Village officials are working to trim a tax rate increase of more than 4 percent in the proposed fiscal year 2020 budget after a plan to shift expenses into the town flopped.
Trustees began their budget process with a general fund increase of 4.8 percent in a proposal that would have raised the tax rate by only 1.2 percent, thanks in large part to the town picking up the annual transfer into the village’s rolling stock fund of about $235,000.
But while a majority of the selectboard supported the concept, members said they don’t believe now is the right time to make the change given impending merger talks. So the village must now decide whether to eat the increase or find other places to trim.
The trustees started their meeting last week facing down a proposal with a tax rate bump of 4.45 percent. Staff offered some modest ways to save, including transferring $11,000 from the fund balance to cover fees for the merger attorney, delaying the start of a cleaning contract for Essex Jct. Parks and Recreation to save about $10,000 and trimming funding for village community events by $1,000. That would lower the tax rate increase to 4 percent even.
In lieu of further cuts, however, staff said the only other way to reduce increase is to secure more revenue. That’s where the town comes in. Macy said the village could get the increase down further – to 2.83 percent – if the town contributes an additional $50,000, roughly half the salary and benefits of the unified clerk position.
For the last several years, the village has paid the clerk’s salary while the town has picked up the office’s two assistants. That fact surprised village president George Tyler, who saw the transfer as “reasonable” and “equitable” but added, “You can’t disguise the fact that it has a political component to it.”
The timing of it all could complicate matters.
The town approves its budget in March, while the village does so a month later. Tyler said the village needs to finalize its proposal prior to Town Meeting Day, setting a scenario in which residents could vote to remove the additional $50,000 and leave a gap in the budget.
Officials have stressed that while voters can add or remove money from the budget from the floor, the municipalities aren’t legally obligated to distribute that money toward any specific line item. Because the trustees would have already legally warned their budget, however, the town would likely have to eat the cost and find a way to patch the hole in its own budget, Tyler said.
“It’s like a constitutional crisis would occur,” he said.
On Monday night, the selectboard agreed to include the $50,000 in its final budget proposal. But the scenario illustrates the ever-growing complexity of the relationship between the town and village as a result of ongoing consolidation efforts, further entangling the two municipalities through a series of temporary agreements and trust.
It’s also why some, like trustee Lori Houghton, continue to stress the next step must be addressing governance. “If we keep moving money back and forth, someone might eventually stand up and say no,” she said.
Municipal manager Evan Teich, in his first budget cycle here, said the move would just be another in the spirit of shared services and cooperation. Plus, he said, the two municipalities have transferred larger sums of money without much backlash.
“If this year is another step in that direction, we will all find out at the town meeting where the public stands,” he said.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here