ESSEX TOWN — The selectboard unanimously approved a resolution affirming the town’s commitment to fairness, freedom and safety at its meeting Monday night.
Clerk Shannon Jackson read the resolution, which states the people of Essex Town believe in dignity, safety and the worth of every individual in the community, whether resident or visitor, and that acts of discrimination, racial targeting and political violence by institutions or individuals undermines the values of justice and fairness that form the foundation of a free and democratic society.
“Our community has a long tradition of neighborliness, civic responsibility and respect for diverse views,” Jackson read from the text. “The selectboard recognizes that healthy democracy depends on free speech, due process, rule of law and the protection of personal freedoms for all, regardless of race, background or political belief.”
The selectboard acknowledged the right of community members to feel secure, respected and empowered to participate in civic life without fear of intimidation or violence, and affirmed the Vermont Criminal Justice Training Commission's model for fair and impartial policing policy as adopted by the Essex Police Department, disallowing racial profiling and limiting Essex Police Department from assisting in federal immigration and force immigration enforcement activities.
The selectboard reiterated the town’s commitment to its declaration of inclusion, and the town’s commitment to standing firmly against discrimination in all forms, including racial targeting and political violence.
The resolution also encourages all residents, organizations and institutions to engage with one another respectfully and constructively, even when disagreements arise, and commits to fostering a safe and welcoming community where every individual has the opportunity to thrive without fear of prejudice, harassment or harm.
“This resolution shall be entered into the official minutes of the selectboard and shared publicly through the town's communication channels to affirm our community's shared values, adopted by the town of Essex selectboard this twentieth day of October,” Jackson said.
First requested by local residents, this resolution has multiple drafts, and has now come to pass — though not without its hiccups.
Prior to the resolution’s approval, resident Julian Ughetti noted that at the Oct. 6 selectboard meeting, a member of the selectboard — Ethan Lawrence — said the Constitution is written solely for American citizens, without being corrected by other members of the board.
“I want to bring attention to the fact that this is a serious misrepresentation of not only the Constitution, but of U.S. law more broadly,” Ughetti said. “This is particularly concerning for me, coming from a body entrusted with local governance.”
“I would like to underscore that the Constitution and Bill of Rights guarantee fundamental protections to all persons within U.S. jurisdiction, not only citizens,” he added. “This has been upheld by Supreme Court cases numerous times.”
Certain civic privileges like voting or holding elected office are indeed reserved for citizens. Core rights, including freedom of speech, peaceful assembly and due process extend to everyone: citizens, immigrants, international students, undocumented individuals, tourists and beyond.
Ughetti said he supports a previous version of the resolution reiterating the Town of Essex’s commitment to these values. It has since been edited down to, in his opinion, water down the original intentions and clarity of direction of the resolution, with the idea itself having first been proposed by Ughetti and his partner — an immigrant — in light of recent Immigrations and Customs Enforcement activity in violation of the Constitutional rights of community members.
“To strip the resolution of its specific context would weaken his message, reducing it to a vague gesture, when what is needed now is clarity and conviction,” he said. “Symbolic, though the resolution may be, symbolism is only powerful when its meaning is preserved and clear.
“Diluting that clarity with generic language, absent of the context that necessitated it, renders it performative at best, dismissive at worst, and misses the mark of its intended purpose,” he added. “I'm not asking you all to go above and beyond your responsibilities.”
Ughetti said his main request is for the selectboard to meet this moment with the integrity and action required to uphold basic principles of democracy — and to call out and correct false statements when they're made.
Ughetti also took issue with the fact that some of the board members at their last meeting claimed the board shouldn't bother taking this up, because the board is not a political body.
“I will accept that the board is, in theory, non-partisan — but claim that it is not political, I believe is inaccurate,” Ughetti said. “A selectboard, by definition, is a political body elected to make policy decisions that reflect the town's values and protect its residents.”
“So deflecting responsibility to take action under the guise of non-partisan neutrality, in itself, is a political act,” he added. “And doing so would allow partisanship to hide behind inaction, rather than upholding the bipartisan principles upon which our democracy is built.”
Resident Brian Clifford also spoke out in support of the resolution and of the specific inclusion of protections for immigrants, given the uptick in deportations without due process, both state- and nationwide, and to support Ughetti’s interpretation of the Constitution, noting the Fifth Amendment explicitly, inclusively protects all who live in the U.S. and that the 14th Amendment also uses broad language protecting any person on U.S. soil — with equal protection of undocumented immigrants supported by Supreme Court precedent.
Clifford also noted local businesses have fired migrant workers for exercising free speech and participating in “A Day Without Immigrants” earlier this year, an incident he believes underscores the town’s shortcomings and proves more action is needed beyond the declaration of inclusion.
“I just don't think that this is a particularly partisan resolution that we're looking at here,” Clifford said. “It'll protect people waving rainbow flags at the five corners, the same as it will protect people waving Trump flags outside the Grange Hall.”
Town resident, U.S. coast guard veteran and Spanish-speaking immigrant Su Ughetti — married to and business partners with Julian Ughetti — had originally initiated the request for the town to adopt a new resolution on the subject, and had some thoughts to share after seeing the updated version of the proposal that was approved by the selectboard this week.
“The whole reason we're doing this is because I brought this issue out to you all to be considered,” Su Ughetti said. “I definitely think that this is important. I support the resolution, even though I'm not necessarily happy about the language in it, and the lack of teeth.”
“But I still do support this,” Su added. “And I also hope that we still continue to assess the situation that things escalate in this country, because I think you're all aware that they are.”
Su Ughetti also made a point to speak out on another matter of equity.
“Two years ago, this town made a promise of a declaration of inclusion, which, by the way, is in the town plan, which is the most recent one in 2024,” Ughetti said. “We said Essex will be a community where everyone feels a sense of belonging, where equity and access guide every decision we make.
“That declaration was supposed to be our compass, not a plaque that we just dust off once a year.”
Su Ughetti’s comments centered around the planning commission’s reasons for denying a zoning change that would have enabled the state to build a new women’s correctional facility in town. The commission said if there were more solid indications for state-supported bus routes, money for infrastructure and more funding for local first responders, then the commissioners would’ve felt good enough to approve it.
“Those words aren't just about budgets and logistics,” Ughetti said. “They're about comfort, about whose comfort matters enough to justify someone else's confinement. That statement says, in essence, if we're given enough perks, we can feel good about prison — but inclusion isn't about feeling good. Inclusion is about who we are.”
“When comfort becomes the currency of our conscience, we’ve lost the meaning of inclusion,” Ughetti continued. “The women who would have filled that prison are not abstractions. They’re daughters, mothers, survivors, many already marginalized by poverty, disability or systemic bias. Their lives cannot be traded for bus routes or infrastructure upgrades.”
Su Ughetti asked the selectboard and every department head to require standard annual education for all town officials and employees to include robust training on equity, bias and community impact, and requested more information about what current DEI education look looks like, its frequency, its scope, its facilitators, and whether it exists in a meaningful way.
“Understanding how privilege and policy intersect isn't political,” Ughetti said, of the moral health of the town. “It's part of responsible leadership. If we are serious about a declaration of inclusion, then our work must go deeper than ramps and slogans, not as a political gesture, but as professional development.”
Some information about DEI initiatives in the town, Junction and school district is available here.
The iteration of the resolution as just-adopted is available in the selectboard meeting packet.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here