ESSEX AND WESTFORD — It’s been half a school year since Westford’s middle-grade students made the leap from Westford Elementary to Essex Middle School, following the recent consolidation decision by the Essex-Westford School Board.
How are students feeling about the change?
The Reporter talked to a few of them to find out.
Eighth-grader Avery Orisko said the new setting has treated him well so far. Essex Middle School students and teachers have been friendly and welcoming, and he appreciates the larger school’s trove of resources, including additional sports.
“At first, I was pretty annoyed and mad,” Orisko said, of when the consolidation was first announced. “After a while, I was accepting, and it's a school of new opportunities for people, so that's good for the students here.”
“When I first got there, it was, of course, a little big of a transition,” he added. “But I just stuck with friends and they stuck with me and that pretty much helped.”
Last February, Essex-Westford school board members voted to move Westford School’s 60 students in grades 6-8 to Essex Middle School in order to save approximately $277,000. The move, among other district changes, responded to a call from taxpayers to minimize property tax increases.
The consolidation went into effect at the start of this school year. Westford School remains open to elementary-age students.
Orisko said the thing he misses the most about Westford is the teachers he’s known for several years, because in-between classes everybody’s always around, including some teachers he’s known well and had as part of his support system since third grade.
He also noted it does take a lot more driving to get into town and back every day. He gets dropped off at WES by his dad and then takes the direct bus from there to EMS, which requires his family to wake up a little bit earlier than they did before.
“It's harder in the winter now because we were sitting out there in like three-degree weather today, just waiting for the bus,” he said. “But as long as we have layers and we get to talk with friends, we’ll manage.”
Seventh-grader Crosby Tyler told the Reporter that when the Essex-Westford School Board announced its decision to relocate Westford students, he was nervous and “pretty sad,” noting that he remains concerned WES, where he’d been since kindergarten, might be forced to close altogether at some point down the line.
But as far as settling into a new flow goes, things are going pretty well.
“It's been good,” Tyler said. “For the first weeks, it was mostly the Westford kids hung out with the Westford kids and the Essex kids, like, didn't hang out with us. But then as time has moved on, it’s been more of everybody hanging out with everybody.”
“I feel like most of the Westford kids have settled,” he added.
Tyler said his favorite aspect of the change is an enhanced access to special classes like music, art and physical education, each of which WES only offered once a week. At EMS, students get to take three of them every day, on a rotating basis throughout the trimester schedule.
For instance, Avery switched to some new classes recently, including a woodworking class, which is a new opportunity Westford didn't offer.
“I find that it’s just better,” he said. “Math, science and humanities, they were all in a row at Westford, and at EMS, it's not like that, and the day feels much faster because of that. But then also I miss a lot of things about Westford. There are so many.”
For one thing, as a result of there being more kids at EMS, Tyler said he feels students don't get to know their teachers as well, and the teachers don't have the capacity to know their individual students as well either. Class sizes are 25 at EMS, as opposed to 17 at WES.
He said he feels adequately supported, but that there hasn’t been any particular emphasis on integration-focused support or programming for the Westford kids who are new to the school.
While it seems lots of students are settling fairly well into their new school, some parents have noted it’s largely been a tradeoff for the immense amount of invisible labor on their parts to ensure they can get their kids to and from these new opportunities from further away.
Avery Orisko’s mom, Meghan Valyou Orisko, told the Reporter that with only about six months to prepare for the transition, she started by bringing Avery into the school board meetings to let him know a big change was coming.
“I think them adjusting is a big reflection of all the parents in Westford,” she said. “Everyone has really rallied together to support the kiddos now that they're in a new environment. So I think their current status is a big attribute to all the parents supporting the kiddos — whether it's the carpooling, or changing our schedules, they don't see what goes on behind the scenes.”
