CHITTENDEN COUNTY — The State of Vermont is looking at Essex for a new women’s correctional facility.
The Chittenden Regional Correctional Facility in South Burlington has long been eyed for reports of unsanitary living and working conditions. With no room to build a revamped facility at the current location, officials looked outward for a new site to house the state’s only women’s prison.
The Vermont Department of Buildings and General Services and the Department of Corrections have looked at both state and privately-owned land to put the new correctional facility.
What they’ve landed on? Two different, state-owned parcels in Essex.
The Chittenden Regional Correctional Facility is the only women’s correctional facility in the entire state. Over 50 years-old, the facility was never designed to be a women’s facility; it was designed for men.
The conditions at the facility are grim, department of corrections commissioner Nick Deml told the Reporter. Both women who are incarcerated at the facility and staffers have told him of the difficult environment.
“It’s got metal doors, concrete walls, hard floors, everything is loud. Spaces are small and cramped,” Deml said.
Sen. Irene Wrenner (D-Essex Town), the legislative lead for the new correctional facility, told the Reporter that having visited women at CRCF, she’s seen firsthand the poor conditions.
From roofing issues to hard metal surfaces and what she describes as “unbelievable noise,” Wrenner said the space isn’t conducive to creating a connective environment for incarcerated women.
The state is currently spending over $3 million dollars per year on maintenance for the South Burlington facility, and it still has deferred maintenance.
With less than ideal conditions at the South Burlington facility, the state began looking 10 years ago for a replacement. Now, that search has come to a head in Essex.
Starting out, Essex was not targeted by the state in the search for land for a new facility, Deml said. But the state did desire to keep the facility somewhere in Chittenden County, citing a desire to remain near community partners like Turning Point Center and the Community College of Vermont, which the correctional facility partners with regularly.
“If you don’t have those critical masses of people who are in these helping professions…that would be harder,” Wrenner said.
Keeping the facility in Chittenden County would also help women in the facility’s re-entry program remain near employment options, Deml said. The state also wanted to find a location that would limit “the burden of relocation” for current CRCF staff.
The search went from 140 to 25 to four state-owned sites and was eventually pared down to two sites, both in Essex, one near River Road and North Williston Road, and one near Susie Wilson Bypass and Gardenside Lane.
Neither of the sites are in the Town’s flood plan, and neither of the facilities would be visible from a road. Both are about a 20-minute drive from the current South Burlington facility.
The selection of these two parcels was announced in a packed room at an Aug. 1 stakeholder meeting that involved legislative representatives, representatives from South Burlington and state officials.
Both of the sites would require a zoning change, as current Town regulations require state-owned correctional facilities to be located only in a certain district of the town, which neither of the two state-owned parcels for the potential facility are.
Representatives from the state presented their plans for the potential Essex facility at an Aug. 8 Town planning commission meeting.
A facility would follow the mold of a Scandinavian-style correctional facility, which Deml said are looked to as the thought leaders for correctional practices across the globe.
A proposed 120-bed, Scandinavian-style facility would entail comfortable furniture, rounded edges, softer features, wooden details and more natural light brought into the facility.
These types of facilities are “trauma-informed,” Deml said, citing that facilities like the current South Burlington one can cause people to relive past traumas while incarcerated.
“We’re talking about ensuring that the space that people are living in is supportive of their recovery and ability to rehabilitate and move out into the community,” he said.
The state has also sought to model their new facility after Southern Maine Women’s Re-entry Center in Windham, Maine. The minimum security facility has many of those “Scandinavian” hallmarks, from natural light to more outdoor spaces.
As of 2023, a new facility was estimated to cost $70 million, yet the cost is subject to change. The state currently has $15 million squirreled away in capital funds for a new facility.
The search for a new site for the correctional facility has come under fire by different Vermont groups in recent years.
In 2023, the ACLU penned an open letter to state legislators urging them to consider reducing prison populations through “evidence-based reforms” as opposed to the funding of a new correctional facility.
Deml told reporters previously that the ACLU’s alternate strategies don’t capture the reality that more than half of all women incarcerated in Vermont are awaiting trial, and must be held by the department.
More recently, advocacy group FreeHer Vermont has also called on the state to put more funding into education and mental health care for women as opposed to a new correctional facility.
As for the Essex community’s reactions to the potential facility relocation, it’s a bit of a mixed bag.
“This is one Essex Towner who is not worried about having a new, humane facility in Vermont,” Town resident Ann Larson told the Reporter. “Though I don’t know current numbers, in the past most women were incarcerated for non-violent crimes—often committed under pressure from an abusive partner. Many are victims of abuse since childhood and need healing, not punishment and the further trauma of outdated prisons.”
Others don’t have as favorable a view.
Town resident Kyle Scanlon told the Reporter that, in his opinion, it is still unclear what a correctional facility in Essex could do to surrounding property values.
While the state has pointed toward data that shows surrounding property values are generally not affected by correctional facilities, the data is older, having been collected in the 1990s.
Scanlon, who has lived in Essex for 20 years, also cited his worries that the new facility in Essex could be a drain on police resources.
“There is no reason this should be in Essex,” he said. “I do not see any way it will benefit the Essex community, but there’s potential for it to hurt the Essex community.”
But Wrenner pointed out to the Reporter that at the Aug. 1 stakeholder meeting, members of the South Burlington police department and fire department said the facility has not caused problems for their departments.
The state has a preliminary design plan finished for the future correctional facility. If all goes to plan for the state, Deml told the Reporter they hope to have a shovel in the ground within around three years. Construction of the new facility would then take an additional three years to complete.
Wrenner understands Essex residents’ frustrations regarding the dissemination of information about the facility. But its place in Essex is far from a done deal, she said.
“I just look forward to the fact that we have time. No one’s rushing anything, and this is an opportunity that Essex will be able to say ‘yes’ to or ‘no’ to,” she said.
Dustin Bruso, chair of Essex Town’s planning commission, agrees. The commission’s Aug. 8 meeting was the first time the plans for the new facility had been put in front of the group, so discussion around the facility in Essex is still in its infancy.
“There’s been anxiety over a feeling that this is a done deal, and it’s not,” Bruso said. “We have not yet had discussions on the zoning changes themselves. We haven’t had a discussion with the state on what they would be bringing to the table or what the advantages to the Town or community would be or the risks…that’s all still to come.”
The planning commission's Oct. 24 meeting at Essex High School will include a discussion about the zoning change needed for the correctional facility.
Bruso requested for the meeting to be held in a larger room than is typical for planning commission meetings, so that all Essex community members can come out to share their thoughts.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here