Town Selectboard to host forums later this summer for community to share vision for Town of Essex

Posted

ESSEX — The Essex Selectboard fell into what member Tracey Delphia calls “analysis paralysis” during its regular meeting on July 12.

The board spent much of Monday night discussing how to host public forums on the Town’s future later this summer.

“I would not be in favor of letting this languish,” Delphia said. “I call it analysis paralysis if we have a discussion about having a discussion to have the discussion. I would be fine with approving this now to get that scheduling going.”

At the June 21 Selectboard meeting, members approved holding facilitated public forums later this summer to hear from residents on the future of governance in Essex, particularly in regard to the Village’s separation effort.

“Listening to the public in different formats and different places is what’s important,” Unified Manager Evan Teich said.

The forums, which in total cost $3,000, will be facilitated by Jen Knauer, who teaches graduate courses in mediation and conflict management at Champlain College.

Deputy Manager Greg Duggan said as staff and Knauer began planning the forums, it was agreed that residents will be better able to provide feedback if they have plans to react to.

To that end, staff provided the Selectboard with a broad plan for the Town of Essex, should an independent City of Essex Junction be created with approval from the Vermont Legislature.

The plan includes three phases: interim, transition and long-term.

The interim phase includes now through a potential legislative decision, which would come no sooner than February 2022 and only if Village residents approve the new charter the board of trustees in creating.

The transition phase encompasses the period from a potential legislative approval to a City of Essex Junction effective date. During this phase, the Town of Essex would need to decide how to make up for a 42% loss in its tax base.

“[We need to know, if the separation process] is successful, what does the Town look like? What do you want it to look like and what are we going to do about the monetary change?” Teich said.

Possibilities up for discussion at the public forums could include: an increase in property taxes, the implementation of a local options tax or the raising of recreation and development fees.

The long-term phase starts at the effective date of an independent City of Essex Junction and extends into the future.

By the meeting’s end, the board decided the upcoming public forums should only ask for community thoughts on the interim and transition phases, because too much of the future is unknown to discuss long-term plans.

Some community members present at the meeting, like Betsy Dunn, helped the Selectboard come to this conclusion.

“I think the Town needs to come out and talk about our vision of who we are,” she said.

Barbara Higgins, a former Selectboard member, cautioned the board about thinking of separation as a done deal. She thought it unnecessary to ask for so much community input before the Village votes on its new charter.

“It seems to me we are jumping ahead of ourselves,” she said. “I know you feel like there’s not enough time, but there’s really plenty of time once there’s a vote to decide whether or not you need to do some of these things. If you want to inform people about what this community might look like separated, that’s fine and dandy, but asking about something we don’t know is going to happen — I think you are wasting a lot of people’s time and creating a lot of anxiety that’s unnecessary.”

Selectboard member Vince Franco on the other hand thinks it important to prepare now for both scenarios: the continuation of the status quo or a complete separation.

“I personally think we are doing a disservice to everyone who lives in the Town, especially the TOV, if we don’t plan for whatever happens, success or fail,” he said. “We need to at least get information on what we as a board should be doing for both outcomes.”

Franco used an analogy to further his point:

“We can talk about if an asteroid is going to hit us or not, but I still want to be building rockets that can go up and move it out of the way, whether I know it's going to hit me or not.”

All of these comments concluded in the board giving Town staff the go-ahead to work with Knauer to plan forums that ask for feedback on the interim and transition plans, and that leave time for open-ended ideas and imaginings.

“This is a discussion starting point,” Selectboard Chair Andy Watts said. “I for one fully intend to listen to everything and take it to heart and consider it.”

The dates, times and locations of the public forums are still to be determined, thought Duggan said they would take place later this summer.

#ernltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here