Vermont Superior Court proceedings open to begin addressing Amazon’s appeal of Essex decision

Posted

ESSEX TOWN — Vermont Superior Court’s Environmental Division began proceedings today for Amazon’s developers’ appeal of the Essex Development Review Board’s decision to reject the company’s application to build a facility in town. 

Monday’s event was the first in what is expected to be a months-long case, and no decisions were made. 

Judge Joseph McLean acknowledged the two related docket items —  an appeal against the DRB’s verbal decision and an appeal of the DRB’s written decision, could be streamlined into one case — to which all parties’ legal representation were agreeable to. 

The original appellant is Allen Brook Development Inc. and Scannell Properties LLC, the developers who applied to build a facility for Amazon to use as a fulfillment center. It would be the first Amazon facility in the state. 

A cross-appeal was also filed by ACRES, another interested party and local nonprofit recently founded by a group of Essex residents in response to the possibility of a megacorporation setting up shop in Saxon Hill Forest, near neighborhoods and schools. 

The land sought for the Amazon facility is in an area zoned for industrial use. 

ACRES is made up of about thirty Essex residents. The name is an acronym for Alliance of Concerned Residents Envisioning Solutions, a group whose mission is to promote sustainable, responsible development and responsive leadership in town. 

Also present in this conference, in an observational capacity for the time being, was legal representation on behalf of the Town of Essex, Alexandria Gaboury. Individuals Georgianna and Sam Tatro also entered an appearance but have not hired legal representation. 

McLean offered a disclaimer that before becoming a judge, he worked for some time at a small, private law firm in Burlington with Georgianna Tatro for almost 20 years, and have maintained a very friendly relationship, though he hasn’t seen her or Sam in about 10 years since Georgianna retired from the firm. 

“I think it goes without saying that I believe that I can be impartial,” McLean said. “But I wanted to ensure that all the parties in this case are aware of that, and certainly I am willing to answer questions, if, if anyone has questions.” 

“I am more than happy to provide the parties with an opportunity outside of the context of this conference to think about the court's disclosure, discuss it with your clients, and decide whether or not you want to file a motion for disqualification on the basis of the disclosure,” he added. 

Attorney Jim Dumont, on behalf of ACRES, had also filed an anticipatory motion, requesting some additional time to file a motion to intervene, should the original appellants, Amazon’s contracted developers, challenge the neighbors’ standing as “interested persons.” 

No such challenge has been filed to date, but Dumont clarified he filed it out of an abundance of caution, in the event that such a situation might arise months from now if and when there’s a ruling — because the rules are such that the motion to intervene in dismissal has to be “timely.” 

Dumont’s request was to have 30 days for an intervention in the event of such a challenge. 

McLean chose to hold the motion in advance, and proposed for now, that Dumont talk with the other parties’ attorneys, Matthew Byrne and Jeff Polubinsky, in an effort to sort out an understanding around the subject in advance. 

Next, all parties involved will also have to come to an agreement about the schedule and its terms for proceedings, with precise deadlines for document requests, depositions, filing any other pre-trial motions and establishing the trial date. 

McLean also asked all parties to familiarize themselves with the court’s guidelines. The schedule for proceedings leading up to the trial itself will be agreed on by a deadline of Nov. 3, though Byrne expressed on behalf of his clients’ interest in requesting the information they need from ACRES as soon as possible. 

“This is going to be a case we’re going to try,” Byrne said. “The court mentioned mediation, we're happy to participate in mediation if Mr. Dumont thinks his clients would benefit from that. But I'll leave that to him. That's our general view on things.” 

Mediation is a voluntary, non-binding process in which an impartial third party helps disputing parties, like ACRES and Amazon’s developer, reach a mutually acceptable agreement on the issue or around certain aspects of the issue outside of a court setting, facilitating communication before or instead of formal litigation. 

In this case, litigation is expected regardless, according to Byrne. 

Dumont also noted in this application, it’s inevitable there will be an Act 250 permit for this project — but that the developers’ Act 250 application has yet to be filed. 

“I know there's no rule that requires that the zoning and Act 250 trials occur at the same time,” he said. “But we all know it saves a lot of time and money. So that’s an issue I wanted the court to be aware of.” 

McLean said ultimately, the sequencing is largely a matter of applicant discretion, and mentioned there can be any number of reasons why an applicant might want to pursue one application and then the next, which is outside the court’s control. 

Dumont also mentioned it will be very difficult for his party to answer many questions from the other party until they have more information from the applicant, the original appellant — because, in this case, the DRB at the municipal level decided the applicant had not submitted sufficient information to be considered, ACRES needs more data from the developers. 

“There's no legal reason to object to the applicant's propounding discovery now,” he said. “But in the context of this case, it's inevitable that answers we provide within 30 days are going to be a formality until we obtain discovery from the applicant. We'll cross that bridge when we get there.” 

McLean said the court won’t be commenting on that, beyond encouraging the parties to speak to each other about a reasonable exchange of information and the timing of the exchange. 

“We will look for a proposed, stipulated scheduling order by Nov. 3,” he reiterated. “And go from there… Again, I, as always, encourage the parties to talk to each other and resolve, by agreement, as many issues as possible — and whatever remains the court will take up.” 

Stay tuned for further coverage of this case down the line.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here