My ballot arrived in the mail today and I am voting to approve the Plan of Merger (I live in the Town outside the Village). Is it everything I think it should be – probably not. It is a compromise, representing the interest of all parties and therefore no one gets everything they want. Why am I voting yes?
It is the right thing to do. The residents in the Village pay 100% for their budget and then pay over 40% for the Towns. Many of the services are duplicates or not used by residents of the Village. The whole Town/Village governance structure has gone on long enough, has caused enough issues and it is time to end it.
It is better than the alternatives. If there is a no vote, we might continue on as is, but a better bet is if the Town votes no, the residents of the Village could either dissolve their charter and be absorbed by the Town, or separate. The residents of the Town outside the Village would have no say (if voted on by the Village, the Legislature would make the final decision) and the tax increase would be sudden and either equal to or much greater than merger. Even if we continue the status quo, we are currently realizing several million is savings from merged services only because the Selectboard members and Village Trustees have made that decision. Different boards could find this arrangement not to their liking and it could break down after one future election. Not exactly a stable arrangement.
Look to the future. Regardless of how we got to this point, we need to look to where we want to be in the future. A single unified town with one Village center. A single plan on how and where to grow, protecting the rural nature of the Town outside the Village. No competition between the Town outside the Village and the Village. One set of ordinances, one planning document, one town wide government, one community. Probably the most efficient organizational structure.
3 + 3. I am not sure if everyone has thought of the possible ramifications of 3+3 if merger is not approved. We now have Selectboard members for all of Essex who represent all residents of the Town. Under 3+3 we would have 3 Selectboard members from the TOV and 3 from the Village, representing the interests of their areas. What is to stop the Village Selectboard members from blocking any future budget increases for the Town? If they are representing the Village residents and the Village residents are already paying for their own services, it would be in their interest not to pay any more in Town taxes. While three votes could not approve anything, 3 votes would be enough to block any tax increase. While at first people in the TOV may like not having any tax increases, but it would not be long before things could turn pretty bleak. While I do not think or hope this would happen, I do not wish to have this hanging over my head as a possibility. Under merger there would not be a Town budget and a Village budget competing for dollars.
So, as I review the Voter Information on the Merger Plan, I temper the like and dislike of individual items with the long term view on what I believe is in the best interest of the Town as a whole. Could we get a better plan more to my liking? Maybe, but then other people may not like those compromises or I may have to give up some of the things I like to change things I don’t. Again, it is a compromise trying to bring together a lot of different interests. Overall, I believe it is a good compromise from which to move forward. Please join me in voting yes.
Richard Fanus
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here