Column: Social media is primary news source for young people

Posted

Marybeth Redmond is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. Redmond is a long-time journalist who served as state representative of Essex Town from 2019-2022. Reach out to her at: marybethredmond@comcast.net


My 22-year-old son Liam predicted the outcome of the presidential election weeks before Election Day. He saw Donald Trump’s victory coalescing, while I suggested that he, my son, was overreacting. (To be transparent, he and I both voted for Kamala Harris.)

My son was monitoring the social media landscape on sites like X (formerly Twitter), YouTube, and Instagram, and it was clear to him that young, white males in his demographic were posting and sharing content that skewed overwhelmingly in support of the Republican candidate.

On sites you’ve probably never heard of like the Nelk Boys and Adin Ross, my son was seeing a tsunami of frustration related to the high price of groceries, the lack of affordable housing, and general economic dissatisfaction despite decreasing inflation.

 

He also noticed college-educated males sharing memes and video clips from the county’s most popular podcast The Joe Rogan Experience (with 18.6 million subscribers) as signs of “coolness.”

A just-released Pew Research Center study confirms that younger Americans are using social media influencers like Joe Rogan (and others along the full political spectrum) for their sources of news and political information, not just sites that dish comedy or lifestyle.

Pew surveyed more than 10,000 Americans in the summer of 2024 and found that one-in-five adults – 37 percent under the age of 30 – get their news regularly from influencers on social media.

The study defines “news influencers” as individuals who regularly post about “current events and civic issues on social media” and have at least “100,000 followers on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, X or YouTube.”

Most are located on the social media site X, where 85 percent have a presence, followed by Instagram (50 percent) and YouTube (44 percent), though it’s common for influencers to have a multi-site presence to maximize their audiences (27 percent are on five or more sites).

News influencers skew overwhelmingly male – about 63 percent to 30 percent female, according to the study results. 

In terms of political bent, slightly more news influencers are right leaning, with 27 percent identifying as Republican, conservative or pro-Donald Trump compared to 21 percent who see themselves as Democratic, liberal or pro-Kamala Harris.

Many news influencers – 59 percent – monetize their online presence in some way, whether through subscriptions, donations or merchandise sales. So, getting eyeballs to their sites to push products is a central goal.

Also alarming to me, a trained journalist, is that most new influencers have no past or present affiliation with a news organization, a whopping 77 percent!

I can hear the refrain of “OK, Boomer” coming from the mouths of Generation Z’ers reading this column. Something to the effect of: “we don’t trust institutions in general, let alone media institutions.” 

It’s true that all media outlets contain various levels of bias. They are run by humans after all, who have preferences despite their best efforts to seek balance, a hallmark of journalism.

Those surveyed by Pew said that news influencers helped them better understand current events and exposed them to perspectives they hadn’t seen elsewhere in the mainstream media. That’s an upside, for sure. An informed citizenry is crucial for a flourishing democracy; and exposure to a wide range of viewpoints can bring more creative solutions to the fore.

But a serious downside is that none of the rules of journalism apply to these news influencer sites. The Golden Rules of the Fourth Estate such as attribution (citing who said what or where info comes from), fact-checking details for their accuracy and truthfulness, and interviewing diverse sources to achieve balanced reporting do not apply.

My take is that while these influencers offer young people news exposure and quirky, alternative viewpoints, overall, they are contributing murkiness and confusion to the post-truth world I believe we find ourselves swimming in these days. 

Columns are opinion pieces regularly contributed by a select group of writers. Columns reflect the opinions of the writer and do not represent the views of the Essex Reporter.

#ernltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here