George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor.
A bipartisan coalition of 28 Vermont Senators, including Essex’s Tanya Vyhovsky, have co-authored a resolution condemning the Trump administration’s tariffs on Canadian goods and reaffirming our desire for good relations.
The bill crossed over to the Vermont House in mid-March and, if approved, will be sent to the governor for his signature and then on to the White House where, presumably, it won’t be well received.
In plain language it spells out the real harm Vermont faces from the Trump administration’s misguided tactics. We exported $845 million dollars’ worth of goods and services to Canada in 2023 and imported $2.6 billion from Canada in return, nearly half of which was for energy in various forms, and which would be challenging to purchase elsewhere.
To put those numbers in perspective, the Vermont government’s current state budget is $9 billion. In other words, the scale of our trade with Canada makes it a pillar of our state economy.
There’s still much uncertainty about what might be tariffed, but unless there’s a contract explicitly excluding a particular service or commodity, pretty much everything is on the table. And so, once the back-and-forth retaliation starts, who knows where it could lead?
I suspect most Vermonters were surprised earlier this year – surprised as in “that’s ridiculous” – to learn from the Trump administration that Canada is taking advantage of us. Canada is our largest, closest, and most warmly regarded trading partner. We’re old friends and although our financial relationship gets a little rocky at times, it generally works for both of us.
Vermonters were also told that the tariffs were meant to force Canada to do a better job policing the border to stop the flow of fentanyl. But that myth was just debunked by the U.S Intelligence Community's annual threat assessment for 2025, which didn’t even mention Canada as a significant source of illegal drugs.
And so, it’s not clear what the tariffs are actually supposed to do. There seems to be a magical, detached-from-reality reasoning behind them. Perhaps it’s true that the underlying aim is to bludgeon Canada into becoming a U.S. state. But this is such a preposterous idea that it’s hard to believe Trump is serious.
One wonders if his advisors and enablers have pointed out, for example, that Canada has a government funded health service. Unlike us, they believe health care is a basic human right. Sure, their health system has problems. But would they trade it for the public-private calamity we’ve created down here, which, by the way, Trump’s party is hoping to defund? I don’t think so.
When he talks, disrespectfully, of absorbing Canada as our 51st state, does our president understand that it would be a state with a very different worldview than his? For example, the Canadian government trusts the scientific evidence for climate change. Just as Canadian scientists are embarking on a new collaborative effort with their European counterparts to protect fragile and crucial Arctic ecosystems, the Trump administration is scrubbing any mention of 'climate change' from federal websites and publications, slashing climate funding, and arbitrarily firing staff at key climate organizations like the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, one of the oldest and most respected institutes of its kind in the world. When scientists report things they don’t want to hear, they just tell them “you’re fired,” as if running the government is like a reality tv show, with no real-world consequences.
The Vermont government would not be alone in officially protesting Trump’s bewildering moves against Canada. The Alaska State Legislature just passed a similar resolution. Like us, they’re being dragged into a punitive trade war with Canada that neither side wants. Beyond the financial damage they might sustain, they’re concerned about poisoning their relationship with the only country with whom they share a land border. As Alaskan House Majority Leader Chuck Kopp put it, “relationships matter and are far more important than maybe the almighty dollar at times.” He could have been speaking for us.
Vermont’s resolution must still clear a few hurdles, and it wouldn’t be surprising if some elected officials think it’s too risky to voice a Canada-friendly stance. The Trump administration has made it clear that retaliation is not out of bounds for them, denouncing and even defunding anyone – courts, cities, states, universities, the media – who gets in their way or criticizes them.
But we can’t let the silence take us. Like the Alaska state legislature, we need to let Canadians know that we don’t think they deserve this, and that the vast majority of Vermonters are appalled and doing what we can to push back.
If we’re a brave little state, we should be brave enough to risk putting our money where our mouth is.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here