Marybeth Redmond is a long-time journalist who served as state representative from Essex in the Vermont House. This is her final column for The Essex Reporter.
Journalism in the United States in 2026 is both resilient and under profound strain. Reporters continue to investigate abuses of power, document human suffering, and provide the public with essential information.
Yet trust in the news media is near historic lows, political pressure is intensifying, and a post-truth environment has weakened standards of evidence. The institution once known as the Fourth Estate because of its watchdog function in holding power to account on behalf of the public—now finds its authority contested from nearly every direction.
One central concern is the erosion of trust, often framed as a problem of bias or imbalance. For decades, American journalism prized “balanced reporting,” but today that norm is increasingly questioned. When evidence overwhelmingly supports one conclusion, reflexive “both sides” framing can muddy the truth rather than sharpen it.
At the same time, audiences conditioned by partisan media companies interpret editorial choices as ideological signals, reinforcing suspicion of reporting that challenges their worldview. The result is a feedback loop in which journalists are accused of bias no matter how carefully they report, while audiences retreat into information silos.
Equally troubling is the growing pressure on editorial independence, particularly within large corporate news organizations. Recent events at CBS News and 60 Minutes have become emblematic of this tension.
In December 2025, a 60 Minutes investigative segment examining the treatment of migrants deported under the Trump administration was reportedly pulled after clearing editorial and legal review. Network leadership cited the need for further reporting, but the decision drew internal criticism and public concern that CBS’s current leadership was seeking to reduce scrutiny of the current Administration.
For a news program long considered a crown jewel of American investigative journalism, the episode raised alarms about whether corporate caution and political fear are quietly reshaping editorial judgment.
These concerns strike at the heart of journalism’s role. Its democratic function depends not on access or ratings, but on independence and the willingness to ask uncomfortable questions even when doing so risks retaliation. When news organizations soften coverage to avoid lawsuits, regulatory threats, or presidential ire, they weaken the very guardrails that distinguish a free press from state-sponsored media.
All of this unfolds within a post-truth environment where misinformation spreads faster than reporting and identity often overrides evidence. Research shows that false claims aligned with political identity are remarkably resistant to correction. Journalists are thus tasked not only with reporting facts, but with doing so in a culture increasingly skeptical that facts exist at all.
Yet there are bright spots. One hopeful model can be found in the growth of nonprofit, non-corporate journalism, particularly in places like Vermont. There, locally rooted, mission-driven news organizations like VT Digger, Vermont Public, and Seven Days have emerged to fill gaps left by shrinking corporate media.
Funded by readers, foundations, and community support rather than shareholders, these outlets prioritize accountability, transparency, and local impact. Their work suggests that when journalism is treated as a public good rather than a commodity, trust can be rebuilt from the ground up.
For news consumers, sustaining journalism requires intentional engagement: diversifying news sources, distinguishing reporting from opinion, supporting nonprofit journalism, and resisting the urge to amplify unverified claims.
For journalists and newsroom leaders, it means recommitting to transparency, resisting political intimidation, and remembering that credibility is earned not through caution, but through courage.
The Fourth Estate has never been perfect, but it has been indispensable. In 2026, its survival depends on whether journalists and citizens alike are willing to defend truth-telling, even when it unsettles power, and even when it costs.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here