ESSEX TOWN AND ESSEX JUNCTION — Property owners in the Town of Essex and the City of Essex Junction received letters in the mail this past week with the newly appraised value of their residential or commercial properties.
Slated to only take a year, the Town and City have undergone a project reappraising every property since 2023. The town extended the project to maintain quality of work despite difficulty recruiting and retaining the number of field appraisers required to complete the data collection phase, according to the town’s municipal assessor Karen Lemnah.
As reimbursement for tackling the project, the municipalities received $8.50 from the state per parcel per year totaling $751,770. The last reappraisal was in 2007.
The State of Vermont mandates that municipalities undergo a reappraisal project when the common level of appraisal dips below 85%.
CLA compares the value of locally assessed property to the estimated fair market value. In other words, what the property is appraised for compared to its sale price. For example, if a town appraised a property for $200,000 and it recently sold for $250,000, the CLA would be 80% and if a different town appraised a property for $275,000 and it recently sold for $250,000, the CLA would be 101%.
Until 2023, the CLA had not fallen below the state requirement. However, three years ago, town employees recognized that the CLA dipped below 85% and they started the reappraisal process, according to Lemnah.
The City contracted with the Town for assessing services. The Town then contracted professional field appraisers from Catalis to assess commercial properties and 7,298 residential properties, as well as Coldwell Banker Richard Ellis to assess GlobalFoundries. GlobalFoundries required a specialized appraiser as a major industrial complex, unlike any other property in Essex or Essex Junction.
Evaluations for residential properties are based on interior and exterior features, such as building materials and their conditions as well as amenities like finished basements or swimming pools. The contracting companies did not assess all property interiors; however, Essex and Essex Junction were able to assess 30% of interiors.
The field appraisers based the value of properties on the current real estate market and the most recent data about properties in Vermont.
“We don't create the market, we discover it and research it,” Lemnah said. “That's where the valuation comes in. We use three years worth of sales to come up with our data sets and our valuation models, which are set into our valuation system. And as we set that data in for each property, that's how the valuations come out.”
Deputy Town Manager Karen Adams said she was surprised how many objective qualities were included in the criterion, like evaluating materials such as granite countertops, solid wood flooring or the condition of a roof on today’s market standards.
“It's more based on factual characteristics of the property than someone's subjective label,” Adams said about comparing materials and conditions to neighbors and similar properties.
Field appraisers based residential property and commercial property values on different criteria. While residential property values mostly included materials and condition of structures, commercial property criteria evaluated the income generation potential and the investment potential of a business.
Adams and Lemnah compared residential to commercial properties as lifestyle versus income and investment.
Appraised values are likely to change for many reasons. For example, materials such as linoleum and vinyl might be less valuable now compared to their value in 2007 during the last appraisal.
The condition of the materials may have changed as well. If a homeowner puts effort into maintaining the property, then it will be valued higher than one who did not. If a property was not maintained or amenities have become outdated, the value falls.
If any features were added or taken away, like a pool or finished basement, the value of the property would likely increase or decrease. Deterioration of the same features would decrease the value.
Lemnah said assessors found location was an important factor; they did not find property values overall rose, but instead appraised values fluctuating by neighborhood and region.
Tax rates are determined separately from property assessments. The proportion a property owner contributes to the budget in taxes could possibly increase, decrease or remain the same depending on their newly assessed value when the selectboard and City Council set their respective tax rates in July.
Voters approved the City and Town municipal budgets during Town and Annual Meeting Days. These will not change. Taxes will not overall increase or decrease, but the percentage a property owner contributes to the preset budget will change based on the newly appraised value of their property.
“The other misconception that I find during reappraisals is ‘if my value goes up 60% my taxes go up 60%,’” Lemnah said. “That is incorrect. The two do not go up the same percentage rate. The grand list will rise, the tax rate will lower.”
While the tax rate hasn’t been set yet, if a property value increases, the amount the homeowner will pay will likely be less proportionally compared to the value of their property before the reappraisal even if they are paying more overall.
State education taxes are determined by lawmakers in Montpelier. The Town and City do not have direct influence over these rates. Much like the municipal budgets, the Essex Westford School District budget set by voters will remain unchanged.
Adams and Lemnah advise property owners to first make sure certain data points about their property are correct, like how many bathrooms it has, the siding materials, the type of heating or air conditioning systems and other physical materials and their conditions.
After looking at all of the physical attributes of the property and ensuring they are accurate, it’s important to compare their appraised value with those of neighbors and other properties with similar features like materials, amenities and size. A property owner can look at sales from nearby properties and determine if their assessed value is within a similar range.
Adams and Lemnah direct property owners to the Town and City websites to find more information about comparing property value. Town assessment report and City assessment report for prior and proposed values are listed online. They also recommend using the property record card database for comparing homes and values.
A property might sell for slightly more or less than it was appraised for in this project. Both values are set on fair market value between a buyer and seller.
“If a real estate appraiser did an appraisal on a house,” Lemnah said. “They're using three comparable sales. We're using a huge group of sales to average out, so it's a little bit of a different process, but they should be pretty close, within 10%.”
If a property owner reviews their property, compares it to similar parcels and does not agree with the assessment, Lemnah and Catalis are informally meeting with property owners to discuss their values from June 3 to June 12 as well as to answer any questions.
These meetings are around 15-20 minutes and should be scheduled using the number on the Town website. Property owners have until June 11 at 3 p.m. to schedule an informal meeting. In-person or phone appointments are available.
The state requires the Town and City file the grand list by June 24. Lemnah said they will mail property owners finalized values in June with any updated information.
Meetings for formal grievances will then take place 14 days after the grand list filing in mid-June.
The results of the formal grievance may be appealed to the Board of Civil Authority, who will hold a hearing, inspect the property and make a ruling. After that, further appeals take place at the state and higher courts level.
The state requires municipalities to reappraise properties every six years. Adams said the City and Town have not officially decided to assess jointly or separately during the next project.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here