the Superior Court’s decision to the Vermont Supreme Court did all parties finally get clarity on what the Vermont Legislature was trying to say, which is this: Municipal rules can’t impede or overlap the state’s own rules regulating agricultural water runoff from Vermont farms.
What it was not saying is that municipalities can’t impose unrelated restrictions on farming or agricultural practices. Municipalities absolutely have a right to restrict farming to certain areas, even cannabis farming.
And so just because some aspects of a prohibited cannabis farm might hypothetically come under RAP rules doesn’t mean the farm can’t be prohibited.
The Supreme Court remanded the case back to Superior Court, which said mea culpa and reversed its earlier decision against the City of Essex Junction.
Wasting little time, the city sent Struthers a Notice of Violation last July, ordering him to cease his operation. Struthers appealed to the city’s Development Review Board, which is how it all landed back at the Lincoln Hall public meeting room where it started three years ago.
Having watched this whole boondoggle bounce between public hearings and courtrooms over last three years, I’m going to stick my neck out and say it seems patently absurd that it took all this time and money to get clarification on something that should have been crystal clear right from the get-go. And I don’t blame the city one bit. If it takes a Supreme Court-level legal analysis to set things right, then how exactly is a city official – or a city attorney for that matter – supposed to figure it out?
Even more bewildering is that it required an appeal to the Supreme Court from hard-pressed neighbors in Essex Junction for municipalities throughout the state to get the legal clarity they need to deal with cannabis cultivation operations.
Vermont cities, and many towns as well, have zoning ordinances saying where you can have farms and where you cannot. And yet the Vermont government passed a law that appeared to say that local communities can’t regulate small cannabis growers, but was really saying that they can, except for when local rules might bump into state rules about groundwater runoff from farms.
The neighbors around Struthers’ cannabis operation have been through a three-year ordeal that was totally avoidable had the state been more deliberative before handing down rules that intuitively made no sense. A densely developed city can’t prohibit farming in its residential neighborhoods? Are you serious?
Cannabis sales are on track to generate over $30 million in tax revenue this year, of which the state will take the lion’s share while municipalities shoulder the regulatory burden. Perhaps some responsible party within state government could use some of that money to purchase a “thank you” card and send it to the heroic Taft Street neighbors without whom local communities all over Vermont would still be dealing with the state’s mess.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here