Column: How should Essex approach redistricting?

Posted

George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor.

Let’s talk frankly.

Anyone in the Essex community who cares about our schools should be unhappy with Act 73, the Vermont Legislature’s push to consolidate school districts.

We don’t wish to be “redistricted.” We don’t need the state’s help.

In fact, left to their own devices, the Essex Westford School Board could probably decrease property taxes while increasing resources for our schools, if the state would just take its byzantine funding formulas and go away.

So, should we tell our state legislators that they need to say “no” to redistricting when they return to Montpelier in January? Should we tell them to come up with another plan? Fix the state’s health care system first, as a roundabout way of lowering school costs?

Maybe. But before telling them to go back to the drawing board on education reform, we might want to think about what they’ll be facing this winter.

According to U.S. Rep. Becca Balint, up to 45,000 Vermonters could be losing their health insurance later in 2026 under the Trump administration’s brutal budget. Thousands more could be hit with double-digit premium increases. Some Vermont hospitals could be forced to close. Other Vermont institutions and nonprofits that are already reeling from drastic cuts in federal funding will be looking to the Legislature for help.

And that’s just the predictable bad stuff. The unpredictable bad stuff is worse.

For example, without any substantive explanation, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, which oversees FEMA, just cut off the funding that the town of Burke had been receiving to recover from flooding.

FEMA has also denied disaster relief to Illinois and Maryland which, like Vermont, are blue states. At the same time, they approved relief funding for Alaska, Nebraska, and North Dakota which – what a coincidence! – happen to be red states. Homeland Security said their decisions were entirely “non-political.” Right.

A Pew analysis of state-by-state vulnerability to extreme weather events in 2023-2025 matched with reliance on FEMA for disaster recovery showed that the federal disaster relief Vermont received surpassed 90% of its reserves to deal with emergencies, the highest of any state.

In other words, the next extreme weather event of the kind we’ve seen in recent years could wipe out not just one of our communities, but our capacity to repair the damage, with no help from Washington. Heading into the winter-spring flooding seasons, we’re skating on dangerously thin ice. The Legislature must find a way to dramatically increase emergency reserves

Which brings us back to school consolidation.

The Redistricting Task Force has drafted several models for reconfiguring Vermont’s 118 school districts. Their “Center for Technical Education” (CTE) model uses technical education centers as the organizing hubs for 14 consolidated districts. It would incorporate the Center for Technology, Essex and the Burlington Technical Center, along with all of Chittenden County’s K-12 schools into a single CTE district with over 22,000 students, which is nearly three times more than most of the other proposed districts in the CTE model.

The Essex Westford School Board has correctly rejected this as unworkable and discriminatory.

Their alternative to the CTE model is the “Boards of Cooperative Education Services” (BOCES) model. The Task Force borrowed the idea from other states that have successfully dealt with the same problems Vermont wrestles with: Unequal distribution of education resources in rural vs developed areas.

The BOCES model creates an administrative network among school districts that mobilizes resources such as special education, transportation, and professional development so they can be efficiently shared by all districts in the network, while allowing district autonomy.

BOCES provides the efficiencies the state wants while preserving the local control that school boards want.

The BOCES model currently proposed by the Task Force would consolidate all Chittenden County schools into a single BOCES network. This makes little sense because Chittenden County districts are already resource rich. Plus, it creates the same disproportionate school population for Chittenden County vs the rest of the state as the CTE model.

The Task Force acknowledges that their proposals are “rough-edged” because they’re struggling to meet a Dec. 1 deadline, which sounds like an opportunity for creative criticism.

For example, why not a hybrid CTE/BOCES model that pairs resource rich Chittenden County school districts with districts in adjacent counties? Essex-Westford with Lamoille County; Colchester with Franklin; Burlington with Grand Isle?

The South Burlington School Board recently announced that they’re open to the BOCES concept and they’re looking for partners. Other Vermont boards have done the same.

Instead of rejecting consolidation out of hand, perhaps the EWSD board should reach out?

The Reverend Jesse Jackson said that “leadership must meet the moral challenge of the day.”

Our political leaders, statewide and local, are facing a moral challenge they didn’t ask for. But that’s how moral challenges usually work. How will they respond?

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here