George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor.
Donning my “former city councilor” hat for a moment, I’d like to suggest there was an important contributing reason for the defeat of the EWSD budget in April that no one is talking about.
The separation of Essex Junction from Essex Town has radically changed the municipal tax landscape on both sides of the city-town border. Most homeowners in Essex Town have seen a $500-plus increase in their non-school property taxes in the three budget cycles since 2022. Essex Junction homeowners saw a $300-plus increase in the same period. These increases were for “average” homes with an assessed value (not market value) of $280,000, which means that hundreds of homeowners in both communities saw municipal tax increases that were much higher. These numbers are based on annual reports published by the City and Town finance departments.
To put this in perspective, typical year-to-year municipal tax increases in Essex Junction and Essex Town have been in the $20-$40-dollar range over the last two decades. During my 16 years in elected office in Essex Junction prior to 2022, a $100 increase in the average homeowner’s municipal taxes was unheard of.
The surge in taxes is not because the Essex Selectboard and Essex Junction City Council suddenly became profligate in their spending. When Essex Junction departed from the Town, it took nearly 44% of the Town’s tax base with it. The Town Selectboard faced the stark choice of either making draconian cuts in Town services or proposing unparallelled tax increases. They did a good job using federal COVID-19 funds and other cost-saving measures to buffer the initial impact of separation on property owners, but they could only do so much.
On the Essex Junction side, the City Council had to fill gaps in administrative services that the Town had provided. They also had to reinstate and fully fund a city manager, clerk, and finance director, which were positions that the Village of Essex Junction had shared with the Town during the village-town unified manager years between 2015-2022.
Total combined municipal expenditures for Essex Junction and Essex Town have ballooned from $21 million in 2022, the year prior to separation, to $28 million in the two recently approved FY 25 City and Town budgets. That’s a $7 million increase in municipal spending in four years. Contractual increases in staff salaries and higher than usual inflation account for some of that increase, but to give some perspective consider that total municipal spending for Essex Junction and Essex Town increased by only $770 thousand in the previous four-year period, 2018-2022.
One of the main drivers of the increased municipal spending has been the dismantling of the hybrid village-town shared service agreements that were put in place over the seven years prior to separation. Not only did separation require fully staffing two completely independent municipal administrations, but the cost efficiencies gained over six years by consolidating village-town municipal services, which were estimated to be in the $3.5 million range, were suddenly lost.
City councils, school boards, and selectboards operate within their own rarified domains. They perceive a world of difference between municipal spending and school spending. But for homeowners, particularly those without school-age kids, the memo on the check they write says “property taxes,” and that’s pretty much it. And when you hit those homeowners with $500-plus increases on the municipal side of their tax bills in three years, it’s no surprise when they just say no to a proposed 20 percent increase in school taxes, even among stalwart supporters of the Essex-Westford School District. I’m not saying that this entirely explains the EWSD budget defeat in April, but it changed a dicey situation into a sure bet.
The EWSD board acted responsibly after the April school budget defeat. They’ve aggressively sought public input and made significant cuts in their proposed budget which will be up for a vote again on May 7. We’ll see if it’s enough. And our state representatives realize, I hope, that the Legislature bears most of the responsibility for this year’s school budget fiasco. A few minor tweaks to the state’s algorithmically problematic school funding formula won’t cut it if it means the EWSD board is once again put in the position of asking for a massive tax increase.
What we all need to consider is that separating Essex Junction from Essex Town dramatically increased the cost of local government for everyone and, therefore, dramatically reduced the tolerance for big jumps in school spending. I hear the term ‘inflection point’ used a lot these days, and I suspect we may have just stumbled into one.
Columns are opinion pieces regularly contributed by a select group of writers. Columns reflect the opinions of the writer and do not represent the views of the Essex Reporter.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here