By Colin Flanders
What you need to know for next week’s joint meeting
The subcommittee tasked with exploring governance options between the town and village plans to recommend three potential structures at a joint meeting on April 10.
To help any residents planning to attend that meeting, The Reporter is outlining each option below based on minutes from the subcommittee’s recent meeting. Members of the subcommittee stress these are recommendations, with any final decision requiring approval from both the selectboard and trustees.
Governance structures
- Unified charter: Only the village charter would need to be dissolved to create a unified town charter. But members agreed that dissolving both existing charters and creating an entirely new one to govern the single municipality would be the best option so that neither community feels like they’re being taken over.
- Special district: Under this model, the village charter would be converted into a special district to include all non-essential services – like recreation and libraries – while maintaining the status of village residents as town residents. Members also discussed the potential for a second district that includes just town-outside-the-village residents that could govern their library and recreation department. The subcommittee planned to reach out to merger attorney Dan Richardson with further questions about this model.
- Status quo: The third option is to essentially do nothing. Members said this option will outline the current status of village and town services, and how they’re already interconnected, to help residents understand how the other two options would change the municipalities.
The subcommittee plans to give the boards a ranking system that shows the strengths and weaknesses of its recommended options across a myriad of issues, including how they would impact equal representation, tax equity and public participation.
The full boards can also request to add back in any models that the subcommittee cut out of its proposal. That includes two options discussed at this month’s subcommittee meeting: the city charter model and a complete separation of the two municipalities.
Meeting minutes show the subcommittee threw out the city charter model, which would operate under a mayor/council board structure, because it says the joint boards have heard little input that residents want to become a city. And members decided not to bring the separation model to the joint meeting because the full boards have continually voiced support for consolidation, not divorce.
If the boards do pursue one of the two options that would change governance structures, they will need to also determine what that new governing board looks like. The subcommittee agreed the board should have at most seven members, though five would be ideal, who could sit on a board made up of the following structures:
- At-large membership: Each member would be elected by the entire municipality instead of representing a certain geographical area – akin to how the selectboard is now elected. There was disagreement over whether the at-large model would fairly represent residents, with selectboard member Irene Wrenner arguing that it’s unfair for some residents to be represented by someone who does not live near them.
- Two wards: This model would split the municipality by the two existing boundaries, with each ward electing its own representatives. These officials could potentially make decisions on ward-specific issues while collaborating on town-wide issues, though members were unsure of the legality of such a model. They planned to further research it prior to next month’s meeting. Because this model would result in an even number of officials on the board, the subcommittee briefly discussed some ways to break a tie. One potential remedy would be for the chair to break the tie, while another would be for the motion to die in the event of a split vote. Members said they will look into further options.
- Hybrid model: The final option would look similar to the ward model but add in an at-large member, which could help the board avoid any tied votes barring any absences. The committee noted one drawback to such a structure is that at-large members would need to campaign throughout the community while their counterparts would not.
Following up on a discussion at the last joint meeting, the subcommittee also reaffirmed the goal of putting any potential governance changes up for a vote at the November 2020 presidential election, which would likely ensure the largest turnout.
That means the proposal must be finished by August 2020 to allow for the question to be placed on early voting ballots. Members said finishing their proposal by that April will give them enough time to engage the public with outreach events.
Subcommittee member Elaine Haney recommended seeking a facilitator to help guide the discussions. Staff planned to prepare a request for proposal to be presented at the next joint meeting.
The next joint meeting is scheduled for April 9 at 7 p.m. in the village offices at 2 Lincoln St.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here