Column: Seeing humanity of incarcerated through art

Posted

Marybeth Redmond is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. Redmond is a long-time journalist who served as state representative of Essex Town from 2019-2022. Reach her at  marybethredmond@comcast.net


I cherish original art, handicrafts, poignant writing – truly artistic expression of any kind. I am a lover of color and texture, and all things homemade that radiate simple beauty.

It’s the receiving of an original watercolor painted by an inmate more than 20 years ago that propelled me into the work of supporting the incarcerated.

A slender package arrived at my door, a wedding gift at that time. It was from a man incarcerated in Otisville, New York, whom I had visited in-person once or twice. Before Ned, as I’ll call him, had been charged with murder, he had resided at the homeless shelter my husband ran in the Bronx in the late 1980s.

The painting gifted to us was of a Maine lighthouse perched on a rocky outcrop bathed in sunsetting light. I was struck by the sophistication of the artwork; it conveyed depth and precision. Delicate brushstrokes brought luminescent ripples of water to life. The painting exuded harmony without a hint of the harsh, isolated world in which its creator resided.

For reasons I can’t explain, this work of art provided an aperture into Ned that was not visible to me before. I could see him fresh and whole, beyond the worse thing he had ever done. I certainly didn’t condone Ned’s actions, nor believe he shouldn’t serve time to rehabilitate himself. But I was able to see his value and humanity through his ability to create great beauty. 

My five years of creating with justice-involved women in Vermont correctional facilities though the writinginsidevt program that I co-founded had a similar impact on me.

Week after week, listening to the poetry and prose of 12-15 women sharing vulnerably in a circle, well, it changed me and how I orient to those who commit terrible acts. It didn’t lessen my desire for individual accountability or public safety for citizens. But I began to understand the unique pathways that lead people to criminal behavior, women in particular.

If you asked me to highlight the central lesson that I learned about justice-involved women through those years of writing together, it would be the connection of past trauma to future incarceration.

 

In 2013, I co-edited a book of some of those “inside” writings entitled, “Hear Me, See Me: Incarcerated Women Write.” The volume fleshes out their harrowing stories, as well as their efforts to heal. Heather’s poem “Screaming in Silence” about physical violence by a boyfriend; Jen’s story “Shattered Trust” about healing from childhood sexual abuse by uncles; and Tess’s account “Crawling on My Knees” about the things she did to support her own substance misuse – describe the reality for some Vermont women locked in cycles of multi-generational trauma. 

A just-released survey of 100 women residing at the Chittenden Regional Correctional Facility confirms these realities. Administered anonymously last November by the Vermont Network for Domestic and Sexual Violence (where I serve as a board member), the data lines up with years of anecdotes I’ve heard from the women: 97 percent have experienced or witnessed domestic violence (40 percent before the age of 5); 82 percent have experienced or witnessed sexual violence (47.6 percent before the age of 10); and 62 percent have been forced or pressured to engage in labor or sexual activities in exchange for money, substances or basic needs. 

We need to see this reality for what it is. There is a clear relationship between lifetime experience of domestic or sexual violence and the risk for incarceration among women. No one grows up with the aim to live a life of disorder and illegal activity, no one. 

Justice-involved women in Vermont deserve a robust system of support, rehabilitation, and healing. I support the development of a new, smaller, gender-responsive women’s correctional facility with a reentry center component that will reduce a current 40 percent recidivism rate. And I support it here in Essex. 

This past holiday season, I am told, few programs were planned at the women’s correctional facility in South Burlington due to so many contractors and volunteers being on vacation. Heather Newcomb, program manager for Vermont Works for Women, floated the idea of a facility-wide art project to keep the women occupied.

Teams formed according to the units the women reside in, and they created their own winter village scenes (see accompanying photo). The competition began on Dec. 20 and was judged by facility staff on Dec. 30.

The Department of Corrections, along with donations from the United Church of Christ in Hinesburg, provided frosting, M&Ms, gum drops, Starlight mints, red licorice and other yummy treats for the project. According to Newcomb, “all of the villages were winners since the women were really engaged and went above and beyond what I had imagined.”

Once again, the humanity and value of the artists shone through.

Columns are opinion pieces regularly contributed by a select group of writers. Columns reflect the opinions of the writer and do not represent the views of the Essex Reporter.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here