Valyou Orisko said Avery made the A-team for EMS soccer and basketball, hence, he hasn’t had to deal with what many of his friends and peers who made the C team have. Some of them made the tough decision not to play a sport they love because for the first time ever, they don’t get to play with their friends — and, because C team practices last, and parents have to shuttle kids in and out of town for practice after school, which isn’t an option for everyone.
“So if your child does sports like mine, there's no [bus] ride home,” she said. “We're now in winter, so yes, it takes even longer to pick your kiddo up and come home, and that's when I have two younger kids and my husband here at home… That's an hour every evening that I'm missing with my family.”
She noted families try to carpool, but because there aren't other Westford kids on the A team, the options for carpooling are very limited. Plus, different families are operating with different extracurricular schedules. The Oriskos shoot for one or two carpools a week, if possible.
This fall and winter, a day in the life of her child involves a 6:30 a.m. wake-up, a 7:15 a.m. drive by a parent to WES for drop-off, a 7:30-7:55 a.m. bus ride to EMS, an 8-8:30 a.m. wait outside EMS, an 8:35 a.m. start time, a 3:35 p.m. end of school, a wait in the library, a 4:45 p.m. basketball practice, a 5:20 p.m. departure of a parent to get to EMS, a 5:45-55 p.m. pick-up, and 6:15 home arrival — which she believes is fairly typical for Westford kids in middle school today.
Other tiers of the basketball team start practice between 5:30-7:15 p.m.
For the Orisko family, the student commute is 45 morning minutes and 25 evening minutes a day, or 350 minutes per week, which is 1.9 times the commute time as compared to last year; the parent commute time is 15 morning minutes and an hour each evening, or 275 minutes per week, which is three times the time commitment as compared to what was needed of them last year.
Avery now spends 11 daily hours away from home — 10 more hours per week over last year.
“Teachers did make an effort to keep friends together, and each homeroom has three Westford kids,” Valyou Orisko said.“Westford students were given a survey and asked for one, two or three peers who they would like in their homeroom, so that they can have at least one safe person with them at all times. So Avery has at least two peers in every class that is a Westford student.”
“I appreciate the effort the teachers and the staff have made for their comfort level,” she said.
When she asked Avery who he sits with at lunch, Valyou Orisko learned that Westford kids to this day have two tables where they stick together amidst a sea of Essex tables, at least for the eighth grade lunch period. But this decision was the students’ choice, not staff-segregated.
“A few of them do, I guess, mingle or mix with the Essex kids,” she said.
But the primary underlying issue at hand, in Valyou Orisko’s eyes, is that she felt Westford residents didn’t have adequate board representation or hence, much of a say, in the decision that led everyone to the current situation.
“That would have been more appropriate, but the board would not allow that,” she said. “We didn't have a choice to be in this position, or enough of a vote to keep our kids in our own town. So we've done what we can to make their lives as least impacted as possible so they don't see what happens behind the scenes.”
For one thing, Valyou Orisko definitely noticed she is fueling up her car more this year — twice as much as usual. During soccer season, she also had to end her work day early to drive in and pick the kids up and transport them to games, because game transportation isn’t provided at the middle school level, which was also true of Westford, but Westford only had games at Westford and Fairfax, so parents barely had to travel.
Now, they go as far as South Burlington, Middlebury, Burlington and Colchester.
Valyou Orisko said the family has had to spend $100 per month more than last year, and are looking to have to budget $1,000 more just for fuel for the school year solely because her son is now at EMS.
“I try not to let him know that that's happening, because he is so sweet that he would be like, ‘Well, I won't do a sport then, because it costs too much money,’” she said. “That's why I don't want him to know, because he's the type of kid who notices his shoes are too tight, and I'm like, ‘Okay, we'll get you new shoes,’ he's like, ‘No, no, it's okay. They're too expensive.”
Crosby Tyler’s mom, Kirsten Tyler, had a similar set of concerns to share.
