City Council modifies Essex Junction’s DEI policy to comply with federal grant condition for train and bus station

Posted

ESSEX JUNCTION — Essex Junction City Council narrowly voted to alter the city’s diversity, equity and inclusion language in personnel regulations Wednesday in order to comply with a federal grant. 

Back in 2022, the City was awarded $3 million from the Federal Railroad Administration for improvements to the Essex Junction Multimodal Train and Bus Station. Located on Railroad Avenue, the current station is small and provides minimal shelter for an estimated 20,000 annual rail and bus patrons. 

But to comply with the grant’s conditions, the City must alter the DEI language in its mission, value and goals statement, and job descriptions. 

Councilors Amber Thibeault, Elaine Haney and Tim Miller voted in favor. Councilor Brian Shelden voted against, followed by Marcus Certa, after he said he was struggling with which way to vote.  

City Manager Regina Mahony said the grant agreement contains provisions related to President Trump’s Executive Order 14173, which requires recipients to certify they do not operate programs promoting DEI initiatives which violate applicable federal anti-discrimination laws. 

The city attorney and Vermont League of Cities and Towns reviewed the condition and determined the city’s personnel regulations could be of concern. The FRA has stated this condition is under litigation and cannot give clear guidance on what the city is required to do. 

Mahony recommended a “minor adjustment” to the city’s personnel regulations. The Declaration of Inclusion and equal opportunities statement is in conformance with the conditions, but the city’s mission, value and goals statement highlights DEI and conflicts with the executive order. 

The edited part of the statement would read: 

“Promote Equal Opportunity – Our organization is committed to providing equal opportunity in employment and service delivery. We strive to create a respectful and welcoming environment for all employees, clients, and community members. We value the range of experiences and perspectives within our community and seek to ensure that our programs, services, and workplace practices are accessible, fair, and responsive to the people we serve.”

“The recommended change is really an art of wordsmithing,” Mahony said. “I don’t think we are going to change our practice at the end of the day in terms of what we are actually doing.”

The City is currently working with Tabitha Moore, an organizational equity consultant from Intentional Evolution, LLC who founded the Rutland Area Branch of the NAACP, to rewrite mission, value and goal statements. The statements are “quite old” according to Mahony and she anticipates having more conversations about them so they will best reflect the present-day city. 

The second change recommended by Mahony, which would be made internally without the council’s approval, is to change the language on job descriptions and job advertisements and instead refer back to the full equal opportunities statement that does not need to change.

“It’s not just this $3 million,” Mahony said. “We are one year into a four year federal administration, and [if we don’t make this change] we are talking about potentially not using federal funds at all for the next three years.”

Shelden said he didn’t like the “look,” comparing the decision to Columbia University changing its DEI policy in response to executive orders. He pointed back to the condition being under litigation and said he'd be “super disappointed” if they made these changes unnecessarily and the lawsuits succeed. 

“It doesn’t change who we are or what we do or how we do it on the day-to-day,” Miller said.

Haney said the change does not mean the city will stop practicing DEI, and she’s willing to make a concession on language with potential for revising the language again at a future time. She added the multimodal train and bus station was one of the first projects she learned about when she became a village trustee 12 years ago. 

“Multiple boards and multiple employees here at the city have gone through so much to make this project happen, and I wouldn’t want this piece to be a small hitch of it,” Haney said. 

Before the meeting entered into executive session, Certa wrapped up his final meeting as a city councilor by saying he “couldn’t be more jazzed” to see newly-elected Bethany Clark bring a different insight and fresh perspective to the council. 

“The universe is going to be fine,” Certa said. “I know you all have Essex Junction’s best interests in heart.”

A full description of the edited policy language can be found on the city’s website under City Council packet April 15 on pages 21-24.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here