Column: Olympic ad is creeping people out, and rightly so

Posted

George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor.


[NOTE: No generative AI chatbots were used in the creation of this column.]

If you've been watching the Paris Olympics, and you really should because they’re much less terrifying than the presidential race, you may have seen an ad for Gemini AI, Google’s new artificial intelligence app that can, among many other amazing things, help you write more grammatically eloquent letters.

The ad features the brilliant U.S. track & field star Sydney McLaughlin-Levrone and a young girl who wants to be like her. As the video alternates between clips of McLaughlin-Levrone and the girl running, the voiceover features the girl’s adoring dad sharing his aspirations for his daughter with Gemini. He sees bright things for her and seems to think Gemini agrees with him. So, he asks Gemini to help his daughter write a fan letter to McLaughlin-Levrone, expressing her admiration but also letting her know that one day, tongue in cheek, she plans to break her world record.

The ad is heartfelt and charming and, as many media pundits and commenters have said, very creepy.

In order of prevalence, I’ll list the top three reasons it creeped people out. First, why doesn’t the dad help his daughter write the letter? Isn’t that what dads are supposed to do? Is producing a perfect letter really the point? What about the opportunity to nurture your child’s creative thinking?

Reason two, obviously, is why would we encourage a kid to rely on an app to write a fan letter, or anything else for that matter? It’s one thing for writing tools to correct spelling and help with grammar, but this goes way beyond that. The sense of the video is that because McLaughlin-Levrone is polished and perfect, the girl’s letter must also be polished and perfect. Nothing less will do. No mistakes; no childish language; no silly ideas. Just fluent, machine-like perfection.

And creeped-out reason number three is what should McGlaughlin-Levrone make of such a letter? As one commenter said, wouldn’t this be like receiving a weird greeting card? A commercialized generic expression of sincere warmth sent to you by someone claiming to be a young girl who aspires to be a track star, but who writes like a tenured professor? Wouldn’t McGlaughlin-Levrone be more likely to consign it to the trash, with a dismissive shudder, rather than tape it to her refrigerator?

From their tone and syntax, I’m guessing most of the online critics of the ad didn’t use generative AI tools to express their angst. Some were irked, some were disturbed. Some said it was tone deaf and dystopian. One said it was the “WORST” ad ever made, which I’m not sure I agree with. (I recall an old Budweiser ad featuring animatronic frogs.)

One critic wanted to give the head of Google an “atomic wedgie.” I think we can all agree with this, at least in spirit.

We’re inundated with ads that are melodramatic and silly, so why did this particular ad strike such a nerve? Because Google is one of the masters of the online megaverse and, like it or not, an irresistible force in our lives. Perhaps it’s all just a misunderstanding but this seemingly innocent little ad speaks to our deepest fears about artificial intelligence worming its way into our lives wrapped in a sugar-coating of caring, helpful goodness. It just wants us to be the best we can be. Yet we all suspect, rightly, that gigantic global corporations like Google aren’t creating these expensive, energy-consuming platforms out of pure love for humanity. They may not necessarily have dark purposes, but they have commercial purposes and, most importantly, a very big stake in getting us to see the world the way they see it: Technology can solve all our problems, even cute ones like little girls writing fan mail.

And what we surrender in the bargain is our own creative minds, as messy and flawed and ill-informed as they may be. As one critic put it: “Use our brain instead of yours.”

The intense backlash will surely have Google rethinking where it wants to go with this ad campaign. But will it fundamentally change Google’s overarching view of what its Gemini chatbot can and should be doing for us?

Not likely.

This little skirmish is a reminder that we’re now in a continuous struggle to shape what one critic of the ad called the “hivemind” that ultimately embraces these technologies and allows them to thrive. We must learn to push back on AI when it encroaches upon our humanity.

We’ve got a lot to lose.

As author and media critic Will Leitch said about the ad, writing on X: “It takes a little chunk out of my soul every time I see it.”

Exactly.

Columns are opinion pieces regularly contributed by a select group of writers. Columns reflect the opinions of the writer and do not represent the views of the Essex Reporter.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here