George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor.
I’m writing this on a slick new mini-pc I just got. I can carry it around in my pocket (not sure why I’d want to) and it’s a gazillion times faster than the clunky brute I wrote my first articles on back in the dark ages of cyber history.
My new toy is connected to a high resolution flatscreen, a gaming keyboard (great for fast typing), and a trackball mouse (great for fast editing).
I bought the entire rig online and supercheap at — you guessed it — Amazon.
You see where I’m going here, right?
The honchos at Amazon didn’t choose Essex, Vermont as a site for one of their new distribution centers because they wanted to tussle with our chilled-out lifestyle and progressive values. They chose Essex so they can more efficiently (and cheaply!) deliver the stuff we already buy from them.
Stroll through our neighborhoods and you routinely see UPS and FedEx trucks zipping around like part of the landscape, bearing treasures from afar.
According to the ecommerce and marketing analytics site Jungle Scout (I love that name), shipping is a major battleground in the cutthroat but staggeringly profitable online business world. About 66% of Americans expect free shipping to be available on all their orders which, for Amazon, means they must pick up the shipping cost. And about 50% are willing to pay for faster delivery — next day or within two or three days — than the standard free shipping time.
Amazon can claw back more of its incoming revenue by building its own infrastructure to provide faster and cheaper shipping for more instant customer gratification.
You can’t argue with their logic, but I sincerely hope the community protests they’ve triggered will make them think twice about coming to Essex. I really do. As a writer and reader of books, I hate their malign dominance of the publishing world. Handing them a loss would be particularly sweet since Phoenix Books, our local bookseller, is leading the charge.
I also have this quaint idea that valuable space in our industrial parks should be reserved for companies that actually manufacture things, rather than just warehousing things and distributing them. For our local economy to thrive, we need to be more about making and conserving, and less about consuming.
But I can’t ignore the conundrums.
First, as a former city official I’m sympathetic to the town government’s position. You write zoning and land development rules to reflect community values but also to comply with state law and then hope for the best. If an applicant checks all the boxes, there’s not much you can do. I’ve been in that hotseat lots of times. You hate to see your constituents unhappy but denying an application just because you don’t like who’s submitting it can land you in court. I also know that a massive new distribution center would give a nice boost to the town’s tax base, and new jobs are always welcome.
But the bigger conundrum is us. We helped create the monster. Now that it’s smiling in at us through the front porch window, we’re going to pretend we don’t know it?
Maybe our outrage will hurt Amazon’s feelings, and they’ll pick some other spot for their new distribution center. Maybe someone on an Essex Town board or in an Act 250 hearing will find some snag to upend their application. But I doubt either of those things will happen. Big corporations do their homework well ahead of time, and this probably isn’t the first Amazon distribution center application to be protested.
But even if they do go elsewhere, we shouldn’t celebrate too loudly because it doesn’t solve our existential dilemma. We may live in idyllic Vermont, but we also live in global cyber-land, and the community protests over Amazon suggest that we haven’t figured out how to reconcile those two things.
I could have shopped around for my mini-pc ensemble at the local big box stores. But I knew I’d find a wider selection and better prices online. Plus, it’s hard to resist the pleasurable buzz of comparison shopping and reading reviews. And once you’ve made your choice — voila! — the UPS guy delivers the package to your doorstep.
Online services bring the whole world to the black screens in our homes, and in return we’ve made them immensely rich and powerful, to the point where they can rattle our real lives.
The phenomenon was on full display at Trump’s inauguration in January, when the seats of honor didn’t go to poets, philosophers, and statesmen, but to Zuckerberg, Musk, and Bezos. This coalescence of techno-capitalism at the heart of American government shocked us, and we shared our concerns on Facebook and X, using electronic devices purchased through Amazon.
Oh, the irony.
Columns are opinion pieces regularly contributed by a select group of writers. Columns reflect the opinions of the writer and do not represent the views of the Essex Reporter.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here