Board is trying to quash free speech

Posted

In the debate over the proposed creation of a separate municipality to protect the rec budget from competition, a lot of rhetoric has been expended on whether a selectboard member can speak his or her mind to the public outside selectboard meetings. Having been on the board, I personally witnessed attempts to throttle public discussion and hide information from the public. Max Levy is one of the co-conspirators in attempting to impose a gag rule on board members or, in other words, to suspend the First Amendment.

As an example of this intimidation, I am sharing what Linda Myers, then a selectboard member, had to say against freedom of speech, back in August 2010:

“I’m offering this comment as the oldest member of the selectboard both in longevity on the board and years.

  I have to tell you that I was away for awhile, and when I came back, I went through my mail and my newspapers and I picked up a copy of the July 22 issue of The Essex Reporter, and I was stunned by a letter to the editor that had been written by Bruce Post of the Essex Selectboard.

  In the nine years that I have served on the selectboard and the 17 years that my husband served on the selectboard, I have never seen anything like this before. Bruce Post took the opportunity to speak on an issue that has been under discussion with the selectboard, which is the open burning ordinance, without the selectboard having an opportunity to comment or rebut what he had to say in The Essex Reporter. I have never heard of this being done before, and I was very, very upset by seeing this. To me this was grandstanding at the ultimate.

  Bruce seems to feel that as a member of the selectboard, having been elected to the selectboard, he seems to feel that he hasn’t lost or given up his right to speak, and that’s absolutely true, but he hasn’t given up his right to speak on issues that are not being considered by the Essex Selectboard. On issues that are being considered by the Selectboard, I’m sorry, he does give up the right to speak.

  Now, there may be comments from the Vermont League of Cities and Towns that say OK, you really can do this and possibly from the Secretary of State’s office, but for 26 years on the Essex Selectboard, which I have intimate knowledge, that has been our policy whether it’s written or whether it’s accepted policy.

  That’s about all I have to say on the issue except this. I will not accept any comments from Bruce on what I have said tonight because he took the opportunity to make comments in public to the public through a letter to the editor which then did not give the selectboard members the opportunity to make comments, so I feel I should be afforded that same ability. Thank you.”

As I said at a recent selectboard meeting, comments like Myers’ are more characteristic of the old Soviet Politburo than they should be of our selectboard in a supposed democracy.

Bruce S. Post

Essex

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here