Vote by mail: How a bill and participation data show potential trend for democracy in Vermont

Posted

MONTPELIER — The first Tuesday in November and the first Tuesday in March were big for Vermont.

In the clutches of a global pandemic and with voter safety in mind, state leaders opted to mail ballots to all voters ahead of the 2020 presidential election. Then in January, Gov. Phil Scott signed into law a bill that allowed municipalities to mail out ballots or change the date for Town Meeting Day, again with the goal of voter safety.

These changes have impacted one facet of elections that could see them become permanent: voter participation.

March 18, the Vermont Senate passed a bill — S. 15 — that, among other things, would require the mailing of ballots to all Vermonters for general elections. Sen. Jeanette White, D-Windham, chair of the Senate Government Operations Committee, said the general election saw 74% turnout with a lower-than-normal 0.5% defective ballot rate.

Most general elections have 50% to 65% participation, she said.

“With the passage of S. 15, Vermont is making a huge step toward increasing voter access,” White said after the bill passed by a 27-3 vote.

Yet there are some who think the bill should go further. When asked about the bill during a press conference Tuesday, Scott said the bill should include mailing ballots for Town Meeting Day and other elections.

“If we’re going to do it for the general election, I’m wondering why not for the other elections that we have,” Scott said.

In an email to Reporter staff, Eric Covey, chief of staff for the Vermont Secretary of State, said the state doesn’t have a list of which towns opted to mail ballots for Town Meeting Day, or which towns that normally have floor meetings switched to Australian ballot. As of March 16, Covey said the state doesn’t have statewide participation numbers from the March 2 vote either.

However, voter participation numbers in throughout the state have a story to tell.

In the Town of Essex, which automatically mailed ballots to all active voters, 7,520 people voted at Town Meeting this year while 6,969 voted in 2020. However, Essex had the highly contentious vote on merging the town and incorporated Village of Essex Junction on the ballot this time around, and 2020 coincided with both the Democratic presidential primary and a highly debated charger change that was on the ballot. For further comparison, just 1,746 people voted on 2019’s Australian ballot which did not include the municipal budget.

In a social media poll inquiring why people were inclined to vote this year, 56% of the 161 respondents chose the “other” option which included an example of always voting if possible. From the remaining respondents who chose one of the other three options -- because of merger, mailed ballots, or both -- 69% said mailed ballots were at least a partial factor.

But Essex voters surely took advantage of being able to mail back or put their ballots in the drop box at the Town Offices in 2021 as 83% of those cast were early or absentee compared to 21% in 2020 and 16% in 2019.

Still, some people chose to go to the polls including Jocelyn Cummings who said outside of Essex High March 2, “It’s the only way to vote. I don’t trust the mail.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here