Column: Governor's education plan deserves a closer look

Posted

George Tyler is a columnist for the Essex Reporter. A resident of Essex Junction, Tyler is a former journalist, village trustee and city councilor. 

Though lacking much detail, Governor Scott’s education reform plan, outlined by Education Secretary Zoie Saunders, demonstrates an astute grasp of the basic flaws in Vermont’s unmanageable education funding system, and offers a radical yet credible framework for dealing with them. 

It challenges all stakeholders – legislators, school boards, parents, teachers – to show how truly serious they are about doing what’s best for our students. 

What Act 60 Got Wrong

When the VT Supreme Court ruled in Brigham that Vermont must provide equal educational opportunities for all students, the legislature responded with Act 60, which mandated that all public schools must provide the same level of per pupil spending. To achieve this, property wealthy school districts were required to help fund less wealthy districts.  

But Act 60 imposed no mandates about class sizes or student-to-staff ratios. This enabled schools with low student populations to continue operating long past the time when they might otherwise have closed or been forced into mergers to achieve operational efficiency. Our “uniquely Vermont” solution to school funding produced a uniquely expensive education system. 

According to the US Dept of Education, Vermont’s student-to-teacher ratio in the 2022-2023 school year was 10.5, the lowest in the country, compared to the national average of 15.4. Economists have identified this as the root cause of Vermont’s education funding predicament.  A low student-to-teacher ratio is fine if you’re a wealthy state like Massachusetts or New York (with ratios of 12 and 11.7, respectively). But Vermont is a middle-income state with an aging population.

If Vermont students tested far above their peers in other states, there might be an argument for maintaining this top-heavy structure, as former state economist Art Woolf argued in a 2020 editorial. But our kids don’t perform noticeably better, Wolf noted, and many states get better student performance results with much less per pupil spending.

Scott’s plan would solve this by reconfiguring Vermont’s 98 school districts into five regional districts in which school populations and student-to-staff ratios could be equalized. And it would be the state, not individual districts, that would do the equalizing. That’s the other key component of Scott’s plan. 

What Act 46 Got Wrong

Act 60’s flaws emerged soon after its inception, as school costs and property taxes kept surging while Vermont’s school population remained static. The legislature made a few duct tape fixes to the law, but not until 2015, with the passage of Act 46, did they seriously attempt to deal with the school size and student-to-staff ratio dilemma. 

Act 46 cajoled and enticed school districts to merge, but it didn’t insist. The decision of whether and with whom to merge was left mainly to the towns and local school districts. Yes, the state offered financial incentives and made veiled threats of forced consolidations, but in the end (I’ll be kind) Act 46 wound up being a well-intentioned muddle. 

Education Secretary Saunders alluded to the inherent problem with Act 46 during her presentation of Scott’s plan:

“What we’ve been hearing is, historically, we’ve been pushing down a lot of these really hard decisions at the local level. Districts are working to think intentionally around how they can consolidate to provide different resources for students, but they often tell us that they lack cover from the state to be able to make those important decisions.”

Putting it less diplomatically, local school officials and school board members who see the benefits of school consolidation can have a tough time convincing parents and other stakeholders to surrender control of their schools. Many state representatives and senators are understandably hesitant to tell their constituents that the best thing for their kids’ education, and their own financial wellbeing, might be to share resources by merging their cherished local school district into a larger union with other districts. 

As much as we might rage against the state commandeering our local control, the forced consolidations in Scott’s plan is one instance where Big Brother’s heavy hand, lightened by the winsome smile of the country’s most popular governor, might provide the political “cover” that’s needed to get the job done. 

Local Control?

Our own school funding woes, here in Essex, highlight the quandary: How much local control do we actually have when most of the EWSD budget, like all school budgets, is taken up by contractual obligations, curricular requirements, and state mandates? 

Our hard-working school board is once again being forced to pare back student resources just to minimize the amount by which the state will artificially inflate the EWSD budget this year to meet education funding rules. Our ‘local control’ seems mainly about the pace at which we deconstruct our school system.

If merging with other Chittenden County school districts stems the flow, would it be a worthwhile trade-off?

That’s the question before us, and it’s a tough one. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here