ESSEX WESTFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT — Since the murder of George Floyd in 2020, equity has become a more intentional effort by school districts across the country.
For EWSD, this effort started in the 2018-19 school year as it began to establish its new unified identity. Three years later, in 2021, the district established its equity policy.
Conversations around equity are often surrounded in jargon and can be hard to understand for those completely new to the topic.
The Essex Reporter sat down with EWSD director of equity and inclusion Erin Maguire to help alleviate this barrier of understanding in a Q&A conversation.
A: If someone is reading this article and finding the language too complicated or feeling like they're not understanding even after reading it, I really would, in our community, encourage them to reach out to me.
I would be happy to be of support. I think looking at the resources on our website (ewsd.org/page/equity-inclusion), might be another good place because maybe you have some questions about how we are recommending people talk to young children about race, or maybe you have a question about supporting gender diversity, or LGBTQ youth in our schools.
There are also books recommended on our website that you can look through to see if there might be a book you might be interested in reading.
A: The community made equity a central part of our work when EWSD was being formed as a new district, and a new vision was written. There was a great deal of community comment and input during the development of the vision that showed a community value toward equity and diversity.
In EWSD when we think about diversity, we think about race, gender, ability, language, religion, and other parts of people. There were conversations about the different outcomes for different demographic groups. These discussions resulted in the end piece of the vision: every day, every way, every one.
This represents a very clear commitment to equity. We want to ensure that all students are able to meet their goals without systemic barriers. This all happened before the murder of George Floyd. Many associate this body of work with that moment in the civil rights movement. It certainly is important and plays a role in our conversation as a country and as a community; and the EWSD Equity work started before that happened, and it was centered on the development of the vision from the community.
That incident shows the continued importance of the work.
A: Yes. Equity is when everyone gets what they need to be successful; this does not always mean everyone gets the same thing or has the same experience. Equality means everyone gets the same thing. In EWSD, we have focused on identity-based equity, so we look at how identity is or is not related to the success of meeting one’s goals and examines the barriers or privileges of someone’s experiences.
As a part of this work, in order to reduce barriers, we want to make sure that all students are represented in their education, and that they're also learning about others. We want to center the voices of those most impacted and we want to reduce policies, procedures, and rules that create barriers.
We look at students based on who they are and what they need. That means we need a really robust experience for all students to know themselves as well as to know others. And that's what we mean when we talk about equity.
A: Yes, equity can be applied above and beyond identity based equity. For example, living in rural spaces with two working caregivers who begin their day before they can get you to school creates a higher need for transportation from the school district as opposed to someone who lives a mile from the school.
These two families could have the same identities but have different needs. Equity is not always based on identity. However, it is more frequently based on identity than anything else and inequity can be measured clearly through considering identity and demographics.
A: Equity does not mean all students reach the exact same goals. It means that students do not have barriers to the goals they want to reach. All students want to be good readers, that is a common goal for all. Literacy is a critical skill to meet many other goals.
However, not all students have a goal to go to a four-year liberal arts school, some prefer to go into a trade school after high school. We support all goals for all students, and there are some goals we want to see all students reach. When we look at our literacy scores broken down by identity, we can see inequities.
A: Intersectionality is a word we use to talk about the different identities people have. All people have a race, all people have abilities, all people have a language they use primarily to communicate with others.
People who have identities that match what is dominant (most present) in any environment gain a benefit from that. People who have identities that are not as dominant can experience barriers without work done to decrease and eliminate those barriers. All people have parts of themselves that fit into these two categories.
The way those identities intersect for a person is what we call intersectionality. The reason this is so important is that we do not want to limit how we understand a single person based on one of their identities. It is so important to understand people – students and their families – as whole people with all that they are and all that they bring.
A: We have a goal to ensure that we are supporting and protecting our staff and our students, especially those who hold non-dominant identities, and recognizing bias, both individual and systemic, that can create barriers. We want to make sure that we hold space for and deeply listen to people and their experiences.
We know that it is important that our teachers and our staff feel a sense of belonging in order for our students to have access to adults who support them and feel a sense of belonging. If we have staff and faculty and administration and adults generally in our systems who are not feeling a sense of belonging and are feeling harmed regularly by our organization or by each other, we will not be as successful with our students.
Our work to have a sense of belonging for all is a centerpiece of the equity work as well as our overarching work toward our vision. And that includes our faculty and staff. We do not always get any of this perfect, we are working to improve. We want to diversify our staff and support them into an organization that reduces barriers, rather than increases them.
A: I remember in fifth grade, studying about the abolitionist John Brown, and having a teacher who really helped celebrate abolitionist movements. It substantially informed my thinking about history.
While I had that experience, I also experienced history taught in ways that were not as clear about the importance of abolitionist movements and it depended on the teacher and the ways in which they were telling those stories. I remember having students with disabilities as an integral part of my upbringing in my elementary and middle school experiences and I also remember the separate room that existed where they spent much of their day.
I remember wondering why there were so few students of color in my school in Vermont. I don't remember a substantial emphasis on recognizing my relationship with others who are different than me as a part of my education but I remember being very curious about that. So I wouldn't describe it as substantially expressed by the organization where I went to school. But I remember teachers who had it as an area of focus when I was in school as well,
A: Sure. I think I'll start with the intentional design of the equity policy through community members, students and staff who were most impacted by the policy as the group. They wrote the policy with the support of the administration in moving the policy through the board to passage. The policy work was necessary to get clarity from our community on the equity work in EWSD.
The Equity Advisory Committee was established by the policies and they created 57 change recommendations for our schools. This is one of the ways in which we deeply listen to people's stories, understand what's happening to them and having that be meaningful in the ways and create change in the district based on those.
