State: Fairfax CTE students to stay put

Posted

The Center for Technology in Essex received welcome news Tuesday after the Vermont Board of Education denied a request to reassign students from the Franklin West Supervisory Union to a different service region.

CTE director Bob Travers said the proposal would have meant losing $640,000 in revenue for the state’s largest tech center if passed — just under 8 percent of its operating budget.

This would have inevitably led to teacher layoffs, he said in an interview last week.

The proposal came before the state board after FWSU Superintendent Ned Kirsch requested the change last October. His proposal would have transferred all tech students from BFA-Fairfax to Northwest Technical Center in St. Albans.

School districts in Vermont are assigned to one of 16 technical center service regions; FWSU is currently assigned to Chittenden County, which CTE shares with the Burlington Technical Center.

The state board employs four factors when examining these requests: enrollment, distance traveled, student opportunities and fiscal impacts.

Secretary of Education Rebecca Holcombe recommended the board deny Kirsch’s request because it failed to meet three of these benchmarks, with shorter travel time between high schools and the center the only clear benefit.

Her recommendation echoed that of Deputy Secretary Heather Bouchey, who said the proposal would adversely affect student counts and revenues at BTC and CTE while increasing Northwest’s. She also concluded student opportunity would be limited.

The board concurred with Holcombe and Bouchey, voting 5-1 to deny Kirsch’s request.

Kirsch said Act 46, the landmark education law passed in 2015, largely motivated his request for the reassignment as FWSU looks for more ways to save money.

CTE’s full-day program takes away students from BFA-Fairfax, he added, limiting class sizes and program offerings for those who stay at the high school.

The change would cut travel time for students by up to 2.5 hours for BTC attendees, Kirsch said, and reduce mileage reimbursements for special education services sent to Essex. He estimated the change would save $137,000 annually.

Judith DeNova, superintendent of Chittenden Central Supervisory Union where CTE is located, empathized with Kirsch’s attempt to save money but asked the board to deny the request during “this time of exploration” sparked by Act 46.

The state board’s criteria say tech centers must accommodate changes so other districts don’t have to make up the losses with higher tuitions.

Tech centers’ revenue depends on enrollment, which is reported as full-time equivalents, or FTEs.

Today, 46.83 FTEs from FWSU attend CTE, including students from the towns of Fletcher, Georgia and Fairfax.

Bouchey initially said CTE would lose 22.73 FTEs with the change. Multiplying that by CTE’s $16,750 tuition, she estimated a $380,000 loss of revenue.

Travers felt her assessment didn’t show the whole picture, however.

Students in Fletcher and Georgia, towns without high schools, can choose to attend BFA-Fairfax. Travers said there’s about 10 FTEs who do so and also attend CTE. These students would also be forced to attend Northwest under Kirsch’s request, making the actual loss about 32 FTEs, Travers said.

The cost for each FTE is closer to $20,000 when including about $3,300 per student in state aid.

In testimony to the board on Tuesday, Bouchey revised her data to agree with Travers’ estimate. This would force him to cut at least nine teachers and thereby lose programs or raise tuition and bill sending districts, he said last week.

Kirsch acknowledged CTE would have to cut costs “just as all schools and districts must do” but said the impact would be “negligible,” as 83 percent of CTE’s enrollment comes from outside FWSU. CTE would recoup lost students through Essex’s merger with Westford, he added.

Travers and DeNova refuted this claim in a December letter to the AOE, arguing Essex High School will likely gain only 20 Westford students once choice is phased out; of those, only up to three would likely attend CTE.

Bouchey sided with DeNova and Travers, saying the change would negatively affect both Burlington and Essex’s enrollment while increasing Northwest’s by 35 students.

Tuition is paid based on a six-semester average of enrollment, or three years’ worth of data, so it would be paid incrementally over the next three years. Northwest wouldn’t fully yield tuition for all 35 students until fiscal year 2020.

DeNova and Travers questioned if Northwest could handle this influx while not receiving any funding during the transition’s first year.

“We are concerned that FWSU or NWTC may not understand the full impact of these funding implications,” they wrote.

Leeann Wright, director of Northwest Technical Center, and Kevin Dirth, superintendent of Franklin Central Supervisory Union, where Northwest Tech is located, responded to these “erroneous conclusions” in a letter.

They wrote Northwest Tech is fully aware of and prepared for the delay, and Wright affirmed this Tuesday at the meeting.

Northwest is opening a new program and expanding popular ones to further accommodate more students, Kirsch added.

He also disagreed with Bouchey’s assessment on student opportunity, arguing students can attend tech centers outside the service region if their assigned one doesn’t offer their desired program. For example, Northwest doesn’t offer agribusiness or dental assisting, so students could attend Cold Hollow Career Center in Enosburg and CTE, respectively, Kirsch said.

Yet Bouchey wrote there’s a “real likelihood” programs unique to BTC and CTE wouldn’t exist after both centers cut programs to make up for the decline in enrollment.

Prior to voting, members of the board commended the testimony from both sides.

“This is one of the most challenging votes that I’m going to be putting forth,” board member Mark Perrin said.

In an interview following the decision, Kirsch admitted he’s still confused about the state board’s criteria.

“I felt like we met the standard,” he said, adding FWSU will continue exploring the best option for the town of Fairfax and its students.

“In the long run, the decision subjugates Fairfax students to longer bus rides and the high school less access to students,” he said.

Even so, he felt the three tech centers involved all have great programs.

“The kids win either way,” he said.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here