Without unanimity, board supports union district plan

Posted

By COLIN FLANDERS

As the recreation governance study committee continues down the path toward creating a union municipal district, at least one selectboard member believes too many questions will remain when the plan goes to voters in December.

Irene Wrenner urged the board to reconsider its position earlier this month in what amounted to the harshest critique of the plan since it was announced in early June.

“Until I got into the weeds, I did not realize the depth of the mess we’ve been asked to pass on to our voters,” she said at the July 11 meeting. “I just don’t think it’s fixable.”

Wrenner criticized the plan’s complexity, its potential tax impact and apparent lack of oversight.

Both the village board of trustees and Essex Prudential Committee, the board currently governing the Essex Jct. Parks and Recreation department, passed motions supporting the venture.

“We have a home for our recreation department,” Wrenner said. “And, last I knew, things were going just fine.”

With the change, town residents would see a tax increase, though the amount is unknown. So is what will happen to an existing EJRP $320,000 bond over the next three years.

The recreation district needs a budget, however, before the tax impact can be determined. And that work can’t begin until and unless the vote passes in December, and after a new governing body forms in January. Taxpayers would vote on the budget in April 2017.

The committee expects the new district would operate with “the same amount of tax money or less” than the two departments do now, according to its FAQs draft.

Initial savings are expected for printing a combined annual brochure and by purchasing only one membership to several parks and recreation associations.

Yet until the governing body makes decisions on IT, payroll, finance and human resources, the “final numbers are to be determined,” the committee wrote.

EJRP’s $2.35 million budget is $1 million higher than the town department’s budget. The amount raised by taxes is similar, however: $745,000 for the village, $728,000 for the town.

Since village residents pay into both the town and village recreation departments, and town residents pay only into the town, equalizing the rates means an increase for the latter.

Doug Fisher, town director of finance, said to achieve an equal recreation tax rate for all residents, a cost shift is inevitable.

“The idea is to make it more efficient and less costly,” he said July 11.

Wrenner doesn’t mind paying extra to support a village entity, but some town residents can’t afford another $100 to $300 a year for a “rec department they may not even use.”

“I’m speaking for those people now, and I will vote no on just about every option I’ve already heard,” she said.

Max Levy, selectboard chairman who serves on the study committee, said writing off the plan was premature, as they haven’t heard all the details.

“We need to understand what the tax impact is before we can say it’s too much,” he said.

Though the selectboard helped form the committee, statute allows the recreation committee to decide on a structure without selectboard or trustee approval, said selectman Andy Watts, a committee alternate.

Watts told the selectboard the only way to halt the vote is by refusing to fund the December election — what he called an “extreme measure.”

At the study committee’s June 8 meeting, Watts urged the group to wait two weeks before making its decision, allowing the trustees, selectboard and prudential committee to share feedback during a joint meeting June 22.

The committee declined, citing its statutory power, said Watts, who felt the move was to avoid being “derailed.” Wrenner found this unsettling.

“That just doesn’t give my constituents, I think, any piece of mind that this is going to be a district … that is accountable to them,” she said. “And they will be the ones paying the bills.”

Watts also said the district doesn’t want representation from the selectboard or the village trustees on its governing body, only adding to Wrenner’s concern.

“The more oversight, the better when you’re spending taxpayer dollars,” she said. “To think that a board of a few people are going to be making up things as they go along, as I’m hearing has been done already, who’s going to stop them?”

Levy disagreed with her assessment, noting the Chittenden Solid Waste District is an independent board, but voters have a say on its budget, providing checks and balances.

“The residents can say, ‘You guys are crazy; this budget’s going down,’” he said.

Wrenner continued her critique, noting the committee’s draft FAQs lists more than 60 queries, illustrating the plan’s complexity.

“As a selectman who’s spent literally days with this material and hours at meetings, how do I explain that to my voters when they call up and say, ‘What the heck am I voting on tomorrow?’” she asked.

It’s a top-down approach out of sync with Essex’s stance on mergers, Wrenner said. Recent successful consolidations like in public works were made incrementally, she added.

Wrenner fears a poor showing at the polls could undermine future consolidation, comparing this effort to a 2006 campaign by then-selectboard chairman Tom James, who aimed to merge the town and the village despite heavy opposition. Wrenner served on the merger committee at the time.

The proposal failed, she recalled, and James wasn’t reelected.

“There’s incredible emotional strife waiting for us, just as we saw in 2006,” she said, adding, “Unless you’ve lived through that … you may not recognize just how devastating those costs can be.”

Despite Wrenner’s argument, her motion to send the issue back to the study committee failed 4-1.

The board then wrestled with wording its motion, deciding to “support the concept” of the union municipal district “pending further details.” It passed 4-1. Wrenner, wary of the implications, dissented.

“I don’t want my name behind this come December if there are a bunch of interim questions … because whatever I vote tonight to push forward will be spun by whoever gets the mic first,” she said.

Experience tells Wrenner the board’s vote will be used down the road to show its support for the district, and “that is not the message that I intend to send,” she said.

The recreation committee will present its draft agreement to the selectboard, trustees, prudential committee and unified school board over the next two weeks. Residents can also weigh in during a 6:30 p.m. public hearing August 4 at Essex Middle School.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here