Town residents oppose rec district proposal

Posted

By Jason Starr

The multi-year undertaking to combine Essex Town and Essex Jct. municipal departments and school districts didn’t have so much as a whiff of public pushback until Monday, when a plan to unify parks and recreation was unveiled.

A study committee appointed by the Essex Selectboard and Essex Jct. Board of Trustees recommended unifying the two departments into an independent municipal district with its own taxing and budgeting authority. A town-wide special vote is scheduled December 13 on the matter.

Previous unifications have occurred over the past two years — stormwater management, public works, tax collection and finance — by incorporating both municipal departments into the town’s budget. Voters also approved a plan last year to consolidate the school districts into one by the end of the next school year. The town and village are also in talks to combine planning commissions and zoning boards.

But the creation of new taxing entity for parks and recreation is a different strategy drawing fire from a group of Essex Town residents. They panned the idea at Monday’s selectboard meeting, saying a new town-wide municipality will add a layer of bureaucracy with unknown property tax implications.

According to the committee’s recommendation, “Essex Community Parks and Recreation,” as it will be called, will be governed by a five-member elected board with annual budgets voted by ballot along with school budgets each April.

Resident Barbara Higgins argued the selectboard abdicated its authority by allowing the committee to set a town-wide vote on the issue. The town’s attorney, Andrew Bolduc, ensured the committee is following procedures under state law to set up an independent municipal district.

“The selectboard has a responsibility to decide whether to move forward,” Higgins said. “It’s not a loose-knit study committee’s decision.”

Selectboard member Irene Wrenner agreed the committee overstepped its original charge to “study” the issue.

“We did not choose to create a district,” she said. “We formed a study committee … [We] didn’t request a recommendation to which our hands would be tied.”

The governing boards voted in February to create the committee. Selectboard chairman Max Levy acknowledged Monday the board planned it as advisory.

Board member Andy Watts said during the committee’s decision to form an independent rec district and draft bylaws, it became clear the process would be out of the selectboard’s control.

“The information was provided to us that if the committee voted to form a municipality, then the selectboard would no longer have a say whether the proposal is approved,” Watts said. “It was clear the committee could go in that direction and make the [decision] they did.”

Village president George Tyler urged elected officials not to get hung up on process and control. He said the independent district would give the community more oversight, responsiveness and access to programming.

It would also solve the taxing imbalance inherent in the current set-up, he said. Of the roughly $1.5 million town and village taxpayers pay into two departments, he said, village residents pay roughly two-thirds.

That inequity has underpinned previous failed efforts at comprehensive mergers of the two overlapping municipalities.

“I’ve heard all the old village and town arguments,” Tyler said. “That belongs in the 20th century. In 2016, I urge all of us to come together and solve this problem as grown ups for the good of the community.

“There is no expectation from people in the village that they will see some sudden tax benefit, so there should be no expectation that people outside the village will see some big tax increase,” he continued.

A public hearing on the proposal is set for 6:30 p.m. this Thursday at Essex Middle School. The final rec governance study committee meeting is scheduled for 6:30 p.m. August 10 at Albert D. Lawton School.

Committee member Betzi Bilodeau said the group will incorporate feedback from the public hearing into its next discussion before adopting a final municipal district agreement.

Public forums are planned in the fall before the December 13 special ballot.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here