ESSEX JUNCTION — The new apartment building on 197 Pearl Street was required to seal off its fifth floor after contractor Gabe Handy strayed from the approved plans.
The City only allows four-story buildings, but officials decided against having Handy remove the extra floor, as doing so would have delayed housing accommodations during an already pinched real estate market.
The fifth floor only belonged to one apartment unit, which still has its first floor, meaning no housing was lost when the floor was sealed up.
The plans for this building were approved before City Manager Regina Mahony and community development director Chris Yuen started their positions, while the City was still in a transition period.
The extra floor was added to the corner of the building that was approved to be taller than all other parts of the building—most likely a design choice, Mahony said, so the building isn’t just one flat rectangle.
“I'm assuming that's what he was thinking. But I don't I don't know for sure,” Mahony said.
The building was not approved to have five stories, which goes against the City’s land development code.
In an interview with the Reporter, Handy denied having done any work that was unapproved, saying he always intended to close off the extra floor he built—the floor the City required be sealed.
“This is no different than the building up in the Five Corners,” Handy said “If you look at it from the road, it's a five-story building, but actually when you go inside, it's only four and a mezzanine. So this is no different.”
The tell-tale sign that the building has more floors than are allowed are its fourth row of windows. Handy said he added the windows to make it blend in with the rest of the building.
Yuen said every development in the City is subjected to the municipality’s zoning laws, and when 197 Pearl Street was approved, a fifth story was not allowed by the LDC.
“The building at Five Corners was permitted under a Land Development Code that included the option for a height waiver; this option was removed from the Land Development Code before 197 Pearl Street was approved. In the end, there was no mezzanine at 197 Pearl Street because the space up there was sealed off and was never finished,” Yuen said.
While there is an additional story, the height of the building does not exceed the zoning regulations, which is why City staff did not notice the violation until all of the windows were installed in the building.
So why close off the floor if the building meets the LDC’s height requirements?
“The LDC is very, very clear. It is a maximum of four stories,” Mahony said.
Mahony, who was not on staff when this part of the LDC was written, said she believes the number of stories allowed versus the building height allowed was written in a way that incentivizes pitched roofs, as opposed to flat roofs.
“Typically, if you were to look at zoning regulations all across the board, if you see that discrepancy between the amount of stories allowed, versus the height of the building, and if there's some discrepancy between what those would typically do, it's probably because the community is trying to incentivize a pitched roof,” Mahony said.
Yuen added that the story limit and the height limit may not have been added to the LDC at the same time.
“Some communities start with one or the other and then realize, ‘oh, we're getting results that we were not expecting,’ so then the other part comes in,” Yuen said.
S.100, the recent state housing bill, requires municipalities to allow for a bonus floor in buildings that qualify as affordable housing, but 197 Pearl Street does not fall into this exception.
This is the first time Mahony or Yuen have come across an issue like this. Handy will face no additional fines and his company will not be subjected to different approval processes for any future buildings in the City.
“I think there is a natural kind of financial consequence for the developer when things like this happen,” Yuen said. “I don't think this was intentional on their end to break the rules. But in the end, they spent money on something that couldn't create the economic value that they wanted to.”
Yuen said the unapproved floor was most likely added because the contractor was required to add sprinklers to the space and Handy decided making it into usable space made sense.
Had the City required the fifth floor be removed, there would have been delayed housing for those planning on living in the building, which was not something the City wanted when the state of Vermont is facing a housing crisis.
Going forward, now that the City staff is more established, staff will be performing more routine checks on new developments.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here