“The teachers at EMS are nice, and I don't have any problems with the academics or the offerings or whatever, but the biggest thing, which we sort of predicted as one of the biggest issues, is it's so hard for my kid to participate in anything, because we live 32 minutes away from the school.”
“Our school was consolidated against our wishes,” she said. “We are concerned about our total lack of governance and control of our town school. What this consolidation has done to our family life is pretty terrible. We now spend hours, not exaggerating, in the car per day so our kid can participate in the ‘opportunities’ highlighted last budget season.”
Last year, while at WES, Crosby played sports, participated in band, took piano lessons at home outside of school and had time to hang out with friends and have family at home. Now that he is at EMS, Kirsten said she can’t get him to school on time for band so he doesn’t participate.
He gets home too late to participate in piano lessons, so years and years of lessons have stopped — that’s three extracurriculars down to one. He participates in sports at EMS and enjoyed soccer, but didn’t get home until about 6:30 p.m. every day. Between homework, shower, and dinner, Kirsten said he has little down time after it all.
Crosby is now on basketball’s C team, which practices from 7:15-8:15 p.m. every night, meaning Crosby won’t get home until about 9 p.m., which is later than he usually goes to bed. Kirsten is concerned about the schedule’s effect on his academics and its reduction of weeknight family time on practice and game nights to zero.
Kirsten is aware of other Westford families who were also put on the C team, who have quit because they just can't make it happen for their students. Crosby is only doing some of the practices and some of the games because it's just too late and because of time spent in the car.
“It just puts a lot of hardship regarding time on our family, not to mention the extra gas money and the fact that I'm not working those hours that I need to go pick him up and go drop him off … It's a lot of driving, a lot of time, I don't see him as much.”
Kirsten also expressed frustration, not with any teacher or coaches for lack of effort, but with the scale of the new school and lack of direct outreach from administration rendering it, in her eyes, nearly impossible to get to know the school staff to a meaningful degree.
“We're never going to know them,” she said. “It feels very disconnected.”
Kirsten said these sentiments have all been shared by Westford families new to EMS, even among people who wanted this move and were excited for it, who are now having trouble keeping up with the basketball schedule and considering pulling their kids from the team.
“We all hope that kids are doing well at the school, everybody wants their kids to just be okay and enjoy school, make new friends, blah, blah, blah, all that good stuff,” Kirsten said. “But, parents work very, very hard to make that happen.”
“Crosby is having a fine time,” she said. “He doesn't hate the school. It's not like, ‘Oh my god, this is devastating to our family… But we don't have a voice. We don't matter [in the decision-making process]. Stuff happens to us, and we don't have control over any of it.”
However, not all parents are feeling the stressors Tyler and Valyou Orisko described.
Amber Mellion, a Westford parent, also reached out to the Reporter, noting her son Owen was not interested in being interviewed but that she wanted to share how the transition has gone for her family. Owen is in eighth grade and was part of the WES-to-EMS shift.
“While the timeline initially felt rushed — and it certainly wasn’t what we had signed up for or wanted — I can now say that it has been a very positive experience,” she told the Reporter. “Owen is absolutely thriving. He’s embraced the ‘real middle school’ environment, connected with new peers, and really enjoys the broader range of opportunities.”
“From clubs and school-wide assemblies to field trips and athletics, he’s been engaged and excited to participate,” she added. “He’s also built strong relationships with his core teachers and is doing very well academically, balancing homework and extracurriculars with confidence.”
Mellion noted her younger daughter is still at WES and is also having a great year. The Westford school has offered more opportunities for parents to be present and involved in day-to-day activities, and the family has appreciated the continued sense of community there.
“It is important to us that Westford School remains open to support PreK-5,” she stated.
“I know there’s been a lot of discussion around this transition,” Mellion noted. “And some perspectives have focused on the challenges. But I wanted to be transparent that, for our family, the experience has been overwhelmingly positive. The opportunities, structure and connections have really supported Owen’s growth this year.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here