We are working to view all curriculum through an equity lens, which is why people say it's not a curriculum. It's a lens through which we teach all subjects and look at all of our materials.
Our goal is to look at the stories that we tell and the perspectives from which they're coming. We want to center access to our schools. We want to improve our skills in restorative practices. We want to improve in centering our impact. A lot of times when harm is done, there's a lot of focus on intent. And so one of our goals is to help people understand the importance of recognizing their impact on others as opposed to just the intent that they have.
There is no recipe for this body of work. And it is why we try to bring lots of voices in. We have over 100 leaders in equity work in EWSD between the equity Advisory Committee, the leadership team and then all of the school based leadership teams with teachers and support staff on them, focusing in on the work that we'll do.
A: A way to think about equity work for someone who is just beginning to learn about it is thinking about representing all people through our curriculum and our school environments. To create a sense of true belonging for everyone. We want multiple cultures around the world throughout our schools.
Representation of all races are in our materials, being supportive and affirming of LGBTQIA+ youth in our schools and being fully accessible to all students with disabilities are important. We strive to recognize the way that we contend with students or staff who are doing harm – because we all do harm to others sometimes – and using education to teach out of those behaviors.
Learning about cultures, religions, languages, and experiences from around the world throughout the curriculum so students both see themselves and learn about others is essential. If you want to see the structure of equity work in EWSD, you should go to the EWSD website and review the visual of the leadership model.
It will help you understand how we are structured to do the work and the specific changes that are recommended. This work means we look at ourselves as an organization and hold ourselves accountable where the organization has created barriers or lack of representation. The leadership structure is designed to do that.
We use the DESSA as an social emotional learning assessment. That supports educators in measuring social emotional learning. Dylan McNamara is our Director of Social Emotional Learning and Wellness and so he would want to speak more to this too. We also have teachers grade and assess social emotional learning standards in the same way that we assess reading standards. You can look on our website to see our social emotional learning standards and teachers are assessing those in classrooms. We administer the youth truth survey as another tool. And we are always continuing to grow and become more complex in our local assessments for social emotional learning.
The original goals in 2019 were developed primarily by the leadership team prior to the writing of the EWSD Equity Policy. Since the writing of the policy, which established our goals, they have not changed.
Those are the areas of focus for the district because it is important [that] the community members most impacted by this work, creates direction, which is why we went ahead and established those goals directly in the policy. They're very long term goals. It's not something that you'll check off in a year. And so those have stayed stable since then.
A: Our goals are applicable pre-K through 12. The equity policy does reference the importance of developmental appropriateness and that is to make sure that we are aligned with childhood development as we talk about topics.
As we're teaching elementary literacy, and we're selecting text related to the classroom and the range of texts that need to be represented there, we are applying an equity lens to create representation and recognize whose story we are telling through the stories that we're placing into the literacy curriculum.
I'm glad you asked the question because I think this is an area that people struggle to understand around how is it that equity is everything and that's an example. And that continues all the way through and you can see the developmental change in the texts from kindergarten through 12th grade obviously, more complex, digging deeper into more complicated and young adult and later in high school adult concepts that are important to be able to unpack from multiple perspectives.
And so you know, as we look to put the equity lens into high school social studies, it looks different than literacy in first grade, although what we're looking for is similar as it relates to what are we representing and whose stories are we telling and which stories haven't been told through the development of our curriculum.
I encourage people to reach out to me who have curiosity, because it's very challenging, even in an article or in an interview to try to get people the information that they might need because some people understand this and some people are new to the concepts. If people have questions or concerns or confusion about the work, I would just encourage people to come talk to me. My door is always open, regardless of people's perspectives.
There are many common conversations about equity in multiple contexts. An example is within health equity or equity of health outcomes. There are lots of people working on that as well. It is focused on both mental and physical health outcomes in the medical field. It focuses on identity based equity.
Education is specific to educational outcomes with a similar lens. So there are common conversations about identity based equity in multiple areas. I also think that because education is a public good and serves children, it creates a need to be in conversation with and in partnership with families more frequently than some other fields considering equity based work, which is one of our goals.
All in all, accessing school has similarities and differences to accessing health care. There is equity work being done in both spaces.
I know people who feel like having conversations about identity divides people through labels. And so I think that sometimes it's hard for people. I also think that where religion is speaking in opposition to LGBTIA+ identities harm is created. This is in opposition to our policy.
That is another area that I see people feel stressed when we discuss equity. As an equity director. I believe strongly in valuing people's experiences and listening carefully, where a group of people is feeling harmed by or not well supported by the organization for which I work that matters to me, I hear those voices. And even if people don't want that to be true, it is; and for us to ignore that would be further harm.
For us not to work to redress that to resolve that to help make that better would be wrong, in my opinion. And so while we can have differences of opinion about a lot of things, I just don't think that differences of opinion that deny the right of someone to exist as they are our should be use to make decisions in the school district.
People have experiences based on how others treat them and when people are biased and where institutions make assumptions about people based on their identities, inequities are born.
A huge part of my role is organizing and supporting people forward in the conversation and in the work. There are many organizations hiring equity directors. And while equity directors are important related to creating pathways and identifying resources to support change, I don't see myself as the person who has the most information to help make all of the decisions.
My job is to make sure that student voice, staff voice and community voice are centered in the decision making process. I think sometimes there's an association of authority and decision making, that we've really worked to distribute decisions and center voices outside of administration often in this particular area of the organization, including through the Office of Equity and Inclusion.
Our community has guided this work and will continue to do so.
This article was updated Dec. 8 at 2:43 p.m. to include all 16 questions.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here